Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Hayes D, Hartsock JA, Latimore J, Elgin E. 2026. Application of occupancy models to aquatic macrophyte data collected via rake-based point-intercept sampling. Lake Reserv Manag. XXX–XXX.Aquatic macrophytes are often surveyed with a double-sided rake using a point-intercept design. Rakes are not completely efficient at capturing aquatic macrophytes, and do not capture all taxa with equal efficiency. As such, estimates of frequency of occurrence are biased low due to incomplete detectability. We evaluated a protocol using 2 rake tosses per sampling point and applied a suite of occupancy models to data on the capture of common taxa in 78 lakes in northern Michigan, USA. A model allowing occupancy and detectability to vary freely among lakes fit best for most taxa but led to untenable estimates in lakes where macrophyte occurrence was low. A model allowing occupancy to vary freely but assuming a constant detectability among lakes fit well for many species and provided more reasonable estimates. For species that occurred in 20 or more lakes, detectability based on 2 rake tosses averaged 0.47 and ranged from 0.20 to 0.77. Depth was an important covariate for the occurrence of aquatic macrophytes. For example, applying a logistic regression to slender naiad (Najas flexilis) using depth and depth2 produced high fit scores for data pooled from all lakes. However, a model allowing for lake-specific depth distributions (i.e., including a lake × depth interaction term) was substantially better and showed that the depth distribution of this species varied widely among lakes. In summary, 2 or more rake tosses per sample point allow investigators to draw stronger conclusions about the prevalence of macrophytes than taking a single toss per sample point.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Hayes et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: