Key result
Microvascular obstruction and infarct size measured by cardiac magnetic resonance were stronger predictors of the primary outcome than infarct size by SPECT.
Why the study?
Does CMR provide superior prognostic utility compared to SPECT for infarct characterization in acute STEMI patients?
Does CMR provide superior prognostic utility compared to SPECT for infarct characterization in acute STEMI patients?
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
CMR provides superior prognostic utility over SPECT in post-MI patients, primarily due to its ability to detect microvascular obstruction, suggesting it should be the new reference standard.
Nuclear cardiology laboratories provide diagnostic services as part of standard care in many hospitals worldwide. In 2008, a world-wide survey of nuclear cardiology procedures was reported by the Working Group on Nuclear Cardiology for the International Atomic Energy Agency.1 High nuclear cardiology utilization (>1000 procedures/100 000 population) was reported in the USA, Canada, and Israel, and moderate-high utilization (250–999 procedures/100 000) was reported in most Western European countries, Australia, and Japan. Lower utilization rates were reported in other countries in all continents globally (Figure 1).1 Estimates of worldwide utilization (per 100.000 of the population) of nuclear cardiology procedures. Reprinted with permission from Maurizio Dondi, MD, Nuclear Medicine Section, Division of Human Health, International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA). Historically, in many hospitals, radionuclide testing has been the reference diagnostic method for the assessment of infarct size, myocardial viability, and ischaemia after acute myocardial infarction (MI).1–3 In contrast to North American guideline recommendations (see Supplementary data online, Table S1),2,3 recent European guidelines for the management of patients with ST elevation myocardial infarction (STEMI) accord radionuclide testing a more restricted indication and alternative diagnostic modalities have greater prominence.4 The evidence-base for imaging infarct size with Tc99m-Sestamibi-SPECT2,3,5 and late gadolinium enhancement cardiac magnetic resonance (CMR)4,6 are well established. However, the comparative diagnostic accuracy and prognostic significance of infarct size measured by SPECT and CMR are uncertain. Our commentary is stimulated by the publication by Hadamitzky et al.7 who retrospectively analysed 281 acute STEMI patients treated by primary angioplasty who had undergone both Tc99m-Sestamibi-SPECT and CMR on a 1.5 T scanner at a median 5.0 (IQR 4.1–5.9) days post-MI. In multivariable analyses, the strongest predictor for the primary outcome was microvascular obstruction (P < 0.0001), followed by infarct size by CMR (P = 0.0043) and infarct size by SPECT (P = 0.012) (all P-values corrected for clinical risk). However, in a multivariate model including clinical and peri-procedural parameters, microvascular obstruction was the only significant predictor in addition to clinical risk as measured by the GRACE score. In addition to the authors three main conclusions,7 we would add a fourth. Given the prognostic importance of microvascular obstruction revealed by CMR, over-and-above infarct size, CMR has superior diagnostic utility over SPECT for prognostication post-MI. Infarct size varied according to the method of analysis. Compared with SPECT, infarct size with CMR was greater when a ×4 SD threshold was used to discriminate infarct tissue from non-infarct tissue, whereas the amount of infarct size was smaller vs. SPECT when ×5 SD, ×6 SD, or ‘full-width half maximum’ methods were used. Clearly, technical factors underlie these differences. On the one hand, smaller MIs may be missed with SPECT due to limited spatial resolution. On the other hand, with CMR, viable oedematous tissue may be included in the infarct area when a less restrictive approach to CMR image analysis (e.g. ×2 SD) is used. In fact, the size of infarction as revealed by late gadolinium enhancement within the first week post-MI may over-estimate actual infarct size compared with when infarct size is re-assessed 6 months later.8 Therefore, the timing of the scan post-MI and the approach to infarct size measurement should be standardized. Hadamitzky et al.7 also observed that infarct size by CMR using the 6 SD threshold had a stronger relationship with clinical outcomes compared with infarct size by other CMR methods or SPECT. The superior correlation between late enhancement at higher thresholds and health outcomes may be explained by the fact that the restrictive approach provides a more accurate assessment of actual (final) infarct size. This study's results support the adoption of ×5 to ×6 SD difference in infarct zone signal intensity vs. mean signal intensity of the remote zone. Hadamitzky's study has several important and obvious limitations, but these limitations do not outweigh the originality of the data and importance of the paper. Instead, the reader should understand the limitations of the paper and interpret its results accordingly. The limitations are the retrospective nature of the analysis, the selection of patients from clinical trials (which may explain the small median infarct size and low event rates), the slight discordance in time from admission for each test modality (CMR was performed 0.4 days later than SPECT), the exclusion of potentially higher-risk patients with contra-indications to CMR (e.g. renal dysfunction, creatinine clearance <50 mL/min), and incomplete enrolment since only 281 STEMI patients of 1294 STEMI admissions in the two participating hospitals were included in the final analysis. The strengths of the data set are firstly, it uniquely involves SPECT and CMR in a reasonably large cohort of STEMI patients, and such data are unlikely to ever be obtained again in the future. The only other study that describes SPECT and CMR modalities in STEMI patients involved 16 patients.9 Also, the imaging physicians were blinded to the adverse events for the primary outcome, implying ascertainment bias was minimized. Finally, the cardiovascular events in the primary outcome were ‘spontaneous’ and the composite outcome did not include either revascularization or unstable angina, both of which are susceptible to bias. Staff and patient exposure to ionizing radiation has public health importance, which should influence and where appropriate, constrain the provision of medical imaging procedures. The European Union Radioprotection Directive (9743) states in Article 3 that ‘existing types of practices involving medical exposure (to ionising radiation) may be reviewed whenever new, important evidence about their efficacy or consequences is acquired’.10 In line with this directive, we believe that diagnostic tests should not involve ionizing radiation where an appropriate alternative exists. In the post-MI setting, clinical guidelines place emphasis on echocardiography as the standard care test for left ventricular function,3,4 whereas CMR is the only method which can delineate a broad range of prognostically important infarct characteristics, including infarct size, oedema, microvascular obstruction, and myocardial haemorrhage.11 For myocardial viability and ischaemia, compared with SPECT, both stress echocardiography and stress CMR are alternatives that do not involve ionizing radiation exposure. In conclusion, healthcare providers that undertake radionuclide testing for the measurement of infarct size post-MI and prognostication should reconsider this practice in light of the new information reported by Hadamitzky et al.7 We conclude that CMR now represents the reference method for post-MI prognostication. Whether or not CMR can be used for this purpose in routine clinical practice depends on a range of factors, including cost and feasibility. This research was supported by a grant from the Chief Scientist Office, Scottish Health Department. C.B. was supported by a Senior Fellowship from the Scottish Funding Council, and holds project grants from Medical Research Scotland and the British Heart Foundation Project Grant (PG/11/2/28474).
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Corocoran et al. (2013) conducted an editorial in Acute STEMI (n=281). Cardiac magnetic resonance (CMR) vs. Tc99m-Sestamibi-SPECT was evaluated on Primary outcome (p=<0.0001). Microvascular obstruction and infarct size measured by cardiac magnetic resonance were stronger predictors of the primary outcome than infarct size by SPECT.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: