Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The past century has seen progress in healthcare unheard of in the history of humankind. This development has taken place concurrent with an increase in the global population from about 2 billion at the beginning of the 20th century to above 8 billion at present and was made possible by increasing the use of the earth's resources to such an extent that several so-called planetary boundaries have been overstepped.1 If the trajectory of resource utilisation is not altered we risk destabilising the planet with devastating consequences for the climate and the environment. This will be disastrous for the health of current and future generations through a multitude of interconnected effects on extreme weather events, food security, spread of infectious disease, and heat waves.2 Our axiomatic dependence on our planet was aptly described by the UN secretary Gutierrez when he said that ‘There is no human health without planetary health’. The fulfilment of the Paris agreement and sustainable development goals (SDGs) is therefore essential for the health of future generations, and it follows that we as healthcare providers have a vested interest in sustainability. Paradoxically, healthcare has a significant negative impact on planetary health. On a global scale healthcare contributes to about 5% of net global climate gas emissions; if healthcare was a country it would be the fifth largest greenhouse gas emitter.3 Peri-operative and intensive care are resource-intensive sectors of healthcare and, although incompletely quantified, their climate and environmental footprints are probably substantial.4,5 Consequently, increased sustainability in anaesthesia and intensive care must be a part of the transition to the net zero greenhouse gas emissions required to limit global warming to below the 1.5°C, as stipulated in the Paris Agreement. The need for a change in practice has been recognised for some time and several guidelines and position papers for environmentally sustainable practice have been published by professional societies, including the World Federation of Societies of Anaesthesiologists.6 The abolition of desflurane in many centres is inspiring and shows that we can change practice for environmental reasons. However, for anaesthesia and intensive care to become sustainable and contribute to reaching the goal of net zero greenhouse gas emissions other and more fundamental changes in the provision of care are required. While such changes must involve multiple stakeholders such as governments, international organisations, and the pharmaceutical and medical device industries, it is essential that anaesthetists and intensivists also rise to the challenge. As medical professionals and researchers we are uniquely positioned to identify areas in which we can improve sustainability while preserving quality of care against the backdrop of finite resources. The R's of sustainability (Refuse, Reduce, Recycle, Reuse, Rethink, Research) may serve as a framework for an agenda of change by which anaesthetists and intensivists can contribute. We can Refuse the provision of care which lacks a proven effect/value. Recent data suggest that interventions with limited effects are considerably overused, including the overly liberal use of the intensive care unit (ICU) and operative procedures.7,8 By targeting such interventions, we can achieve both financial and environmental gains. We can also Reduce the environmental impact of necessary and effective procedures in several ways. For example, we can engage in, and take a leading role in, green teams that critically examine procedures and processes on a local level. Such efforts could include relatively simple interventions such as promoting Recycling or Reuse and removing unnecessary items in prepacked kits for surgical procedures.9 Despite a growing body of evidence suggesting that disposable items have a higher environmental impact than reusable items, the use of disposable items is increasing. The underlying reasons are multifactorial and beyond the scope of this editorial. As experts in our field, we should engage in procurement and require that manufacturers provide environmental product declarations to enable informed decisions similar to that already required by law in the building industry in some European countries.10 As clinical experts become involved in procurement, we could also shape procurement specifications to encourage or mandate reusability which will in turn encourage reusable product development. Life cycle assessment (LCA) is a method to assess the environmental impact of a service or a product from the extraction of raw material to the destruction of the product. LCA is increasingly applied to medical products and could be used to inform public procurements. A valuable feature of an LCA is that it can also identify hotspots for environmental impact which can be targeted by interventions. LCA data are now available for several of the drugs and some of the procedures used in anaesthesia and intensive care, enabling us to incorporate environmental sustainability in practice guidelines.11 To incorporate environmental sustainability in practice guidelines we will have to Rethink how we assess the value of healthcare interventions. We should expand the definition of value of an intervention to include effects on patients and on the global population against a bottom line consisting of financial, environmental, and social costs or impacts using a so-called triple bottom line approach.12 The efficacy of many interventions and treatments in anaesthesia and intensive care, which may have considerable side-effects on the general population and on the environment as a whole, is based on low grade evidence. Such treatments include drugs like desflurane, which is about 70 times more potent as a greenhouse gas than sevoflurane for the same anaesthetic effect. Other examples include more complex interventions such as targeted temperature management after cardiac arrests, as well as different hygiene measures that are likely to drive resource consumption in the ICU or operating room.13 A triple bottom line approach could create a framework to assess such interventions. In situations where clinical efficacy is uncertain and a high environmental impact is certain, the intervention should be questioned. However, when an intervention is likely to be effective but has a large environmental footprint the situation becomes more challenging. For such situations, it may be helpful to quantify the environmental impact in a way which would facilitate assessment of the trade-off between clinical and environmental impacts. As suggested previously, such a quantification could be based on the available CO2 budget as defined in the Paris agreement, and could also include measures reflecting other planetary boundaries.12 We should add sustainability as ubiquitous component in our Research agenda. As mentioned above LCAs are increasingly used to assess the environmental impact of healthcare interventions, and are particularly important when marginal to no health gains are expected for patients. However, a recent review of LCA analyses in surgery and in anaesthesia identified methodological heterogeneity and a lack of detailed background data in databases as limitations in the research field.14 As researchers, we need to establish a consensus on the design, analysis, data sharing, and reporting of LCA studies similar to those of the Equator network for other study types in healthcare. In addition to increasing transparency, data sharing of the labour-intensive LCA studies could facilitate sensitivity analyses in which LCA models are adapted to local conditions as well as enable easy reuse of models in further research. Similarly, there is a need to develop methods to incorporate analysis of environmental effects of an intervention into both research ethics assessments and trial design, and to update current trial design guidelines to include an environmental analysis plan.15 Interestingly, the Sustainable Healthcare Coalition recently estimated that the climate footprint of clinical research corresponds to 5% of healthcare's global climate footprint, highlighting the need to consider sustainability of the trials themselves in trial design.16 Finally, we need to Rethink education in anaesthesia and intensive care and include education in sustainability in the training and in continuing medical education. This need is increasingly recognised, and sustainability was recently added to the curriculum of the Royal College of Anaesthetists. We encourage other national and international societies to follow this example. This will allow our specialty to take an active role in the transition to a sustainable healthcare system from the bottom up, for example by taking on leadership in green teams. The magnitude of the task ahead of us is daunting and can be paralysing. No one can do everything, but everyone can do something. The increasing number of publications in the field suggests a growing interest for change in our community, which is very encouraging. By embracing the interconnection between humans and planetary health, as first described by Alexander von Humboldt more than 200 years ago, there is reason to believe that we together can turn danger into opportunity for the benefit of global human health.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Bentzer et al. (2023) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: