Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Compares yield criteria for predicting residual stresses in anisotropic sheets, indicating preference for anisotropic models in fatigue design.
The selection of an appropriate yield criterion for finite element simulation of deep drawing involves a trade-off between computational efficiency and predictive accuracy. The isotropic von Mises criterion, widely used in preliminary industrial design, neglects the plastic anisotropy inherent in cold-rolled sheet metals. This study presents a systematic, head-to-head comparison of the von Mises and Hill's 1948 anisotropic yield criteria in predicting residual stresses throughout a complete deep-drawing loading-unloading cycle. A two-dimensional axisymmetric finite element model was developed in ANSYS Mechanical APDL employing nine through-thickness elements with the B-bar formulation to prevent volumetric locking. A bilinear kinematic hardening rule captures first-order Bauschinger effects during the bending-unbending sequence over the die radius. The complete forming history is discretized into seven stages, from initial punch contact through progressive drawing to full punch withdrawal, enabling explicit separation of contact stresses from the self-equilibrated residual stress field. Both yield functions are presented with explicit mathematical formulation, coefficient definitions, and discussion of the isotropic limit. A parametric sensitivity study isolates the influence of individual Hill coefficients on the residual stress field, with all perturbations confined within physically admissible ranges derived from published experimental Lankford coefficient datasets for deep-drawing steels. A first-order Sobol' sensitivity index estimation using a response surface metamodel provides quantitative ranking of parameter importance. Model predictions are validated against experimental X-ray diffraction measurements of hoop residual stress from the literature, with the complete through-thickness stress profile compared to published experimental data using quantitative error metrics and statistical hypothesis testing. The spatial distribution of residual stresses is qualitatively similar for both criteria, but Hill's model predicts higher magnitudes, with a maximum increase of 19% in the sidewall. The through-thickness normal anisotropy coefficient, R_zz, demonstrates dominant sensitivity: a ± 20% perturbation confined within the physically representative range produces a 45% variation in peak residual stress, with a first-order Sobol' index of 0.72. The industrial implications are formulated as a decision framework with explicit boundaries of applicability. Benchmark comparison with published NUMISHEET results demonstrates consistency of the observed discrepancy with findings from independent research groups. For qualitative trend analysis, the von Mises criterion remains sufficient; for quantitative predictions required in fatigue design, an anisotropic model with an accurately characterized R_zz value is essential.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Karimi et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: