Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
We read a lot about leadership per se and more specifically about clinical leadership. In recent years we have seen an abundance of empirical research and literature on leadership in healthcare. The multitude of books, journal articles, TED talks, YouTube clips and so on, provide us with what seems like endless opportunities to think about leadership. In addition, there has been an increasing emphasis on leadership development frameworks specifically for health professionals. Clinical leadership has become a significant issue worldwide in the latter half of the last century and there is every sign this will continue. Why it is important is obvious, given the inquiries and reports into the shortcomings in health services in many countries. The various reports have cited the vital role of leadership in clinical practice. It will be no surprise that in each of these inquiries and reports the role of nurses and midwives and the importance of clinical leadership has been highlighted, yet more reminders or demands are made on leaders and the effectiveness or not of our leadership. In a nutshell, clinical leadership is required for the provision of person-centred and effective care of people providing care and those receiving care. Given it is a topical issue and that it ‘touches’ everyone working in and receiving health care, it is somewhat surprising no agreed yet alone, universal definition of leadership exists. In fact, we continue and seem preoccupied, with producing more and more definitions and more and more models. Clear(er) definitions help us agree on core concepts and what really matters to the profession about leadership. When the definitions of clinical leadership are considered, it is interesting that a key theme is the focus on transformational leadership with management virtually ignored. Surely, clinical leadership requires an overt management component given the demands placed on nursing to contribute to the target driven compliance cultures we see proliferating in healthcare? However, we argue that while nursing itself is required to comply, innovation still needs to be kept alive. Therefore, it is our view that clinical leadership needs to embrace both leadership and management overtly. Millward and Bryan (2005 p.xv) embrace both concepts proposing ‘management is about planning, organization and control, while leadership is about the process of influence. It is goal-oriented and inextricably linked with the group or team process’. Our view is that the process of influence needs to be oriented towards nurturing person-centred cultures (Cardiff 2014). Warren Bennis, considered to be a forerunner in the pursuit of understanding leadership, is frequently quoted as saying ‘Leadership is like beauty, it's hard to define but you know it when you see it’ (1989 p.1). In the context of nursing and midwifery practice from our combined practice wisdom, we agree with this statement. When nurses and midwives are engaging with patients and clients providing optimum care (moments of person-centredness) clinical leadership is clearly visible, you know it when you see it and it can be described. If we want nurses and midwives to be clinical leaders then we need to do more to highlight what knowledge, skills and interventions can and should be developed. We acknowledge that much is being done about developing the existing nursing and midwifery workforce regarding effective management for service delivery. However, the future nursing and midwifery workforce needs more overt preparation to become clinical leaders – for the sake of the profession and people receiving care. The development of novice clinical leaders is thus a professional responsibility. In the last editorial in this journal, Patricia Thompson (2016) challenged all of us to become part of the solution to ‘problems’. The solution to this particular problem, we believe needs to be extended to and include nursing and midwifery students. As a profession we need to nurture the next generation and be overt in what we can do to help prepare and support them to become clinical leaders and not simply managers. New graduate nurses and midwives need to be prepared to be more ready to become clinical leaders. This begins with both leading and managing themselves in preparation to lead and manage others. There is ample opportunity to achieve this in pre-registration programmes (Brown, Dewing & Crookes 2016a). Recent research has shown how the antecedents of clinical leadership can be included as curriculum content (Brown, Crookes & Dewing 2016b). In most instances elements of this would already be included in existing preparatory programmes. By scaffolding the curriculum with emancipatory pedagogical learning opportunities, the conditions for enlightenment, empowerment and emancipation can be provided; however, it is not enough to only stratify the curriculum. What students need, like all of us, are appropriate role models who are, through their ways of being, effective leaders in their scope of practice. We need nurses and midwives who bring to life the antecedents and attributes of clinical leadership in the education context as well as those in clinical practice. Our challenge to leaders in all aspects of nursing and midwifery practice, that is clinicians, managers and academics, is to refocus or redirect some attention to nursing and midwifery students and the novice new graduate nurse and midwife to ensure they not only absorb antecedents and attributes of effective management, they also balance this with leadership that enables person-centredness and innovation to thrive (Dewing & McCormack 2016 in press). This we need to attend to with some urgency given the need to have more leaders more quickly.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Brown et al. (2016) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: