Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The inclusion of internet gaming disorder (IGD) in the DSM-5 research appendix renews focus upon the conceptualization and assessment of IGD. Problematically, however, although IGD was included because research had highlighted several distinguishing features of the condition, along with the increased risks associated with online gaming 1, these are not reflected adequately in the assessment criteria now stated in DSM-5. Rather, all the criteria listed for IGD in DSM-5 are derived from substance use disorder or gambling disorder, thus neglecting the potentially unique features of problematic online gaming. Games provide a unique context with particular affordances; to understand IGD it is necessary to understand the contexts and motivations for gaming 2. In a recent paper in Addiction, Nancy Petry and colleagues proposed informative descriptions underlying the DSM-5 criteria 1. While this was a much-needed effort, my concerns with the criteria still remain. One reason why gaming cannot simply be likened to either substance use or gambling is that the majority of children and young adults play online games as a hobby, often spending many hours on their gaming. This calls into question criteria such as preoccupation and withdrawal as applied to gaming. For the younger generations, preoccupation with gaming or feeling upset when they cannot participate as much as they would like are not necessarily indicators of pathology 2, 3. In the words of Cover 4, there is a tendency to misread immersion and interactivity as addiction. To delineate hobby use from compulsive use, one might draw upon research on gaming motivations 5, as the literature suggests that social motivations for game play are unproblematic while escapist motivations are more problematic 6, 7, escapism being a crucial mediator between psychosocial problems and excessive online gaming 8. Thus understanding motivations for excessive online gaming is necessary to draw a line between fascination and compulsion—an important step to avoid overdiagnosis. A second problem is that online games are subject to popular moral panics 9, resulting in a tendency for uninitiated adults to perceive gaming as a less worthy activity, introducing a misleading subjective bias into the assessment of IGD. This can be exemplified by online social interaction, which tends to be considered less worthy than offline social interaction despite plenty of research showing that the two are equally worthy, just different 10, 11. Online gaming affords high-quality social interaction both within and beyond the immediate circle of friends. To assume that a loss of interest in meeting friends offline is indicative of pathology is misleading, as social interaction with offline friends frequently takes place online, mediated by a common game. This represents a unique facet of online gaming and highlights one way in which this activity is not comparable to substance use or gambling. Affordances of online games are vital in understanding excessive gaming, but these are not taken into account in DSM-5. A third problem is that some criteria do not make sense in relation to online gaming but seem to be included as residuals from diagnoses for substance use disorder and gambling disorder. For example, the tolerance criterion as applied to gaming suggests that some individuals would feel a need for more exciting games, more powerful media equipment or increase the amount of time spent playing 1. This criterion is unlikely to correspond to gamers' experiences. It reminds me of early instruments for assessing internet addiction which sometimes asked whether a person was stealing money to be able to finance their internet use. This was clearly a residual criterion from gambling disorder that has now disappeared because it lacked merit. Similarly, preoccupation may be important in a gambling context because high frequency of play is associated with increased losses because the odds are stacked against the player, but research shows consistently that high frequency of gaming is not related directly to problematic outcomes 7, 12, 13. Such nuances need to be recognized and considered when new criteria are discussed. What is currently needed is a qualitative inquiry into which criteria are contextually valid in relation to gaming in particular. Comparing across literatures, research on IGD has appropriated criteria from substance use disorder or gambling disorder without considering their contextual relevance. Research on gambling disorder has focused recently on understanding the contexts and motivations for repeated gambling despite negative outcomes, which has improved our understanding of the disorder. Motivations for excessive gaming are equally crucial to consider, as they may tell us more about the underlying problems 2. Such a focus is necessary to guide the search for unique determinants of IGD and will help in constructing a valid assessment instrument that also takes into account the affordances of online games. In short, de-contextualized criteria such as preoccupation, withdrawal and tolerance are unhelpful, while criteria assessing motivations for play should be considered for inclusion. At present, it is unlikely that the criteria will be effective in diagnosis, risking overdiagnosis while not adding to a deeper understanding of the condition. None.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Daniel Kardefelt‐Winther (2014) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: