This is the authors' abstract. We don't add key points for this paper.
The American lexicon is dynamic and rapidly changing, especially concerning the words used in contemporary diversity-, equity-, inclusion-, and justice-speak. The users of American English may often experience whiplash, given its voracity and dynamic nature. Words that once signaled courtesy, respect, and “knowing,” may now be considered out-of-touch, out-of-date, or potentially uninformed in some circles. The victims of this whiplash may be tempted to give up or opt out of the discussion, finding it too onerous to adapt or update their language. However, the importance, proper use, and significance of words could not be more critical at the present moment, especially for pediatric researchers. Research demands accuracy and precision. This includes effectively communicating new ideas, complex and novel methodologies, and new approaches to interpreting and contextualizing findings so that others may replicate and build upon the scientific work. Researchers translate and elaborate on the implications of their findings, creating new paradigms and occasionally urging action because of their discoveries. Furthermore, the use of language can draw people in or push them away. Science represents the culture and society in which it exists. The demographics of the United States continues to change and shift, and thus, so should our language to accommodate and give reverence to an America remade. Precise yet adaptable language is needed in our beautifully diverse nation and world. It is equally needed in clinical and translational research and in health care, particularly in our field of developmental and behavioral pediatrics, where respecting the patients, families and those we hope to impact are of prime importance. Likely in response to the killings of George Floyd, Breonna Taylor, and Ahmaud Arbery in the summer of 2020, and the resultant public outcry for action, journals have released guidance about the use of language around the concepts of race, ethnicity, disability, and gender.1,2 Some journals even have determined that the use of race in analyses without an explicit explanation of the reasons for its inclusion should be prohibited.2 The new perspectives mark a critical turning point in the field as a whole, an indication that we will not return to a time when we did not acknowledge or address race, racism, sexism, ableism, or other systems of oppression in our work. However, with the current criticisms and backlash against critical race theory, inclusive teaching, and language,3,4 our commitment to equity, inclusion, and justice may start to waver. The Journal of Developmental and Behavioral Pediatrics (JDBP) has a long history of publishing research and commentary on issues that span the spectrum of equity prior to 2020, including the first review article on the influence of racism on child health in 2009.5 However, after the events of the early 2020's we recognized that we could do better, and Editor-in-Chief Lee M. Pachter6 called for the journal, authors, reviewers, and researchers to take up the mantle. In that call, the journal made a commitment to developed a more equity-focused peer review process that develops guidelines for authors, reviewers, and editors to ensure that the next wave of research rigorously investigates the drivers of disparities as well as approaches to bridge these gaps and help to further health equity. Since that time, we are making strides to move forward. Dr. Nia Heard-Garris was appointed as our first Associate Editor for Research Equity, and drafted our first health equity principles for authors, which was presented to the Associate Editors, Section Editors, and the Editorial Board. We collected feedback to clarify and to improve the principle's ease of use. Since then we have developed and revised the guidance, entitled the Journal of Developmental & Behavioral Pediatrics Health Equity Guidance for Authors (Fig. 1), published in this issue of the Journal, to make our commitment to health equity in research and scholarship clear and unwavering.Figure 1.: Journal of Developmental & Behavioral Pediatrics Health Equity GuidanceThis is a framework created to encourage and support our authors by providing them with the scaffolding needed to incorporate equity in their manuscript and perhaps in their future research. This editorial commentary serves to introduce our new Guidance and explain how we recommend for authors to use it, as well as our plans for our continued work towards health equity at our journal and in the field of pediatrics and developmental and behavioral research. However, we know that as our lexicon and understanding of health equity shifts and expands, so must our Guidance. Thus, this Guidance will serve as an opportunity for our authors, reviewers, and editorial board to revisit, reflect, collaborate, and revise. The Guidance is arranged similar to the PRISMA checklist used for systematic reviews and meta-analyses to improve the consistency and quality of the work.7 We have divided our Guidance into the main sections and topics generally found within a manuscript, including the introduction, methods, results, and discussion, and other information. These sections are further subdivided where appropriate. Below is a summary of what authors will find in the sections of the Guidance: Introduction: In the introduction, authors should consider noting any disparities and inequities in the topic of their research, as well as populations disproportionately affected or understudied. Authors should discuss any structural factors that may drive these inequities, avoiding deficit-based and population-blaming language. Methods: The methods section should clearly specify the study design and efforts made to ensure equitable recruitment and retention across groups studied. Authors should discuss the tools and assessments used and their validation for the study's populations, or any adaptations made. Furthermore, studies should include non-English participants or those with limited English proficiency, and if this population is excluded, there should be an explanation or justification provided. The methods section should justify the inclusion of chosen covariates, explain the inclusion of race/ethnicity and any comparison groups, and should prioritize the use of existing conceptual models. The statistical analysis should specify and explain the selection of any reference group. Additionally, despite our attempts to be objective in research, as individuals we bring our perspectives informed by our social positions, experiences, and knowledge. As such, authors may wish to include a perspective statement describing the study team's demographic characteristics or positionality (which is described as the social position and power that informs an identity, including but not limited to race, socioeconomic status, gender, sexuality, ability status, nativity, preferred language, etc), in order to make these perspectives and positions more transparent. Results: Demographic characteristics should be reported with attention to age, race, ethnicity, sex assigned at birth, gender identity, disability status, geography, and other relevant categories. Researchers must avoid white-centering (e.g., using terms such as “Non-white participants”). All racial/ethnic groups should be capitalized within the text and listed in alphabetical order. Additionally, attempts should be made to disaggregate data for racial groups to avoid large heterogenous groups (e.g., “Asian”, “Hispanic”). Unclear racial/ethnic categorizations such as ‘Other’ should be avoided if possible. Consideration should also be given to including the multiracial/multiethnic category if appropriate. Discussion: In the discussion, authors should discuss the systems of power that may contribute to inequities or disparities in the study findings. Again, discuss conceptual frameworks used to contextualize findings, ensure limitations are described, summarize equity issues within the study (e.g., underrepresentation of certain groups, potential biases, etc). Discuss how any racial differences are typically not attributed to biology but to social constructs such as potential discrimination/racism on the structural, institutional, inter-personal, or internalized levels.8 Finally, discuss implications of the results related to practice, policy, and future research, especially as it relates to health equity. Other Considerations: Where appropriate, authors should make efforts to cite scholars and researchers who are underrepresented in research (e.g., racial/ethnic, sexual gender, disabled and other minoritized groups) to ensure a more balanced perspective on the topic. We would like for authors to understand that this Guidance is simply that, a guidance, not a singular rule or a litmus test for manuscript acceptance. We understand that researchers typically are not trained as cross-cultural social scientists, and therefore, will not be held to that level of expertise. However, if our goal is to move the needle on developing a science that is equity-informed, we need to provide a rubric that begins and guides this process. We will instruct our editors and peer reviewers to consider these issues alongside the traditional metrics of review as they provide their comments back to our authors. Thus, this guidance is offered as a tool for learning and to further move our field toward the pursuit of health equity. As authors become accustomed to this Guidance, they can either address these issues in their manuscripts or cite them as limitations and directions for future research as appropriate. Our hope is that over time, this guidance become embedded in the way researchers conceptualize their research questions, designs, analyses, and interpretations. Providing this Guidance begins that process. Finally, we acknowledge at first glance, this may seem to create additional work for authors and reviewers, and that every item in the Guidance may not be applicable to all manuscripts. However, we know this is a first critical step for journal to promote health equity in research in our field. Our hope is that with each application, the Guidance becomes easier to use, and becomes the standard of practice with respect to our writing and research. Our long-term goal is to have these issues become embedded in our conceptualization of the research process—not as add-ons, but a core component of how we think about developing, applying, and communicating our scholarly work. We are launching a soft roll-out, encouraging authors to use the Guidance as they develop their research and prepare their manuscripts. Starting in January, 2026 we will ask authors to document that they have reviewed and considered the Health Equity Guidance for Authors during their submission. Authors will not be required to submit the checklist; however, reviewers and editors will have access to them and will provide feedback to the authors as a part of the peer review process. Again, the guidance is meant to be instructive, not punitive. The Editorial Team at the Journal is available for any thoughts, comments or questions about this Guidance. Please feel free to contact us at [email protected] or [email protected]. Our next steps will be to develop a variety of educational offerings for the entire journal community—authors, reviewers, and editors—to help support all those in the journal's ecosystem to ensure that the lens of health equity is considered as a core component of your research. The path towards health equity may not be linear, and certainly may not be without obstacles, detours, and minor collisions along the road. However, at the Journal of Developmental and Behavioral Pediatrics, we hope to equip our community with the tools and support—akin to seatbelts and air bags--to avoid the whiplash of our rapidly changing lexicon as we embark on the journey to become a more equitable world.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Heard‐Garris et al. (2025) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: