Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The folding/unfolding pathway of barnase has been analyzed using a method similar to the classical Brønsted-β approach: Φ-value analysis. Kinetic and equilibrium measurements on the folding/unfolding of over 100 designed mutants have led to a residue-by-residue description of the transition state. The transition state responds to mutation and changes in solvent in a manner analogous to both classical Hammond and anti-Hammond behavior as the energy landscape is perturbed. Here, we compare the Φ-value analysis with an explicit structural analysis of the transition state by molecular dynamics simulations of thermal denaturation of wild-type and two mutant forms of barnase. We look for similarities in the results of experiment and simulation to provide a detailed and reliable description of the folding reaction and for differences that could point to deficiencies in the methods. In general, there is excellent agreement between simulation and experiment, with a correlation coefficient of 0.93 between observed and simulated Φ-values for the transition state for unfolding, with the exception of the second helix, α2. In the simulations, wild-type barnase unfolded by disruption of the hydrophobic cores and β-structure, followed by unraveling of the principal α-helix, α1. The Ile 88 → Val mutant unfolded by the same mechanism as the wild-type protein, albeit more rapidly. Tyr 17 is one of the residues that, when mutated, leads to anti-Hammond effects; the helix unfolds earlier, relative to gross unfolding of the rest of the protein. In the simulation of the unfolding of the Tyr 17 → Gly mutant, the main helix unraveled before substantial loss of β-structure, showing more precisely the structural change in the transition state. The major difference between simulation and experiment is that α2 is present in the simulated transition state, but Φ-values suggest that it is unstructured. Although this could result from simulation overestimating the helical content, there is an alternative explanation that reconciles simulation and experiment. The segment of protein containing α2 is autonomous and makes few interactions with the body of the protein in the simulated transition state. If the folding of a segment of the protein is not coupled to the rest of the molecule, then the mutations may not be felt until significant interactions are made between these portions of the protein. Such an effect could occur for any multimodular protein.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Daggett et al. (1998) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: