Key result
A six-lead wearable-recorded ECG demonstrated superior diagnostic value for atrial fibrillation detection with 99.2% sensitivity and 98.4% specificity, outperforming single-lead ECG and PPG-based detection in patients with frequent premature contractions.
Why the study?
Wearable technologies for AF detection repeatedly face challenges from frequent premature beats, warranting evaluation of the diagnostic benefit of six-lead ECG compared with single-lead ECG and PPG algorithms.
Does six-lead electrocardiography improve diagnostic accuracy for atrial fibrillation detection compared to single-lead electrocardiography and photoplethysmography in adults with frequent premature contractions?
Case-Control (n=249)
Blinded evaluators
No
Does six-lead electrocardiography improve diagnostic accuracy for atrial fibrillation detection compared to single-lead electrocardiography and photoplethysmography in adults with frequent premature contractions?
A six-lead smartwatch ECG significantly improves atrial fibrillation detection accuracy and reduces false positives compared to single-lead ECG and PPG in patients with frequent premature beats.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
May aid AF detection amid frequent ectopy; leaves open prospective validation before clinical adoption.
Background Smartwatches are commonly capable to record a lead-I-like electrocardiogram (ECG) and perform a photoplethysmography (PPG)-based atrial fibrillation (AF) detection. Wearable technologies repeatedly face the challenge of frequent premature beats, particularly in target populations for screening of AF. Objective To investigate the potential diagnostic benefit of six-lead ECG compared to single-lead ECG and PPG-based algorithm for AF detection of the wrist-worn device. Methods and results From the database of DoubleCheck-AF 249 adults were enrolled in AF group ( n = 121) or control group of SR with frequent premature ventricular (PVCs) or atrial (PACs) contractions ( n = 128). Cardiac rhythm was monitored using a wrist-worn device capable of recording continuous PPG and simultaneous intermittent six-lead standard-limb-like ECG. To display a single-lead ECG, the six-lead ECGs were trimmed to lead-I-like ECGs. Two diagnosis-blinded cardiologists evaluated reference, six-lead and single-lead ECGs as “AF”, “SR”, or “Cannot be concluded”. AF detection based on six-lead ECG, single-lead ECG, and PPG yielded a sensitivity of 99.2%, 95.7%, and 94.2%, respectively. The higher number of premature beats per minute was associated with false positive outcomes of single-lead ECG (18.80 vs. 5.40 beats/min, P < 0.01), six-lead ECG (64.3 vs. 5.8 beats/min, P = 0.018), and PPG-based detector (13.20 vs. 5.60 beats/min, P = 0.05). Single-lead ECG required 3.4 times fewer extrasystoles than six-lead ECG to result in a false positive outcome. In a control subgroup of PACs, the specificity of six-lead ECG, single-lead ECG, and PPG dropped to 95%, 83.8%, and 90%, respectively. The diagnostic value of single-lead ECG (AUC 0.898) was inferior to six-lead ECG (AUC 0.971) and PPG-based detector (AUC 0.921). In a control subgroup of PVCs, the specificity of six-lead ECG, single-lead ECG, and PPG was 100%, 96.4%, and 96.6%, respectively. The diagnostic value of single-lead ECG (AUC 0.961) was inferior to six-lead ECG (AUC 0.996) and non-inferior to PPG-based detector (AUC 0.954). Conclusions A six-lead wearable-recorded ECG demonstrated the superior diagnostic value of AF detection compared to a single-lead ECG and PPG-based AF detection. The risk of type I error due to the widespread use of smartwatch-enabled single-lead ECGs in populations with frequent premature beats is significant.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Bacevičius et al. (2023) conducted a case-control in Atrial fibrillation (n=249). Six-lead electrocardiography (wrist-worn device) vs. Single-lead electrocardiography and photoplethysmography was evaluated on Sensitivity for atrial fibrillation detection (95% CI 95.4-100). A six-lead wearable-recorded ECG demonstrated superior diagnostic value for atrial fibrillation detection with 99.2% sensitivity and 98.4% specificity, outperforming single-lead ECG and PPG-based detection in patients with frequent premature contractions.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: