Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Sperm motility is one of the three fundamental tenets of semen analysis providing diagnostic and prognostic information for both natural and assisted reproduction technology (ART) conception. The landmark papers of John MacLeod and Ruth Gold demonstrated clear differences between subfertile and fertile men in sperm motility (MacLeod and Gold, 1951) which have been confirmed by a plethora of subsequent studies (Barratt et al., 2011). The WHO new reference values for motility, as well as sperm concentration (Cooper et al., 2010), are remarkably similar to those proposed by MacLeod and Gold in 1951 (32% motile cells as a 5% centile of a fertile population), suggesting that these observations are robust. The primary conclusion from all these studies is that although there is no magic number or threshold for in vivo fertility, at the lower ends of the motility spectrum, there are significantly higher chances of subfertility (Fig. 1). This overwhelming body of clinical information ignited a series of studies developing new methods to obtain sperm kinematic data. Initial information was very encouraging, e.g. using the biological endpoints of penetration of cervical mucus (Mortimer et al., 1986). With the advent of computer-assisted semen analysis (CASA) machines, making kinematics more widely available, there was an explosion in studies reporting the relationship of quantitative motility and kinematic parameters with conception in vivo (Barratt et al., 1992), in donor insemination (Irvine and Aitken, 1986), in IUI (Bollendorf et al., 1996), IVF (Liu et al., 1991) and even ICSI (Van den Bergh et al., 1998). However, in the last 15 years, there have been a paucity of further studies perhaps due to the limitations in CASA technology but more likely due to the perceived lack of clinical need following the development of ICSI. Data adapted and interpreted from Hargreave and Elton (1983) who studied in vivo conception in 867 subfertile couples. Note the effective plateau in conception rates with higher concentrations of motile cells and reduced per cent conception below ∼2 million motile cells/ml (blue bar). Importantly, small changes in the concentration of motile cells, e.g. from 0.5 to 1 million/ml, can have a noticeable effect on the chances of conception. This is the zone where small changes in the proportion of motile cells, for example, with in vitro drug stimulation can have a noticeable effect on fertility. These data are consistent with many other studies in the literature. Another clinically relevant aspect of sperm motility research that has apparently been shelved in the archives is the potential for in vitro enhancement of motility using a wide variety of drugs that target phosphodiesterases (PDEs) and increase [cAMP]. Simplistically, increasing the number of functional cells at the site of fertilization would appear to be a rational objective (Fig. 1). Historically, the most widely used drug was pentoxifylline where results were encouraging in both IVF and IUI (Yovich et al., 1990; Stone et al., 1999). However, the lack of recent research is particularly noticeable in the context of the overwhelming progress on specific (third generation) PDE inhibitors. While targeting of PDE5 is not likely to be very useful (Lefièvre et al., 2000), there are a number of new-generation PDE inhibitors available that may positively influence sperm function. It is of course not just PDEs that require investigation and the modification of other enzymes, e.g. kinases and phosphatases, will provide a wealth of interesting data. In contrast to the above, which could be described as sleeping giants of ‘clinical andrology’, there has been breathtaking progress in the understanding of sperm motility in the research laboratory, largely brought on by developments in technology: patch clamping, imaging and the rudimentary synergy of mathematics/physics with sperm biology (systems biology of sperm). A primary example is the role of Ca2+ in regulating the activity of the flagellum. Central to this has been the discovery of CatSper channels and elucidation of their role(s) in sperm function. In mice, the main source of Ca2+ entry for hyperactivation appears to be via pH-dependent CatSper channels in the plasma membrane of the flagellar principal piece. These channels are essential for male fertility as sperm from CatSper null mice are motile but unable to hyperactivate, rendering them unable to migrate to or within the oviduct and unable to fertilize oocytes even by IVF (Ren et al., 2001; Carlson et al., 2003; Quill et al., 2003). CatSper channels are also present in the flagellum of human cells, and very recently, two independent studies have demonstrated that induction of Ca2+ entry into human sperm by progesterone is at least partly via CatSper channels (Lishko et al., 2011; Strünker et al., 2011). There is also strong evidence for the presence of stored Ca2+ in mammalian sperm and for the contribution of stored Ca2+ to the regulation of flagellar activity (Costello et al., 2009). For example, Park et al. have recently provided evidence that prostasomes (prostate-derived membrane vesicles present in semen) provide Ca2+-signalling tools to ejaculated sperm. These prostasome-delivered components prolonged hyperactivation of human sperm by progesterone, apparently by mediating release of stored Ca2+ (Park et al., 2011). This complexity of control should lead us to query whether everything that we define as hyperactivation is the same—do different sources of Ca2+ (CatSper channels and stored Ca2+) contribute to similar changes in flagellar activity and force generation—or do they do different things? Concordant with the pivotal role of calcium in hyperactivation and sperm function, several clinical studies have suggested an association between a low responsiveness to progesterone (in terms of intracellular calcium) and sperm dysfunction leading to reduced fertility (Krausz et al., 1996). As we begin to understand the processes by which sperm respond to progesterone and other agonists, we can expect to understand the basis of impaired functioning in cells that do not respond—and hopefully apply it in a clinical setting. Where else might we hope to see similar rapid progress in the coming years? Exciting and potentially clinically important areas would include: Understanding the mechanism of force generation by the sperm flagellum, the way that flagellar activity is regulated and the functional significance of the patterns of motility that result from this regulation presents a diversity of technical and conceptual problems that require the application of a wide range of complementary techniques and disciplines (Fig. 2). Our aim must be to generate a comprehensive model for how sperm swim and how that swimming is controlled. Here we bring together a number of reviews and speculative commentaries from leading scientists in the field. These include an overview of how turning and directional swimming may be controlled in sperm (Yoshida and Yoshida, 2011), the importance for motility of sperm phosphatases and their regulation of the phosphorylation status of sperm proteins (Fardilha et al., 2011), use of patch clamp to understand regulation of key flagellar ion channels (Kirichok and Lishko, 2011), theoretical analysis of how sperm Ca2+ signals are generated and shaped (Olson et al., 2011), new imaging approaches to investigating and understanding the nature and regulation of sperm motility and flagellar bending in three dimensions (Guerrero et al., 2011), the components of the flagellum and how they generate force (Inaba, 2011) and how this force is reflected in movement of the sperm through viscous media (Kirkman-Brown and Smith, 2011). How are flagellar bends formed and propagated and how do second messengers, kinases and phophatases control and regulate this? How does the motility we see in vitro and measure with CASA relate to activity and transport of the cells in the female tract? How does swimming in three dimensions differ to swimming near a surface? Chemotaxis in mammalian sperm: does it occur and does it play a role in fertilization? What level of behavioural flexibility does a sperm have? Does it need to do different things to penetrate the zona and to progress through mucus? How? Schematic illustration showing the diversity of processes that contribute to flagellar activity and sperm behaviour and the diversity of technical approaches that are being applied. Illustrations are derived from the papers in this special issue. Primary regulation of flagellar beating is probably through phosphorylation and dephosphorylation of axonemal proteins through the activities of kinases and phosphatases, which in turn are under the regulatory influence of second messengers. Some aspects of the complexity of sperm [Ca2+]i signalling (an area which has seen considerable recent advance—see text) are shown, as is the influence of viscosity and characteristics of complex fluids at the micro scale. Changes in flagellar waveform and beat frequency bring about complex changes in the behaviour of the cell. SOCs, store-operated Ca2+ channels. The six images (clockwise from top left) were reproduced from Kirichok and Lishko (2011), Olson et al. (2011), Guerrero et al. (2011), Yoshida and Yoshida (2011), Kirkman-Brown and Smith (2011) and Fardilha et al. (2011) all published in the August issue of MHR. The last few years have been very exciting and it is likely that there is a lot more to come. Some of the sleeping giants may be waking up.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Publicover et al. (2011) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: