Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
How has a well-meaning attempt to simplify the capture of safety incidents become an “I’ll Datix you” joke? Electronic Incident Reporting Systems (EIRS) are used in health services worldwide. Datix is used by over 900 organisations in 19 countries. After the horrors of the UK Francis Report, Gosport and other health system failures, services desperately needed an alternative to cumbersome, infrequently used, paper reporting. Professional literature is silent regarding the ‘I’m going to Datix you’ phenomenon (Hazan, 2020), but social media such as twitter reveals the situation in many health services worldwide. Recent twitter threads on ‘being Datix'd’ revealed Datix abuse that ultimately undermines EIRS and thus patient safety and care. ‘Wearing jeans on a Saturday when I called to see a post-op patient.’ ‘Not fully closing a door.’ ‘Wasp in bay #2.’ ‘Not supporting night nurses concerned about a possible ghost.’ ‘Eating chocolates in the ward intended for nurses.’ Such Datix inanities highlight why many health professionals avoid using Datix (Johnson, 2016). Yet the ‘ludicrous Datix’ is not merely absurd but instructive. In a poor culture with toxic relationships, such reports reveal underlying communication and relationship problems. Good clinicians and managers recognise the situation and mediate directly with staff, ‘behind the Datix wall’. EIRS cannot substitute for adult, professional relationships and communication that must be learned, nurtured, enabled, modelled and supported. If nurses respond to legitimate Datix reports about patient safety or unhealthy workplace cultures with defensiveness, personalised ‘hurt feelings’ or tit-for-tat Datix reports, they are failing as surely as any EIRS can. ‘It is 100% about blame because that’s how we’ve chosen to use it.’ ‘Heard today, ‘They’ll Datix us if we don't’...So sad to see it still used as a weapon.’ ‘Abuse has tarnished Datix.’ Every nurse manager seeing Datix reports could supplement this litany of ludicrousness. We learned from colleagues of Datix reporting anything about the workplace that people disliked. For staff wanting perceptions or prejudices validated, Datix was the perfect venting vehicle. ‘If it's not Datixed it didn't happen’ or ‘if it's not Datixed, it's not real’, can be dangerous maxims if their corollaries become unproblematic ‘facts’ – if it was Datixed, then it definitely happened as described. Datix as a veiled threat says more about organisational cultures than about any IT system. It is incompatible with a, ‘learning from errors’, ‘no blame’ or ‘just culture’, to have the primary safety alert system used to target individuals for perceived slights or wrongdoing. Nurses must face the unpalatable recognition that they may be responsible for most of this misuse. Given nurses’ historical position as a powerless group, it is understandable when they resort to a reporting mechanism with a guaranteed management response. Doctors or senior managers have greater access to channels of influence than a Registered Nurse (RN) and do not need Datix when they can readily influence matters in other ways. Rather than bemoaning nurses’ individual Datixing instances, organisations could create compassionate, safe and respectful cultures (West et al., 2020) where the nursing voice is valued and visible. Unfortunately, we learned that nurses and junior medical staff seem more ‘harshly dealt with’ in Datix reports, perhaps because managers regularly ‘make an example’ of less powerful staff than a star surgeon or a Trust's executive. One tweet from a junior doctor reported ‘being Datix'd’ and receiving her first ‘formal complaint’ from a Senior Nurse after a patient had the wrong wristband. The manager's blame logic was that ‘it had to be her’. Apparently my eyebrows shown above my mask looked 'aggressive'. Called to elderly lady with skull bleed. Told nurse to bleep for help. Found him Datixing that he had poor handover and not told re; falls risk. I said this is not the time to be Datixing as we had an acutely unwell patient. Later found I had been Datixed for stopping him Datixing. This phenomenon of paperwork or computer time taking precedence over actual care is not new. We can only speculate regarding the percentage of nurses’ time spent in compliance, target-meeting and documentation as opposed to direct care and its vital recording, what Sir Stephen Moss famously called, ‘feeding the regulatory beast’ (Agnew, 2012:24). It would be a travesty if Datix became another compliance drain, distracting nurses from care and engagement and exacerbating documentation and reporting becoming proxies for care recorded, but never actually given. Nurses told that they were putting in too many Datix reports. In future their manager would decide which ones to submit. I was once hauled into an office by my manager and told to stop completing Datix for staff shortages because it makes her look bad. I sent in a genuine safety Datix but this was opposed by the Ward Manager who took it as a personal attack on her Unit and its staff. I have experienced the same issue with ‘moderate harm’ incidents being downgraded by managers to avoid external scrutiny. strategic defence routines, used to pretend that learning has occurred when in actuality there has been little understanding (Gray & Williams, 2011:439). Having discussed and considered this event, the systemic, structural, cultural and political forces that enabled such a potentially dangerous situation to arise are now clear. The overarching lesson learned is the need to continue to work with colleagues to fundamentally change the systems and cultures within which we operate for the benefit of safer and better patient care. Genuine learning cannot occur within a climate of ‘If you don't do what I like or want, I will Datix you’. Discussions with many nurse manager colleagues suggest that collegial conversation and discussion have been supplanted by Datix reporting. Where feedback is erratic or non-existent, such reports and any ‘lessons learned’ lodge at senior management levels and opportunities for change are lost. Any cultural shift from collegiality to semi-secretive condemnation is profound and disturbing. Being unknowingly ‘Datix'd’ until personally summoned to account is at odds with any open, collaborative, incident alert system. Datix feedback is often perceived as a guilty or not guilty verdict rather than a safety learning moment that may prevent a dangerous recurrence. An organisation lacking a learning organisation ethos in any other dimension of its culture, cannot be expected to learn from Datix or any EIRS. So many innovations seem ideal in principle but Datix and other EIRS are only as good as their organisational cultures. Datix may not improve an organisational culture but reflect it. Where a workplace culture is healthy, open, collegial, engaged, non-hierarchical, driven by a desire to improve and where genuine supportive mechanisms for staff exist, Datix may help everyone contribute to improvement. Datix is used well in some settings, where genuine events are recorded, perhaps even collegially and jointly by nurses and other health professionals involved, where nurses model and exemplify safe, compassionate leadership and where healthy feedback and discussions enable learning and subsequent practice improvement (West et al., 2020). Where a culture is the opposite; riven by hierarchies, petty jealousies and conflicts, mutual suspicions and tensions around race, gender or class, Datix may only stoke such a culture. Systemic and entrenched bullying within healthcare from boardroom to bedside is a health care reality (Darbyshire et al., 2019). Datix threats to blame and shame may be yet another example of contemporary workplace bullying. Datix reports have been used not only to coerce peers and subordinates, but to initiate unsubstantiated ‘bullying investigations’ into nurses who had the temerity to ask staff to actually do their job. Apparently Datix is an equal opportunity abuse tool. Numerous human and cultural factors contribute to Datix's misuse by clinicians and managers. EIRS are a technology to report an adverse event or potential danger, not a tool to manipulate colleagues. A computerised form simply cannot ‘manage’ critical incidents, near misses and other serious patient safety concerns while also addressing staff incivility, interprofessional or interdepartmental tensions, staff health and safety concerns, toxic cultures, staffing shortages and more. One of the most frustrating features of Datix abuse is that health services do not have to be like this. ‘Death by Datix’ is unlikely to survive in a compassionate culture where curiosity is more valued than culpability. The literature has shown for decades that punitive, hierarchical, command and control (Khatri et al., 2009), blame systems can never successfully address quality and safety concerns. Numerous examples https://improvement.nhs.uk/resources/just-culture-case-profiles/ show, however, how health services, leaders and managers have transformed their cultures into successful, productive, compassionate, ‘just cultures’. In such a ‘just culture’, disciplinary ‘hearings’ are reduced and staff feel safe and supported in discussing and mutually learning from, ‘when care doesn't go to plan’ https://improvement.nhs.uk/documents/3590/Merseycarejustculture.pdf (p. 3), rather than focusing on reporting someone who has done the wrong thing. Mersey Care NHS Foundation Trust, for example, has garnered deserved praise and recognition for its cultural transformation (See Mersey Care video at: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bu9yhdOegm8). There can be no healthy patient safety culture where Datix or other EIRS are trivialised and weaponised. Nurses at every level can support and enable the blame free culture where nurses use Datix to genuinely promote patient safety. Given what we know about the failure of blame and fear cultures, the success of ‘just’ learning cultures and the impact that principled, compassionate, courageous nurses can have, the only question facing nurses and health services now is not ‘what can we do about this’? but ‘what are we waiting for’? No ethics approval required as this is an Editorial commentary paper. No author declares any conflict of interest in relation to any aspect of this paper.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Maxton et al. (2021) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: