Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Human Leukocyte Antigen (HLA) class I deficiency, in most cases due to a homozygous mutation in the gene of one of the two subunits of the transporter associated with antigen processing (TAP1 or TAP2), results in a very low level of HLA class I molecule expression at the cell surface. Until now, approximately 50 cases have been described in the literature. Exceptionally, the defect can also be the result of mutations in the TABP (encoding tapasin) or the B2M (beta2-microglobulin) genes [1]. Clinically, the syndrome is in most instances accompanied by chronic bacterial infections of the respiratory tract, as well as by cutaneous granulomas leading to deep ulcers, or even disfiguring granulomatous lesions of the midface with nasal cartilage destruction and palatine perforation [1-3]. More recently, the role of viruses, notably herpesviruses [1] and rubella virus [4], have been recognised to be involved in the pathophysiology of the disease. The susceptibility to sometimes severe viral infections is consistent with the important role of endogenous TAP-dependent peptide presentation to CD8+ cytotoxic T lymphocytes, which is largely suboptimal in this disease, and with the frequently applied immunosuppressive treatment. We read with major interest the publication by Fernández-Galván et al. [5] in this journal, reporting a recently diagnosed new mutation in the TAP1 gene leading to the classical pulmonary and cutaneous manifestations in the patient. Although the symptoms were present from age 3 years on, the diagnosis had only been made once the patient was in his thirties, and he had received several immunosuppressive treatments, which are not recommended in TAP deficiency syndrome, because they usually worsen the clinical presentation [1]. So far, the history of the syndrome is conventional, but what renders this report interesting are four observations: (i) the remarkable efficiency of IVIg on the cutaneous lesions that regressed almost completely for some time, (ii) the demonstration of rubella virus replication in cutaneous granulomas, (iii) the appearance of an EBV-associated lymphoproliferative disease, and (iv) the development of an invasive squamous cell carcinoma on a residual scar, leading to the patient′s loss. However, in contrast to the claims of the authors, their report is not the second case of rubella virus replication-associated case of TAP deficiency syndrome, as Wang et al. also showed this phenomenon in a TAP1-deficient patient described in 2024 [6]. Moreover, but after the publication of the article discussed here, Luciani et al. presented a series of four HLA class I-deficient patients, all of them previously described, in which rubella virus replication was demonstrated in three cases by polymerase chain reaction (PCR) and/or rubella serology [4]. Thus, this virus really seems to play an important role in the pathophysiology of granuloma formation, and it should therefore not be recommended to vaccinate these patients against rubella with live-attenuated strains. Squamous cell carcinoma developing on a granuloma or a granuloma scar has likewise been described before in at least two papers, namely the case of España et al. [7] and the one of Cottier et al [8]. In both situations, the carcinomas became rapidly invasive, metastatic and fatal. Finally, the unfortunate history of the current patient emphasises once more the necessity of a correct diagnosis as soon as possible, so to avoid contra-indicated immunosuppressive treatments. With every review on the topic and every additional case report, this rare disease will become better known by the clinicians and therefore improve patients' chances for an improved life expectancy. Jacques Zimmer: conceptualisation, writing, original draft preparation. The author has nothing to report. The author declares no conflicts of interest. Data sharing not applicable to this article as no datasets were generated or analysed during the current study.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Jacques Zimmer (2025) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: