Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
As women earn an increasing share of college degrees, what happens to the labor market value of degrees from institutions where women predominate? The author investigates how the gender composition of degree-granting institutions, termed college feminization , shapes job applicant evaluations in the entry-level labor market. Using an original 2 × 2 national survey experiment ( n = 637), participants evaluated job applicants who graduated from either a majority-women or majority-men college, holding all other qualifications constant. The results show no evidence that degrees from majority-women institutions are devalued relative to those from majority-men institutions. However, college feminization leads male applicants to be evaluated less favorably in interview recommendations. Perceived competence helps explain this gendered penalty but not through a direct downgrading of male applicants’ competence. Instead, competence operates indirectly through a shifting standards process, whereby competence is weighted more heavily when evaluating male applicants from feminized colleges. This pattern suggests that men from feminized institutions are not rated as less competent, but competence is applied more stringently when determining who is interview worthy. These findings suggest that college feminization can disrupt advantages historically extended to men and reconfigure inequality, offering a novel mechanism through which men’s structural advantage is recalibrated in contemporary labor markets.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Amanda Mireles (2025) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: