Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The experience of living with chronic illness is most often described as life changing by participants in qualitative research. However, over the past three decades, there is disparity among the published literature regarding the experience of living with chronic illness. The chronic illness experience is variously described as - a trajectory, a gift, a career, a cause of chronic sorrow, suffering, uncertainty, loss, a dichotomy between acceptance and denial, and transformational. The chronic illness experience may include all of these understandings, so how do such variations in interpretation come about? We argue that a dearth of longitudinal studies about the chronic illness experience means we only have a snap shot of people’s lives lived with chronic illness. Most studies present a person’s positions at a particular point in time, so we lack the information that informs us of the breadth of that experience over time. Consequently, the literature presents differing interpretations of the chronic illness experience. Living with chronic illness is an ever-changing experience. Chronic illness can take many forms and there is no single pattern of experience even within the same diagnosis. Considerable adjustment and adaptation to daily life is required to incorporate the symptoms and consequences of illness. Life with chronic illness can mean both overt and subtle changes in areas such as employment and income, identity and relationships, parenting, life priorities, and changes to physical, mental, emotional, social and spiritual well-being. Progressive chronic illness in particular requires the individual to adjust to change on a continual basis. Change can be defined as the movement from one state to another, and the ways that people respond to change is the process of transition. The process of learning to live with chronic illness involves the need for transition, requiring people to adjust and modify their responses, behaviours and attitudes to ever-changing life situations. Understanding transition involves exploring the person’s responses to a passage of circumstances and events that demand life adjustment. The focus of health professionals may be disease and symptom control, however, when chronic illness is experienced as change that reshapes all areas of life, it is little wonder that people experience the health professional’s gaze as narrow and fragmented. This narrow gaze, in practice, has influenced the scope of chronic illness research. Making a difference to people living with chronic illness is not just about improved treatment options, it is also about health professionals developing participatory and person-centred approaches to care, so that the particular needs and experiences of individuals are central to the care plan and sensitive to the person’s changing needs. When health professionals understand the transition process and the ways they can help people to incorporate the consequences of chronic illness into their lives, the health professional is able to make a substantial contribution to enabling the person to recognise her/his needs, make informed choices to effectively self-care, and in so doing, develops the person’s capacity to incorporate future changes that accompany most chronic conditions. There is lack of consensus among researchers as to whether the dynamic transition process has a definite beginning and end, or indeed any uniform trajectory, and how it is that health care practitioners can best help people to “move on”. Kralik (2002) suggests that transition is cyclical because change is a constant force in human life. For example Elmberger et al. (2002) describes how men with cancer commence the health/illness transition at diagnosis and the transitional period lasts for several years, experienced in a spiral movement. Likewise, Paterson (2001, 2003), after undertaking a meta-synthesis of 292 qualitative research studies, describes a ‘shifting perspectives’ model of chronic illness that challenges the notion of a linear trajectory in transition. She proposes that living with chronic illness is an ongoing transformational process involving movement in many directions. Glacken et al. (2001) suggests that the transitional process is unique, neither time-bound, nor linear in nature, and the duration and outcomes are different for each individual. It has also been proposed that while many life transitions have a distinct beginning and end, transition for people with chronic illness may be ongoing, as one’s health and wellbeing fluctuates (Shaul 1997). Transition is an ongoing process, which may be cyclical, but is definitely not linear in its progression. It seldom has a clearly defined end point because transition involves ongoing modification to behaviour, attitude, knowledge and action after the change event. This is achieved through transformational activities that may be termed ‘hanging on’ or ‘letting go’ behaviours and actions, such as, incorporating, integrating, adapting, rejecting, deferring, discarding and eliminating, to name a few. Over time, as people learn ways to live with chronic illness, they accumulate an increasing reservoir of experience that becomes a resource for learning. Learning to live with chronic illness can be hard work as people renegotiate meaning in many aspects of their lives, grieve their losses, and attend to the practicalities of treatments/interventions and appointments (Kralik 2002). People do attach meaning to the learning they gain from experiences, even if they were adverse and difficult. It enables some people to embrace their struggle and suffering to say they have gained a depth of wisdom and understanding about life and what is valuable, which is impossible to garner in other ways (van Loon & Kralik 2006). This transformative learning is a part of the transition process. Transformative learning is considered to be the kind of learning people undertake when making meaning of their lives (Cranton 1996). Mezirow (2000) posits that all learning is change but not all change is transformation, because people may not follow transformational processes. Meaning is constructed from acquired knowledge. Transformative learning is triggered by challenge. Transition can be prompted by a person’s own internal dialogue and thinking. We argue that the health professional can facilitate the internal dialogue that facilitates transformative learning by establishing a relational environment that facilitates this thinking, and by providing tools to assist critical reflection and self-understanding. The goal of this transformative learning is to share the activities and experience of meaning-making. Transition takes time as people disengage with what was known and familiar and find new ways to locate themselves in an altered world (Bridges 2004). The health professional can facilitate this process by providing a safe space to listen to the person’s story, so he/she can hear their own words and explore new perspectives on that story. In the dialogue, the person will surface values that they hold and perspectives of themselves that they wish to reclaim, and those they need/want to discard (van Loon & Kralik 2006). This facilitates the required sense making that enables the person to action change. Transitional processes require time, as people gradually disengage from old habits and behaviours and ways of defining themself (Kralik et al. 2006b). This represents a profound departure from the medical model which problematises the disease. We suggest that health professionals may choose to work with people by assisting them to identify the changes forced by illness and seek new possibilities from those experiences. We do not argue that the biomedical discourse is inappropriate or should be replaced, on the contrary, we accept the biomedical discourse focuses on achieving specific health outcomes, rather we argue that discourses that promote health and wellbeing should leave room to explore the impact that transition is having on the person’s condition. Understanding transition will enable health professionals to focus attention on more than the bio-medical aspects of disease, facilitating a holistic understanding of the illness experience which will impact on a person’s wellbeing and health in the midst of chronic illness. Our claim is that the diversity in the interpretation of the chronic illness experience is a result of researchers reporting a snapshot or a moment in time, rather than the expanse of the process of transition. A major limitation of the reported chronic illness research is its short-term focus. The passage of time can be a militating or mitigating factor in transition. As such, longitudinal studies are required to explore experiences that promote transition. Further research is required to enhance our understanding of what services will assist people living with chronic illness through the phases of transition. Gaps in transition research relate to gendered responses to change events, the transitional experiences during an acute episode of illness, the differences in transition across the lifespan, and the specific interventions/ activities that facilitate transition during the various trajectories of chronic illness. Learning to live with chronic illness is an ongoing complex and personal process that can take a long time. The experience of illness is constantly changing and new challenges are generated. We believe that over time, and with the support of health professionals who use sensitive listening and thoughtful conversation, the person who is experiencing the challenges of chronic illness can locate a sense of a coherent and continuous self in a changing world.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Kralik et al. (2009) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: