Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
As an intern, I took care of a patient who was admitted to the internal medicine service for renal failure. He required a special formula for his IV fluids. I took incredible care with the calculations and reviewed them with my resident and the inpatient pharmacy. The IV fluid bag was hung alongside the patient’s bed, and the fluids would soon be started when my resident grabbed the bag and came over to me. I had made a mistake. The mistake was not whether the patient needed fluids (he did). The mistake was not whether the calculations were right (the numbers were accurate). The mistake, he said, was the amount of fluid (it should have been enough for 1 hour, not 3). My resident explained to me, “You can’t have such a big bag! Anyone could come by and open it up. If that happened, the patient would be flooded.” He took a breath. “It’s OK. We got it.” My resident truly was awesome. And, thankfully, IVs, in most places at least, are no longer bags with simple tubing attached to accessible, manual valves (I was an intern a long time ago). Nevertheless, over the years I have often revisited the lessons of this “mistake moment” so early in my clinical training. My resident taught me at least 4 things. First, do not set up the possibility of an error, especially a consequential error. Second, do not fail to see how one decision, even if technically correct, fits within a larger set of decisions or actions with a range of outcomes, good and bad. Third, do not forget that you are just one person among many, all of whom may have a stake and responsibility, and that you may not be the person who will bear the ultimate consequences of these decisions. And, fourth, when it is for the right reasons and said in a direct and kind manner, it feels OK to be told that you did something that could have gone wrong. Although they often go unrecognized, mistakes in medicine are made every day.1 Misdiagnosis, incorrect treatment, and errors in the delivery of care may have serious negative outcomes and are leading causes of patient mortality.2–4 Making errors is associated at a system level with negative work environments, limited resources, poorly developed infrastructure, insufficient communication supports, and inadequate safeguards of other types, such as protocols for verifying orders when transferring patients or in performing hand-offs.5,6 At the individual’s level, medical mistakes are associated with exhaustion, inexperience, and isolation of clinicians and clinical trainees.7,8 And once a mistake is made, a clinician may feel devastated, incur medicolegal risk, or leave the health care workforce, as has been well documented.9,10 Twenty-five years ago, the Institute of Medicine published a groundbreaking report entitled To Err Is Human: Building a Safer Health System.11 The report included an estimate that nearly 100,000 hospital deaths each year were attributable to medical errors, a revelation with reverberations for the public and for the profession. Beyond raising awareness, the report identified factors and patterns related to when, where, and under what circumstances medical mistakes were likely to occur. The report presented opportunities for preventing medical errors and placed greater accountability on health care organizations and systems, allowing the field to shift from an older paradigm in which errors were not acknowledged or, when they were, were seen as the blame-worthy failings of an individual clinician. The report’s analyses and recommendations laid the foundation for what has become a far-reaching quality and safety movement, with prevention of medical mistakes as one vital aim.12 Scholarship on quality and safety, including exceptional work on the relationship between professional burnout and medical errors,13,14 has accelerated over the past few years. Out of necessity, new insights and novel processes came forward during the pandemic, as systems of care, as well as health professionals, trainees, and essential health workers, were tested to their limits.15–17 Novel opportunities through the application of artificial intelligence to prevent errors, identify potential sources of error, and improve health system functions are very recently being developed and implemented.18,19 More than 150 articles published in our journal related to quality and safety have been assembled in a valuable and rich collection, which can be found on our website.20 This topic also has been the focus of AM Last Pages by Davis et al,21 Holcombe,22 and Schumacher et al.23 In this issue of Academic Medicine, a departmental quality and safety effort is described in an Innovation Report by Hasimja-Saraqini et al.24 My resident’s 4 lessons have held up well over the years. I cannot think of a domain of my life, let alone my professional work, that is not benefitted by this guidance. Do not set up the possibility of a bigger error down the line. Do not fail to see how one decision fits within a larger sequence of decisions or actions. Do not forget that you are one person among many and may not be the one who bears the burden of a poor decision. And communication about potential or actual mistakes can be handled well in a context of trust, kindness, and shared purpose. As I said, my resident truly was awesome.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Laura Weiss Roberts (2024) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: