Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Scientific publications are and will continue to be a measure of success in academic medicine. We often hear the phrase “publish or perish.” This phrase may hold some truth about the realities of academic medicine; however, we must also recognize that women and men can contribute to medicine in many other ways. Many leaders in the field have contributed meaningfully by implementing curriculum improvements, providing compassionate and excellent patient care, and performing administrative duties. However, when delivering an important lecture, we are all introduced by the number of our publications (“Dr. Duma has published X articles and will talk about...”). Gender inequalities continue to prevail in medicine, and they must be brought to the attention of our colleagues and institutions. In 2017, for the first time, the majority of medical student matriculates were women. However, there continues to be a low representation of women in leadership positions and a lower proportion of women achieving promotion to full professorship. Many theories have been suggested regarding the cause of these inequalities, from a “leaky pipeline” to women wanting to spend more time at home. Data from the American Association of Medical Colleges (AAMC) revealed significant differences in the rates of promotion to associate professor between women and men; many factors can contribute to this disparity, including the number of publications by the ascending assistant professor. Several observational studies have reported a confidence gap between women and men in medicine. Confidence is a measure of self-assuredness in one’s abilities and judgments and power and freedom from doubt about these abilities. Our confidence level can directly contribute to our academic promotion pathway and other academic pursuits, including scientific publications. Carnes et al described the effects of societal perceptions of how women and men should behave and how confidence in women can be seen as a negative trait. Women in medicine often pay penalties for stepping outside of these gender norms. Other studies have demonstrated that women—but not equivalently trained men—who self-promote have fewer successful professional opportunities and that the presence or absence of bragging is given more weight than competence in hiring decisions for women. Women need to ask: Are we advocating enough for ourselves? Is self-advocacy seen as self-promotion in women? Furthermore, are these gender stereotypes diminishing the number of opportunities presented to women in medicine? Academic medicine poses further stresses for female physicians. Female physicians experience all the stressors that their male colleagues face, but deal with additional stressors unique to them. For example, female physicians are more vulnerable to verbal abuse and physical assault by patients as well as other health care workers compared with their male counterparts. Despite these challenges, female physicians are significantly more likely than their male counterparts to pursue academic careers. However, the number of female physicians who advance to senior ranks is much lower than for men, resulting in too few role models for female physicians and inadequate mentoring opportunites. Consequently, there is a sense of isolation and a lack of a supportive network for female physicians. Equal opportunities and training in gender bias are necessary to level out the playing field for current and future female physicians and scientists. In the last 15 years we have seen an increase in research that examines gender equity and balance in medicine, with a particular focus on scholarly productivity. A few survey studies have reported that female faculty were less likely to publish academic papers than their male counterparts, whereas other studies have found no gender-based differences in scholarly productivity. Jagsi et al conducted a 35-year review study in 2006 and showed that although the proportion of women among both first and senior physician authors of original research in the United States had increased during the study’s 35-year interval, women still represented a minority of the authors of original studies and guest editorials. Gender differences in publication rates as first or senior authors have been reported in predominantly female specialties, such
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Narjust Duma (2020) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: