Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) is a virus that attacks the immune system, leaving individuals vulnerable to infections and diseases. More than 1 million Americans are living with HIV, and one of eight people with HIV do not know they have it (1). Human immunodeficiency virus continues to spread, and in 2020 alone, 30,635 people in the United States and surrounding territories received an HIV diagnosis (1). In the past, a diagnosis of HIV was inextricably associated with premature mortality, but with the advent of antiretroviral therapy (ART), the life expectancy of people living with HIV (PLWH) has greatly improved. In fact, PLWH who take ART as prescribed and have a consistently undetectable viral load can expect to have a life expectancy similar to that of individuals without HIV (2). Progression from HIV to AIDS from a weakened immune system is becoming rarer due to the highly successful developments in ART treatment options over the past decade. As a result, more PLWH remain undetectable in terms of viral load and therefore also lessen any damage to the immune system (3). The PLWH who are on ART however, have an increased risk of chronic diseases such as heart disease, hyperlipidemia, diabetes, and certain types of cancer. The increased risk of chronic diseases is likely due to the ongoing inflammation and immune activation that occurs in the body because of HIV infection, even when the virus is well-controlled with ART. It is important for PLWH, and their health care teams, to mitigate their increased risks of chronic diseases and encourage and support PLWH to adopt and maintain a healthy lifestyle, such as eating a healthy diet and engaging in regular physical activity. Current physical activity recommendations as described in ACSM's Guidelines for Exercise Testing and Prescription, 11th edition, for PLWH suggest a moderate-intensity aerobic and resistance training regimen similar to recommendations for the general population (4). The Physical Activity Guidelines for Americans, 2nd edition, suggests individuals accumulate a minimum of 150 minutes of moderate-intensity physical activity a week, 75 minutes of vigorous-intensity physical activity, or a combination of the two, as well as 2 days of full body resistance training at approximately 60% of one repetition maximum (5). Studies have consistently shown that regular, low- to moderate-intensity physical activity can improve physical function, reduce inflammation and risk of chronic disease, and improve overall quality of life for PLWH (6–8).When it comes to high-intensity physical activity or exercise, the benefits and any potential risks are less clear due to the lack of research within the PLWH population. High-intensity interval training (HIIT) has been repeatedly reported as one of the leading fitness trends worldwide for the past decade (9). High-intensity interval training involves alternating between intense bursts of activity and periods of rest or low-intensity activity. Within the past decade, the same benefits have been reported after HIIT compared with sedentary controls in healthy and clinical populations (10–12). Given the importance of health and fitness professionals appropriately prescribing HIIT for PLWH, the purposes of this Clinical Applications column are to: 1) present the benefits of physical activity and exercise for PLWH, 2) provide the latest research on high-intensity physical activity and exercise among PLWH, 3) provide an overview of studies that have examined the effects of HIIT and the immune system, and 4) present an overview of the studies conducted specifically incorporating HIIT with PLWH. By highlighting the potential benefits of engaging in physical activity or exercise for PLWH as a means of improving their health and prolonging their lives, regardless of intensity level, health and fitness professionals may encourage PLWH to adopt an active lifestyle with recommendations provided when prescribing HIIT. BENEFITS OF PHYSICAL ACTIVITY AND EXERCISE It has been well established that engaging in regular exercise can decrease the incidence, severity, and mortality of many leading causes of death (5). Routine exercise training not only prevents death from all causes, but also provides a wide range of physiological and psychological benefits. In fact, 6 of the 10 leading causes of death are preventable chronic diseases that also are known to decrease in risk for people with higher fitness levels who engage in daily physical activity and/or exercise (13). Two of these chronic diseases, cardiovascular disease (CVD) and cancer, are some of the costliest conditions responsible for approximately half of all deaths each year and are among the most preventable health problems in the United States. Studies have shown that increases in the amount of total daily physical activity reduces many of the modifiable risk factors associated with CVD including reducing the buildup of body fat, improving insulin resistance and HbA1c levels, raising high-density lipoprotein (HDL) cholesterol, and lowering triglyceride levels in the general population. Due to its popularity among the general population and enhanced benefits that improve health, HIIT can improve various cardiometabolic health markers, such as reducing blood pressure and blood sugar levels and enhancing heart function and cardiovascular fitness (12). Researchers have explored the benefits of HIIT for other high-risk individuals with known chronic diseases such as cardiometabolic diseases and lung-related conditions like chronic obstructive pulmonary disorder (10,11). Even though the studies were not conducted with PLWH, findings from the ongoing research of HIIT with high-risk populations indicates that not only does HIIT lead to similar improvements in fitness levels but also has a low probability of leading to an adverse event due to the increased stress placed on the cardiovascular system to keep up with energy demands. Research findings could suggest that HIIT may be just as effective and safe for PLWH with or without other chronic disease if all necessary precautions are taken before, during, and after exercise for any individual in a high-risk category. Even with successful viral suppression, the adverse effects of ART alone places PLWH into the high-risk category according to the ACSM risk stratification procedures. Regardless of disease status, medical clearance from a primary health care provider is necessary for anyone with HIV before engaging in a new exercise program. HIGH-INTENSITY PHYSICAL ACTIVITY AND EXERCISE RESEARCH WITH PLWH PLWH have responded well to physical activity and exercise prescriptions that have incorporated some form of high- or vigorous-intensity level, albeit in short durations (Table 1). With more PLWH able to remain undetected and reduce the severe impairment HIV can have on the immune system, it is plausible that HIIT would not pose a serious health risk any more than it would for individuals without HIV. In recent years, some studies have compared high-intensity aerobic exercise and moderate-intensity aerobic exercise (14–19). These studies have shown that a high-intensity modality and dosage was just as safe as moderate-intensity exercise in which both have shown to improve strength, body composition, and V˙O2 peak (16,17). When compared with moderate-intensity aerobic exercise, high-intensity aerobic exercise improved V˙O2 peak at a significantly greater rate (17). More studies involving continuous, high-intensity physical activity or exercise should be conducted to provide a clearer picture of using this modality and provide evidence-based recommendations for PLWH to participate in different modalities of exercise. TABLE 1 - HIV and High-Intensity Clinical Exercise Studies Authors Intervention Results Qin et al. 2022 (14) MIA30: 60%–80% HRmax activity for 30 min HIA: ↓ cortisol 3-h mark postexercise MIA45: 60%–80% HRmax activity for 45 min MIA45: ↓ cortisol immediately postexercise HIA: 10 min (>80% HRmax) No adverse events reported Erlandson et al. 2021 (15) MIA: All participated in the first 12 wk (40%–60% V˙O2peak) MIA and HIA: ↑ sCD14, TNF-alpha, TNF-2 HIA group (half the subjects randomized for high intensity) (70%–80% V˙O2peak) HIA: ↑ sCD14, and IL-10 with MIA CON (no change in activity) No adverse events reported Jankowski et al. 2020 (16) MIA + RT: 12 wk (2–3×/wk) MIA + RT: ↓ body fatHIA + RT: ↓ body fat At 12 wk participants were randomized to continue MIA + RT or being HIA + RT for another 12 wk No significant differences between MIA or HIA groups CON: Matched controls without HIV. No adverse events reported Oursler et al. 2018 (17) MIA (3–5 METs): 16 wk of walking 1 mile at own pace.HIA: 16 wk of high-intensity aerobic training (75%–90% HRR). HIA: ↑ V˙O2peak compared with MIA group.HIA and MIA ↓ 6-min walk time compared with baseline.No adverse events reported Kocher et al. 2017 (18) HIA: 48 sessions of aerobic exercise at 50%–80% HRR spanning 12 wk HIA: ↑ V˙O2peak, mitochondrial density, and spare respiratory capacityNo adverse events reported Maduagwu et al. 2015 (19) HIA: 50%–75% HRR for 40 min, 3×/wk, for 12 wkCON: Unsupervised exercise with check-in every 3 wk. HIA: ↑ CD4, ↓ lipid profileNo adverse events reported 1RM, 1 repetition maximum; CON: control group; HIA, high-intensity aerobic group; HRmax, heart rate max; HRR, heart rate reserve; IL, interleukin; MIA, moderate-intensity aerobic group; RT, resistance training; TNF, tumor necrosis factor; V˙O2peak, peak oxygen consumption. HIIT AND THE IMMUNE SYSTEM Research on the effects of HIIT on the immune system has yielded mixed results, with some studies showing an increase in lymphocyte and/or CD4+ count after HIIT compared with moderate-intensity exercise (20–22), whereas others have found no significant differences between HIIT and other forms of physical activity or exercise (23,24). Although most published research in the area of HIIT has focused on the positive adaptations over time or acute responses to common variables of fatigue, there is a small number of studies (Table 2) that examined the impact it can have on the immune system in healthy adults, most of which were acute measurements (20–25) demonstrating a significant difference in immune cell activation between 30 minutes and 2 hours immediately after a session of HIIT when compared with moderate-intensity activity only or a sedentary control group. This increase in immune cells, followed by a decline below baseline levels for a few hours, is suggestive of a typical inflammatory immune response after a high amount of stress placed on the body that is similarly observed after other forms of high- or vigorous-intensity exercise. According to studies, 24 hours is enough time for full recovery of cell counts or approximation of baseline values. In this sense, the safety of HIIT for maintaining the immune health of the general population is evident. However, more studies are needed for evaluating infection risk over time rather than just acute changes in cell counts. In addition, it also is necessary to know how the immune system behaves with consecutive HIIT sessions. TABLE 2 - High-Intensity Interval Training and Immune System Studies Authors Intervention Results Arroyo et al. 2022 (20) HIIT: 15 × 90 s (85% of V˙O2peak) with 90 s of recovery (25% of V˙O2peak).MIA: 65% V˙O2peak for 45 minCON: None reported ↑LY and CD4+ immediately after exercise followed by transient decrease between 6 and 24 h in both groups Heinemann et al. 2020 (23) HIIT: 20 × 30 s (100% of V˙O2peak) alternated with 30 s of recovery (50% of V˙O2peak)MIA: 50% V˙O2peak for 30 minCON: Crossover study design with participants serving as own controls. HIIT: ↔ in WBC or LYMIA: ↑ WBC 1 h postexercise; ↔ LY Wadley et al. 2020 (21) HIIT: 10 × 4 min (85% of V˙O2peak) alternated with 2 min of recoveryMIA: 60% V˙O2peak for 58 minCON: Crossover study design with participants serving as own controls. ↑LY, CD3+, and CD8+ immediately after exercise in both groups Jamurtas et al. 2018 (22) HIIT: 4 × 30 s (0.375 kg/kg of body weight) alternated with 2 min of recoveryMIA: 70% V˙O2peak for 30 minCON: Standard care ↑WBC immediately after exercise in both intervention groups↑LY immediately after exercise in HIIT only Kruger et al. 2016 (25) HIIT: 5 × 3 min (90% peak power) alternated with 3 min of active recoveryMIA: 70% V˙O2peak for 30 minCON: Standard care ↑CD3+, CD4+, and CD8+ immediately after exercise in both exercise groups Dorneles et al. 2016 (24) HIIT: 10 × 60 s (85%–90% of V˙O2peak) alternated with 75 s of recovery (50% of V˙O2peak)MIIT: 10 × 60 s (70%–75% of V˙O2peak) alternated with 60 s of recovery (50% of V˙O2peak) ↑WBC immediately after exercise in HIIT only.↔ LY in both groups. LY, lymphocyte; MIIT, moderate-intensity interval training group; WBC, white blood cell count. HIIT AND HIV To date, four studies have reported findings from exercise interventions for PLWH that included an HIIT component, with the first published study only dating back to 2020 (26–29) (Table 3). These interventions ranged from 6 weeks to 4 months in duration with HIIT sessions held 3 days per week, which is common among exercise training interventions of any kind for this population. Only Briggs and colleagues (28) reported the specific timing of each high-intensity interval, which lasted 4 minutes, and active recovery, which was 3 minutes in duration. This interval was completed a total of four times and resulted in a significant increase in V˙O2peak by 17.1%, which was 10% higher than the high-intensity aerobic combined with resistance training group that also reported a significant increase by 7.7%. Similar results were reported in the other two HIIT interventions that were shorter in duration (6 and 12 weeks, respectively); however, they did not include a high-intensity aerobic group to compare with HIIT (26,27). Although none of these studies included immune system markers as outcome variables, they also did not report any adverse events or negative consequences to the participants, suggesting HIIT may be a safe and viable option for PLWH who were experienced as exercisers and wished to incorporate HIIT into their workouts. PLWH who are starting a new physical activity or exercise program should acclimate themselves to a moderate-intensity physical activity or exercise that incorporates both aerobic and resistance training before adopting HIIT to avoid potential unforeseen risks or injury due to lack of experience. TABLE 3 - HIV High-Intensity Interval Training Studies Authors Intervention Results Soares et al. 2022 (29) HIIT + PRT: 7 × 30 s (75%–90% HRR) with 1-min passive recovery after PRTHIA + RT: 75% HRR aerobic combined with RT (70% 1RM)CON: maintained usual activities Both exercise groups saw ↑ in fat-free mass, strength, chair stand, and timed up-and-go test compared with controlHIIT + PRT: ↑ strengthNo adverse events reported* Budhwani et al. 2021 (26) 12 wk (2–3×/wk) of motivational interviewing + HIIT + RT: 20 min HIIT, 20 min RT, 10 min of yoga and breathing for cooldown. HIIT + RT with motivational interviewing: ↑ strength; ↓ viral load CON: None reported No adverse events reported* Briggs et al. 2021 (28) HIA + RT: 4 mo (3×/wk) of high-intensity aerobic (70%–80% HRR) combined with RT (2 sets of 8–12 reps at 50% 1RM)HIIT: 4 mo (3×/wk) of HIA + RT. HIIT protocol: 4 × 4 min (90%–95% HRmax) alternated with 4-min active recovery (50%–70% HRmax).CON: Crossover study design had those randomized into control group begin HIIT intervention after 4 mo. HIA: ↑ V˙O2peak by 7.7%; ↑ strengthHIIT: ↑ V˙O2peak by 17.1%; ↑ strengthNo adverse events reported* Ramirez-Marrero et al. 2020 (27) 6 wk (3×/wk) of low-volume HIIT: 8–10 high- and low-intensity intervals at 80%–90% HRRCON: Matched controls without HIV completed same intervention HIIT: ↑ V˙O2peak and average peak workloadNo adverse events reported* PRT, periodized resistance training. CONCLUSIONS It is important for PLWH to consult with their health care providers before starting any physical activity or exercise program because they may need to take extra precautions, such as avoiding certain types of physical activity or exercise that could put them at risk of injury. Healthy PLWH can benefit from physical activity and exercise as a form of preventative care for other chronic conditions. For health and fitness professionals working with PLWH, although research specific to PLWH participating in HIIT might be lacking, there have yet to be any negative reports or complications. To date, research with PLWH consistently shows the same benefits for all forms of exercise as the general population, and exercise-induced immunosuppression or other adverse events have not been reported. A continuation of rigorous research must ensue; however, to further establish the safety and efficacy of HIIT for PLWH. Further research should include long-term studies with PLWH with a history of well-managed with medication adherence, or even undetected. High-intensity physical activity or exercise prescriptions should be discouraged for PLWH with a history of medication noncompliance or who have started taking ART in the last 6 months to allow time for them to adapt before placing further stress on the body.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Jaggers et al. (2023) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: