Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
SUMMARY In July 1974 the Uriarra and Pierces Creek forests near Canberra suffered wind damage unprecedented in severity for Australian radiata pine plantations. The main damage was the uprooting of trees over 30 m tall in a 7 × 11 km area where about 300 ha were almost totally destroyed and a further 250 ha severely damaged. Because the root-balls developed very differently in soils of different depth and drainage, it was not possible to identify sites with mechanically weaker, poorly drained soils as being more prone to windthrow. The severity of windthrow depended on prior felling operations. In stands with trees over 30 m tall which had not been disturbed by recent felling only 0.2 per cent of trees were thrown, but in stands thinned during the preceding 5 years the damage rose progressively to 22 per cent for the most recently thinned compartments. Still greater damage occurred in stands located downwind of recent clearfellings, where the damage intensity rose progressively from 38 per cent in stands not thinned in the preceding 5 years to 88 per cent in stands thinned less than six months previously. Since trees which had grown in relative isolation for many years were superior in windfirmness despite their larger crowns and greater exposure, it is suggested that earlier thinning will improve the stability of stands after the remaining trees have adapted to the greater exposure. Because the trees of a stand were thrown mainly in random sequence and not progressively from an edge, it is concluded that the stability of a stand cannot be secured unless the trees of both the interior and the margins are windfirm. In spite of the facts that more than 100,000 tonnes of merchantable timber were windthrown and salvage took more than a year, little timber was lost through degrade by sapstain or other causes. This was because the thrown trees retained some functioning roots and consequently their foliage and cambium remained alive. The extensive withthrow depended on the coincidence of three conditions: (1) the presence of extensive stands made vulnerable through recent clearfelling upwind or thinning after they had grown to a height of about 30 m, (2) the saturation of soils with water, and (3) the occurrence of prolonged, gusty moderately fast winds with gusts of over 50 km/hr and aggregate wind runs exceeding 800 km in two days or 1200 km in three days. Similar or worse weather conditions have occurred at Canberra 4 or 5 times during the 48 years for which meteorological records are available. Extensive windthrow had, however, not been experienced before 1974 because the extensive vulnerable stands had not then existed.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Cremer et al. (1977) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: