Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Hanswurst's PublicDefending the Comic in the Theatres of Eighteenth-Century Vienna Elizabeth Coen (bio) I flatter myself in being a necessary and agreeable citizen in the best comic world, and therefore hope I shall not be banished from thence, as so many fools are suffered to appear therein for the service of the wisest philosophers. justus möser, harlequin: or, a defence of grotesque comic performances In the Age of Enlightenment, a sausage-loving prankster named Hanswurst tormented bourgeois reformers of the German theatre with his exceptional ability to charm audiences.1 Determined to replace extemporized performances with a literary repertoire, these reformers harnessed the press to argue that the harlequin's plays were "without choice, regularity, unity, or harmony" and that they functioned "without plan or design." Moreover, they asserted in a litany of rants recounted by the eighteenth-century historian Justus Möser that such material was "low, creeping, indecent, and foolish!—full of obscene language, filthy allusions, poor flashes of empty wit, and proverbs without number!"2 These invectives helped Hanswurst's detractors curry favor with the literary public, a bourgeois readership from cities across Austria, Prussia, and the German Reich.3 Nevertheless, they failed to persuade the theatregoing public, a populace much larger and more socioeconomically diverse than their own literate circles. Hanswurst's frequent banishments from the stage were almost always followed by reappearances. This was especially true in Vienna. From 1748 until the 1770s, the Viennese debated the cultural legitimacy of Hanswurst and the merits of German-language comedy in a controversy known as the Hanswurststreit.4 [End Page 7] Pointing to the emergence of the bourgeois public sphere, the rise of nations, and the general fervor for moral education in Europe, theatre historians have long perpetuated the narrative that Hanswurst's exile was inevitable. To that end, the writings of bourgeois reformers aptly illustrate what sociologist Norbert Elias calls the "civilizing process." Striving for upward mobility, they cast off the priapic Hanswurst (in English, the name is Jack Sausage) to introduce gentility to the German stage.5 However, this historiography has engendered an unintended consequence. Scholars commonly assume that eighteenth-century publics engaged with cultural and political issues only in the literary public sphere. By expanding the scope of evidence to include the defense of Hanswurst, one finds a significant if neglected story of actors who used the stage to also actuate a public sphere. To take a case in point, Justus Möser contended in his satiric treatise Harlequin: Or, a Defence of Grotesque Comic Performances (1761) that the comic fool was, in fact, a citizen of the theatre and a productive member of society, targeted foolishly by enlightenment devotees. Comic performers in Vienna echoed this argument when they used the city's municipal theatre to not only mock their detractors in operas and plays but also proffer a reasoned defense of their work. They maintained, for example, that Hanswurst's silly form of dress allowed him to say things about Viennese society that otherwise could not be said. Much like the interlocutors of Aristophanic Old Comedy, Hanswurst was a purveyor of "truth" who could speak frankly about issues that directly affected the city. As such, he encouraged laughter at the expense of his bourgeois critics, the aristocracy, and the imperial family. Many of the great German intellectuals of the eighteenth century—Gotthold Ephraim Lessing, Johann Wolfgang von Goethe, Ludwig Tieck—were not indifferent in their writings to the cultural significance of Hanswurst and his ability to offer a social critique.6 Their work has garnered a significant amount of scholarly attention. Still, we know little about the intellectual pursuits of the actors who regularly depicted Hanswurst in repertoires of improvised entertainments.7 With few of their plays and libretti to draw from, scholars bypass the modes and conditions of public engagement encouraged by the German popular stage, to focus instead on the dramatic theories, acting treatises, and plays of bourgeois writers determined to change the conventions of the time. This essay examines the Hanswurst controversy in Vienna and the defense of an art form typically viewed as sociopolitically regressive. I suggest otherwise. Through an analysis of repertory records, performances...
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Elizabeth Coen (2019) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: