Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
With rising geopolitical tensions and rapid technological change, NATO states pledged 5% of GDP for defence by 2035, spurring major growth in defence innovation investment. This paper investigates the discursive strategies used to justify such investments by applying qualitative content analysis to 100 text fragments from government documents, academic publications, intergovernmental reports, and contributions by civil society. The study identifies five dominant meta-categories of investment rationales: Strategic Technological Advantage, Economic and Industrial Policy, Security and Sovereignty, International Relations, and Environmental and Social Responsibility. Technological and economic arguments dominate, security is also important, while international and social arguments are less prominent. The findings reveal clear alliance-specific differences: EU discourse prioritises economic and industrial policy alongside technological advantage, while NATO emphasises security and sovereignty in tandem with technological considerations. Framed within an interpretivist paradigm, the results demonstrate that defence innovation is constructed not only as a reaction to immediate threats but as a proactive instrument for resilience, competitiveness, and institutional legitimacy. This paper contributes to innovation and security studies by offering a comparative framework for analysing justification narratives across document types and alliance affiliations, while also highlighting avenues for further research on their normative and institutional dimensions.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Kondrāts et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: