Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Given the much anticipated increase in the number of older adults who will be coming to our clinics for assessment and treatment, it is imperative for the profession of audiology to address the unique needs of this population. One critical area of concern is the need for audiologists to be knowledgeable about age-related cognitive changes that may affect hearing assessment and rehabilitative approaches. This article focuses on older adults who have abnormal age-related changes in cognition and it provides clinical practice guidelines related to hearing rehabilitation for this unique and challenging patient population. CLINICALLY SIGNIFICANT COGNITIVE IMPAIRMENT Similar to hearing loss, cognitive impairment is characterized by various degrees of disorder, from mild cognitive impairment (MCI) to dementia. MCI is commonly defined as a subtle but measurable memory disorder characterized by memory impairment, normal general cognitive functioning, intact activities of daily living (ADL), and no dementia. A number of conditions may be associated with MCI, including early Alzheimer's disease, stroke, brain injury, brain tumors, central nervous system infections, major surgery such as open-heart surgery, and abusive use of alcohol or other drugs.1 A person with MCI experiences problems greater than normally expected with aging, but typically does not manifest symptoms associated with dementia, such as impaired judgment or reasoning. Diagnosis of MCI typically involves a family physician or geriatrician, who obtains the patient's medical history with a detailed description of the problems presented by the patient. A physical examination by the physician can also help determine the possible illnesses and other health conditions such as those mentioned above, particularly those that may be treatable. Computed tomography (CT) scan, magnetic resonance imaging (MRI), blood tests, and spinal taps may be conducted to identify possible causes of MCI. An important part of the MCI diagnostic procedure is neuropsychological testing, using evaluation tools to identify cognition and memory. Information about these tests may be available in health records or in the background provided in letters of referral. While there is a large body of information about Alzheimer's disease (AD), research on MCI is at a relatively early stage. MCI is defined by, and is widely viewed as, a transitional syndrome between normal cognitive function and dementia.2 It is estimated that approximately 3% to 19% of adults 65 years and older have some degree of MCI.3 Some people with MCI appear to remain stable or, in some cases, even return to normal after a period of time. However, more than half progress to dementia within 5 years.3 Dementia may range from mild to severe and, in contrast to MCI, is characterized by severe compromises in independent functioning. Patients with AD may be severely compromised by dementia-related cognitive deficits such as memory loss, as well as difficulty with multi-dimensional cognitive tasks necessary for independent living, including driving, preparing meals, and managing self-care such as personal finances, health care, and medications.4 Other warning signs described by the Alzheimer's Association (www.alz.org) include word-finding difficulties, time and place disorientation, difficulty with abstract thinking, changes in mood, behavior, and personality, as well as decreased judgment and initiative. SCREENING FOR COGNITIVE IMPAIRMENT There are a number of options for screening for mild cognitive impairment and dementia. One of the most commonly administered clinical screening tests of cognitive function is the Mini-Mental State Exam (MMSE).5 A total score of less than 23 on this 30-item test suggests impairment in cognitive function. The MMSE, which has been shown to have high sensitivity and specificity, is normed according to education level and age. Although it is useful as a clinical screening tool to detect impairment, it is not sensitive to individual differences in cognitive performance that can affect communication in a healthy older population (see Pichora Fuller in this issue). Some cognitive screeners can be administered via telephone, such as the Telephone Interview for Cognitive Status-modified,7 although the examiner must know if the patient being screened has a hearing loss. However, there is some research to show that hearing impairment is not an obstacle to administering the TICs-m.8 Nevertheless, it is of critical importance for professionals to ensure that hearing impairment is not a confounding factor in cognitive test results. Weinstein and Amsel showed that hearing loss can present symptoms similar to those of dementia.9 When an older patient with a hearing loss responds inappropriately to an item on a cognitive measure, it may be due to hearing loss, cognitive compromises, or a combination of the two. Weinstein and Amsel compared the performance of institutionalized elders on the Short Portable Mental Status Questionnaire,10 with and without use of an auditory trainer. Close to half of the patients with moderate hearing losses and all of the patients with severe losses showed clinically significant improvements in cognitive test results when test questions were presented with amplification. Thus, any older adult suspected of having a hearing loss should be tested in an amplified condition during cognitive measures. In my clinical experience, sound devices such as the Pocket-Talker® or Sound Wizard® can be quite useful in this regard. They are relatively easy for other health professionals to use when tests are being administered. CAPD may precede impairment Several research studies have shown that central auditory processing (CAP) disorders in older adults may be a precursor of cognitive impairment, including AD. For example, Gates and co-authors found that very poor performance on the Synthetic Sentence Identification with Ipsilateral Competing Message (SSI-ICM) test preceded the diagnosis of AD by several years, and thus might serve as an early screening test for cognitive disorders in older adults. The authors speculated that early identification of dementia via CAP tests such as the SSI-ICM might become even more relevant as new therapies for AD are found. In more recent research, Gates et al. found that CAP function was significantly poorer even with mild impairment, particularly for the Dichotic Sentence Identification test (free report mode).12 Thus, it is important to establish a routine of conducting CAP testing with older adults, not only to determine auditory rehabilitation needs, but also for early identification of possible cognitive loss. Finally, Vaughan and her co-authors conducted research to determine potential cognitive tests for use with older adults in audiology clinics.13 Various neuro-cognitive tests were compared to determine which would be most strongly associated with speech-recognition performance. Vaughn et al. chose the Letter-Number Sequencing (LNS) subtest of the Wechsler Abbreviated Scale of Intelligence©-III as the best cognitive measure for determining if an older adult has cognitive aging changes that might contribute to reduced speech understanding. The LNS requires the examinee to listen to a string of letters and numbers presented in random order and then to sort the numbers and letters in ascending and alphabetical order. The LNS is relatively easy and quick to administer (approximately 10 minutes) and may help the audiologist diagnose speech-perception difficulties and develop an appropriate treatment plan. TREATMENT OPTIONS FOR COGNITIVE IMPAIRMENT Neuropsychologists and other healthcare providers are exploring a number of intervention options for MCI and AD. According to the Alzheimer's Association web site (www.alz.org), the standard treatments for cognitive disorders address cognitive symptoms that affect memory, language, judgment, planning, attention, and other thought processes, as well as behavioral and psychiatric symptoms. The predominant treatment for AD involves pharmaceutical attempts to delay the worsening of the symptoms associated with the disease. For persons with AD and MCI, computer-based cognitive training may improve everyday functioning, although much more research is needed in this area.14 Increasingly interventions are being used to assist older adults with MCI to maintain an active lifestyle. These include programs focused on cognitive engagement, social interaction, and physical exercise, with the expectation that these “use it or lose it” interventions may slow the rate of cognitive decline.15 Clearly, the patient's ability to hear and communicate is important to the success of such interventions. CONSIDERATIONS FOR H-I PATIENTS WITH MCI How prevalent is hearing loss in persons with dementia and mild cognitive impairments? Not surprisingly, given the effects of age on both cognitive status and hearing abilities, hearing loss is common among older adults with cognitive disorders. In fact, several studies have shown that the majority of individuals with cognitive disorders also have significant hearing losses.16,17 Using both pure-tone audiometry screening and hearing status questionnaires, Gold et al. found that 49 out of 52 patients with AD or other forms of cognitive impairment also had significant degrees of hearing loss.16 For research participants with suspected AD, the authors noted a significant discrepancy between the patient's self-report of hearing loss and that of their caregivers, whereas research participants with MCI were more reliable with their self-reports. Indeed, persons with cognitive impairment may be less able to understand their own health conditions. It is recommended that a hearing evaluation be part of any assessment of cognitive function—a suggestion audiologists should advocate to other health professionals. Some audiologists may question if the hearing of AD patients can be tested given their severely compromised mental abilities. However, Durrant and colleagues documented that patients with-moderate to severe AD can reliably participate in audiometric procedures, especially if they are encouraged throughout the testing.18 But the authors also found that even though patients with AD can be successfully tested, they rarely receive treatment for their hearing losses. Because cognitive impairment reduces patients' ability to remember what to do and their ability to initiate behaviors, it will be important during both testing and treatment to provide frequent prompts and reminders to sustain target behaviors. TREATMENT OPTIONS Palmer and her co-authors listed five major barriers to management of hearing loss in patients with AD: lack of medical referral, difficult-to-test stereotype, lack of efficacy data, inappropriate technology, and lack of access to ongoing care.19 These authors described a comprehensive hearing aid fitting program provided to an older adult with AD and his wife. Among the features of the fitting program were multiple visits to the patient's home pre- and post-fitting, use of the Hearing Handicap Inventory for the Elderly20 to determine treatment effectiveness, selection of a hearing aid with adaptive compression, spousal instruction on care and use of the hearing aid, and daily tracking by the spouse of hearing aid use and its effects on the user. What were the results of this comprehensive approach to meeting the hearing needs of the older adult with AD? As reported by his wife, her husband could hear normal household sounds such as the furnace, the television no longer blared, she no longer had to raise her voice, and he derived greater enjoyment from going to church and was more interested in conversing with other people, all of which undoubtedly boosted quality of life for both the patient and his wife. In a subsequent study, Palmer et al. demonstrated how unconventional measurement of outcomes can assist in determining the success of hearing aid fitting.21 The researchers obtained valid audiometric data (otoscopy, pure-tone air- and bone-conduction thresholds, and immittance screening) for the eight research participants, who all lived at home and had been diagnosed with AD. They then provided amplification to these eight individuals, and assessed the outcomes. To determine treatment efficacy, they asked the patients' caregivers (either a spouse or a child) to list problem behaviors (e.g., repetitive questioning, arguments, and disturbance of activities) that they perceived as being related to the patients' hearing difficulties. According to their caregivers, the patients wore their hearing aids from 5 to 15 hours a day, and one to four problem behaviors were significantly reduced for each of the patients. Seven of the eight caregivers showed clinically significant improvements in their perception of their spouse's or parent's hearing handicap. Caregivers' comments also provided compelling evidence as to the success of the hearing aid fittings. For example, many reported that patients requested that their hearing aids be placed in their ears and that the patients were easier to engage in conversation, generally more alert, and more aware of background noises such as doorbells, microwave oven signals, etc. Being able to hear these everyday sounds may help individuals with AD feel less isolated and more in touch with their environment. The two patients with the more severe cases of AD showed the least benefit from hearing aid use. Overall the authors' findings are encouraging, and provide some degree of assurance that patients with AD can use hearing aids successfully and will likely benefit from them. FINAL NOTE Both cognitive impairment and significant sensorineural hearing loss are found primarily among older adults. Therefore, it is critical that audiologists make other healthcare providers aware of the negative effects of untreated hearing loss on older adults. Lack of awareness that many symptoms of hearing loss are identical or similar to some symptoms of cognitive disorders may lead providers to erroneously identify cognitive issues in older patients whose actual problem is hearing impairment. Or they may be misled into thinking that patients have more severe cognitive impairments than they really do. Worse still, failing to address hearing loss could accelerate the symptoms of cognitive decline. The profession of audiology, perhaps in conjunction with the Hearing Loss Association of America, should increase its efforts to promulgate the need to determine if hearing loss is a factor when older adults exhibit troubling behaviors such as confusion, inappropriate responses, and withdrawal from friends and family. These types of behavior are common in older adults with hearing loss and may lead families and healthcare practitioners to mistakenly assume that cognitive impairment is responsible for all of these problem behaviors.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Patricia B. Kricos (2009) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: