Key result
South Asian patients were less likely to complete a 6-month cardiac rehabilitation program than white patients (43% vs 51%; P=0.04), but more often reached at least 85% of target heart rate.
Why the study?
Do patient characteristics, compliance, and exercise outcomes differ between South Asians and whites enrolled in cardiac rehabilitation?
Cohort (n=1,200)
Yes
Do patient characteristics, compliance, and exercise outcomes differ between South Asians and whites enrolled in cardiac rehabilitation?
Absolute Event Rate: 43% vs 51%
p-value: p=.04
South Asians enrolled in cardiac rehabilitation have a different risk factor profile and lower program completion rates compared to whites, but demonstrate greater improvements in exercise outcomes.
May warrant targeted retention strategies for South Asians in cardiac rehab; hypothesis-generating for ethnic differences in exercise intensity.
In Brief PURPOSE: To compare patient demographics, the presence or absence of traditional cardiovascular risk factors, medications on entry, compliance with cardiac rehabilitation (CR), and exercise outcomes at 6 months among South Asians and whites attending a CR program. METHODS: A retrospective analysis of South Asian (n = 220) and white (n = 980) patients participating in 2 outpatient, hospital-based CR programs over a 3-year period. RESULTS: South Asians were younger (56 vs 59 years; P = .004), had lower body mass index (26.8 vs 28.4 kg/m2; P < .0001), had lower rates of hypertension (36% vs 45%; P = .01), were less likely to be smokers (25% vs 50%; P = .00001), and were more likely to have diabetes (36% vs 23%; P = .0001). Compliance with the 6-month CR program was poor in both groups, but South Asians were less likely to complete the entire program (43% vs 51%; P = .04). Over the course of CR, maximum achieved metabolic equivalent during stress testing improved in both groups; however, South Asian patients trended to a greater change and more often reached at least 85% of target heart rate (55% vs 42%; P = .02). CONCLUSION: South Asians participating in CR are younger, have a different risk factor profile, benefit equally, but are less compliant than whites. Further research is needed to better understand the barriers faced by South Asians in successfully participating in and completing CR programs. Risk factor profiles of South Asian and white participants in a cardiac rehabilitation program differ significantly. Although compliance was lower, South Asians showed greater improvements in exercise outcomes. Our study suggests that targeting this known high-risk ethnic subset is effective and warranted in light of the proven benefits of cardiac rehabilitation.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Banerjee et al. (2007) conducted a cohort in Cardiac rehabilitation (n=1,200). South Asian ethnicity vs. White ethnicity was evaluated on Completion of the 6-month cardiac rehabilitation program (p=.04). South Asian patients were less likely to complete a 6-month cardiac rehabilitation program than white patients (43% vs 51%; P=0.04), but more often reached at least 85% of target heart rate.
Synapse has enriched 5 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: