Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
In 1978 in Monell v. New York City Dept. of Social Services' the United States Supreme Court reversed its 1961 decision in Monroe v. Pape2 and declared that under the Civil Rights Act of 1871 (now codified as 42 U.S.C. ? 1983) local governmental bodies have no sovereign immunity protection from civil litigation initiated by the injured party. Two years later in 1980, first with Owen v. City of Independence,3 then with Maine v. Thiboutot,4 the Court went further to disallow even the qualified immunity from which municipalities might have some protection in civil litigation, holding them responsible not only for constitutional violations but for federal statutory violations as well. Additionally, the Court provided that the injured, if prevailing in court, may recover attorney's fees from the defendant government.5 What the Supreme Court did via Monell, Owen, and Thiboutot (hereinafter MOT) was to pronounce a major policy change on state and local governmental liability not due to legislation but due to judicial interpretations Some feared that MOT in general, and Thiboutot in particular, might invite a landslide of litigation against local governments7 and poison the administrative environment, creating disincentives for efficiency and bringing a gradual erosion of cooperative federalism.' State and local administrators were understandably apprehensive about the expected rise of lawsuits and the attendant increase in insurance premiums.9 However, not everyone shares this doomsday scenario. Others warned against overreaction, insisting that mechanisms are still built into our judicial system and local public administration which may possibly mitigate the uncontrolled spread of lawsuits.'0 This paper examines whether lawsuits against state and local governments and their officials have actually been increasing, as expected, following the MOT decisions. The paper also examines whether a pattern has emerged in the characteristics of litigants and their complaints, the likely targets of their lawsuits, and the legal outcomes. The main finding is that the MOT decisions have not, at least as yet, brought about a landslide of liability lawsuits. Where increases have occurred, they have been confined largely to the cities and counties, and the courts have been fairly stringent in awarding monetary relief. Data for the study are based on cases litigated in federal district courts between 1977 and 1983 in every odd year. * In the American federal system local governments occupy the hub of public service. It has been predicted that the Monell-Owen-Thiboutot decisions by the United States Supreme Court in 1978 and 1980 would invite a landslide of lawsuits against these governments. Analysis of a national sample of approximately 1, 700 lawsuits litigated in federal district courts between 1977 and 1983 indicates that increases in litigation have not been as pervasive as previously speculated. Where they have occured, the lawsuits have been generally confined to a few specific areas of services in cities and counties including police, judicial, and regulatory subsystems, and the courts have not responded liberally to prayers for monetary relief.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Yong S. Lee (1987) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: