Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The Institute of Medicine report Dying in America1 highlights the fact that multiple transitions between healthcare settings at the end of life, including high rates of hospitalizations, can fragment care delivery and burden care recipients and families. Hospice, which has grown rapidly in recent years,2 aims to provide care that ameliorates symptoms and attends to the psychosocial needs of individuals and their families while reducing unneeded and unwanted medical interventions, including hospitalization. Evidence suggests that hospice has positive effects on quality of life and caregiver outcomes.3, 4 By reducing emergency department (ED) visits and subsequent hospitalizations, hospice may result in other downstream benefits for individuals (avoiding fragmentation, hazards of hospitalization, untreated symptom distress) and families (through caregiver assessment and support and long-term bereavement support), even beyond the person's death.5 Two studies in this issue of the Journal of the American Geriatrics Society examine hospitalization, ED usage, and other healthcare transitions for individuals with serious illness enrolled in hospice at the end of life. Obermeyer and colleagues6 find that the vast majority of individuals with cancer with a poor prognosis visited the ED in the last 6 months of life. Using coarsened exact matching to create pairs of Medicare beneficiaries who did and did not enroll in hospice, they determined that decedents who did not use hospice were significantly more likely to visit the ED in the last week of life and that there were fewer hospital admissions after ED visits for the hospice group. This study suggests that, overall, hospice reduces ED visits and hospitalizations, at least for individuals with cancer. Similarly, in a previous study of individuals with poor prognosis cancer, Obermeyer and colleagues7 found that individuals who received hospice care had lower total expenditures over the last year of life than those who did not. In contrast, Wang and colleagues8 report that, of all hospice decedents in the United States in 2011, 10% had at least one and more than 6% had two or more transitions after enrollment, the majority to hospitals. The sheer number of transitions after enrollment in hospice that that study documented is troubling. The figure delineating multiple transitions makes it clear that a subset of individuals experience a complex and highly fragmented journey after their enrollment in hospice. Transitions of care, including hospitalizations, at the end of life create discontinuity and risks from the hazards of hospitalization and may limit access to potentially important palliative care services such as expert symptom control, communication about what to expect and how to manage it, and reliable continuity of care at a vulnerable time. Although challenging for all families of individuals with serious illness, care transitions may be especially complicated for caregivers of dying individuals who need to be prepared and know what to expect as death approaches and require support from professionals with expertise in the unique challenges of care during the last few weeks of life and the active dying phase. Do these transitions after hospice enrollment necessarily reflect the failure of the hospice system to meet the needs of individuals and their families? Unfortunately, these data, although impressively culled from administrative claims and county- and hospital referral region–level data, do not show why these transitions are occurring. Critically, they are unable to provide any information about individual or family preferences for care or the immediate precipitants of the decision to go to the hospital. Possible reasons include (but are not limited to) poorly controlled symptoms, caregiver exhaustion, and anxiety about the imminence of death. Although hospice is required to provide around-the-clock availability, responsiveness to telephone calls, staffing, and availability to come to the house vary widely from hospice to hospice. Hospices also differ in their ability to prepare family caregivers on how to respond should (predictable) but severe symptom distress develop. During a pain or dyspnea crisis, waiting more than a few minutes for a call back is too long. Thus, hospital use by individuals in hospice may reflect a need for more-immediate or -intense palliation or the provision of other necessary and appropriate medical care, an inference supported by the fact that individuals with cancer in hospice—a group with a high burden of distressing physical symptoms—were more likely to transition to the hospital than people in other diagnostic categories. The variation based on primary diagnosis (individuals with cancer have more transitions to the hospital) also may suggest that the typically intense and long-term relationships with hospital-based oncology specialists may cause individuals and families to feel safest among these familiar providers. Hospitalization could also reflect a change of mind toward preferences of families and individuals for life-prolonging care. The significant of hospice-level variation in likelihood of hospitalization suggests that high rates of transitions to hospitals reflect system-level failures. For example, the finding that hospices with a lower average daily census and those that have been in operation for less than 10 years are most likely to have care recipients hospitalized suggests that some hospices simply have not developed the resource capacity required to adequately meet clients' needs. Researchers have used administrative data to demonstrate that hospice length of stay, disenrollment, and care patterns vary at the individual, hospice, and geographic level.9-12 Now that heterogeneity in hospice care has been established, understanding exactly why such variations exist and what can be done from a policy and regulatory standpoint must be focused on to reduce fragmented care and unnecessary transitions. Hospice quality measures need to be expanded to incorporate claims-based data on care pattern variations so that hospices can be held accountable for fragmented care and unnecessary transitions. Although it is likely that the level of after-hours attentiveness that some dying individuals and their families require is not routinely available, hospice quality measures, including frequency of skilled visits, wait time for retuning telephone calls, and number and type of care transitions, will help achieve a better understanding of the variation in hospice quality and its predictors. Furthermore, data from the new Medicare Care Choices Model demonstration project13 will allow whether simultaneous access to disease treatment and hospice will modify reliance on 911, the ED, and the hospital for after-hours crises to be determined. How fragmented care and unnecessary transitions can continue to be reduced for individuals with serious illness within and outside the hospice setting must be considered. It is possible that, as Medicare begins payment for advance care planning discussions, and they become more standardized throughout medical practice, individuals and families will be more likely to obtain the care they want. Access to palliative care must also continue to be increased earlier in the disease course. Wang and colleagues find that states with the highest access to palliative care in hospitals have 40% fewer transitions to the hospital from the hospice setting, suggesting that the more opportunity for palliative care there is throughout the care spectrum, the greater the likelihood that hospice can truly achieve its goal. The nationwide increase in assumption of financial risk for individuals resulting from a number of policy levers (e.g., growth in accountable care organizations; Medicare Advantage; Medicaid managed care; penalties for 30-day readmissions, hospital mortality, poor satisfaction) will also support greater access to palliative care service delivery that meets the needs of high-risk individuals at home and in community settings, rather than forcing them to rely on 911 calls after hours. Evidence suggests that hospice improves individual- and family-reported quality of care and in so doing is associated with reduction in ED visits, hospitalization, consequent stresses, and their related costs, but more needs to be done than just expanding the hospice benefit; is must be ensured that hospice is providing vulnerable dying individuals and their families with the high-quality care they want and deserve, which means reducing unnecessary and undesired care transitions within the hospice setting. The use of hospice quality measures that focus on identifying and addressing the root causes of transitions is critical to ensuring that this most-vulnerable of all groups of individuals and families receive the highest possible quality of care. Conflict of Interest: The authors declare no competing interests. Author Contributions: Both authors contributed to this paper. Sponsor's Role: None.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Ornstein et al. (2016) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: