Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
This article demonstrates the AV model's framework for assessing argument quality in historiography, highlighting biases and failures.
Disputes in the historiography of contested figures frequently stall in a characteristic way: the parties agree about the surviving evidence, disagree about the conclusion, and accuse one another of bias without being able to specify where the reasoning fails. This article sets out a two-axis audit designed to locate that failure precisely. The AV model separates the acceptability of an argument's premises from the validity of the inference drawn from them, and refuses to let either question absorb the other. It specifies five acceptability conditions adapted to historiographical work — independent verifiability, relevance to the inference actually drawn, non-circularity, standard symmetry across comparable cases, and declared metaphysical load — and four recurrent inferential failure modes. Its principal diagnostic claim is that the most influential arguments in modern historical Jesus research fail on the acceptability axis while remaining formally impeccable on the validity axis, so that describing them as "fallacies" misidentifies the defect and makes them look easier to answer than they are. The model is developed against the background of informal-logic accounts of argument appraisal, then applied to six worked cases, one of which is an argument the present author endorses and one of which is a correction of the author's own earlier misdiagnosis. The article closes with the model's limits, the objections it must answer, and the conditions under which its verdicts are themselves falsifiable. This study forms part of The Historical Jesus Under Scrutiny, Volume I of The Jesus of Nazareth Library (Lux Mentis, 2026). Scripture quotations are from the Revised Standard Version of the Bible, Second Catholic Edition (RSV-2CE), copyright © 2006 National Council of the Churches of Christ in the United States of America. Used by permission. All rights reserved.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Jesús Fernández-Pedrera Correa (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: