Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
This paper analyzes the Kayapó's struggle against large-scale hydroelectric development in the Brazilian Amazon. Whereas environmental justice efforts that were launched in the 1980s against a similar dam project were met with success, efforts in the past several years to halt the Belo Monte dam, to date, have not stopped licensing or construction. And in spite of the rise of regional and international indigenous movements, environmental awareness, and the democratic turn in Brazil, the building continues. This paper examines the different processes the Kayapó have used to address environmental justice issues, especially their deployment of identity politics as a resistance strategy to achieve recognitional justice. As the new wave of “participation” as an environmental governance norm places most emphasis on procedural forms of justice, a focus on procedure, such as the participation offered in Environmental Impact Assessment processes, does not adequately address and sometimes masks underlying issues of recognitional injustice. I show that these policies to ensure participation have had uneven impacts, and Kayapó strategies rooted in identity politics have had mixed results in achieving desired goals for justice. At the same time large-scale organized activist and resistance provide a productive counterspace for marginalized communities to create a public record of their concerns, even if the effectiveness of the protests have varied over time. While a continued robust civil society is promising, it remains a concern that despite the rise procedural forms of justice, recognitional justice remains elusive for the Kayapó.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Laura Zanotti (2015) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: