Key result
Kidney transplant recipients who declined participation in an exercise trial reported significantly higher median physical activity levels (195 vs. 103 minutes per week) than those who participated.
Why the study?
Limited knowledge exists about individuals who decline participation in exercise trials.
Observational (n=157)
Yes
Absolute Event Rate: 195% vs 103%
p-value: p=0.003
Kidney transplant recipients who decline participation in exercise trials may already be more physically active but have fewer motivators for exercise compared to those who enroll, highlighting a specific participation bias.
Nonparticipants showed higher activity but lower motivation than enrollees; leaves open questions on trial generalizability and recruitment strategies in kidney transplant exercise studies.
Background Limited knowledge exists about individuals who decline participation in exercise trials. This study compared characteristics of participants and nonparticipants in a kidney transplant exercise trial using a dual-consent design. Methods The study was nested within the PHOENIX-Kidney randomized controlled trial, which evaluated a home-based exercise and physical activity intervention in kidney transplant recipients. At three months post-transplant, eligible individuals were invited to participate via two parallel consent pathways: one for trial participation and one for observational data of nonparticipants. Both groups completed self-reported questionnaires on sociodemographics, physical activity levels, and perceived motivators and barriers to physical activity. Reasons for nonparticipation were documented, and clinical data were extracted from medical records. Group comparisons used t-tests, Mann-Whitney U, chi-square, and Fisher’s exact tests. Results Of 345 screened kidney transplant recipients, 58% were eligible. Ineligibility was primarily due to medical contraindications (26%), language barriers (24%), and multi-organ transplantation (20%). Among eligible individuals, 88 (44%) enrolled in the intervention and 65 (35%) completed the observational follow-up for nonparticipants. Major reasons for nonparticipation included lack of time (23%), and feeling sufficiently active (20%). Nonparticipants reported higher physical activity levels (195 [120–360] vs. 103 [19–180] minutes per week; P = 0.003), while participants had higher motivator scores for physical activity (2.1 [1.6 – 2.4] vs. 1.5 [1.1 – 1.9]; P < 0.01). Conclusion The dual-consent approach enabled unique insights into differences between participants and nonparticipants, which can inform strategies to reduce participation bias and enhance inclusivity in future trials. Clinical Trial Registration Clinicaltrials.gov identifier number: NCT06260579 .
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Beir et al. (2025) conducted an observational in Kidney transplant (n=157). Nonparticipation in exercise trial vs. Trial participation was evaluated on Median moderate to vigorous physical activity (MVPA) per week in minutes (p=0.003). Kidney transplant recipients who declined participation in an exercise trial reported significantly higher median physical activity levels (195 vs. 103 minutes per week) than those who participated.
Synapse has enriched 5 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: