Genetic Divergence Among Mediterranean and Macaronesian Genera of the Subtribe Chrysantheminae (Asteraceae)

Genetic variation at 17 isozyme loci was used to assess divergence among the four genera comprising subtribe Chrysantheminae (Anthemideae: Asteraceae). The Macaronesian endemic genus Argyranthemum is supported as monophyletic and is about equally divergent at isozyme loci from the other three genera of the Chrysantheminae, Chrysanthemum, Heteranthemis , and Ismelia. Chrysanthemum is native to the Mediterranean whereas Heteranthemis occurs in southern Iberia and Morocco, and Ismelia is endemic to Morocco. The genera Chrysanthemum and Ismelia have a genetic identity of 0.9283, which is comparable to values often seen for congeneric species and indicates that they should be treated as one genus. The isozyme data indicate that three lines consisting of Argyranthemum, Chrysanthemum‐Ismelia , and Heteranthemis radiated rapidly from a common ancestor. Divergence times estimated from isozyme data suggest that the initial radiation of the three lines occurred 2.5–3.0 mya. If this is so, then Argyranthemum or its ancestor arrived in Macaronesia after all the islands except La Palma and El Hierro were formed. The evolutionary history of the subtribe is discussed in relation to the climatic and geological events that took place in the Western Mediterranean between the Tertiary and Quaternary, i.e., the first Northern Hemisphere glaciation and desertification of the Sahara region. The high mean genetic identities between species of Argyranthemum suggest that it might have subsequently undergone a second more recent radiation in the Macaronesian Islands. Also, the high mean identity (0.860) between populations in Chrysanthemum and Ismelia suggest that these continental genera might be in the early stages of secondary speciation.