Key result
This editorial emphasizes the urgent need for systemic quality improvement in the diagnosis and transfer of patients with acute type A aortic dissection across the UK, driven by patient perspectives.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Systemic quality improvement, guided by patient experiences and standardized toolkits, is urgently needed to address widespread preventable harm in the diagnosis and management of acute type A aortic dissection.
The recent Association for Cardiothoracic Anaesthesia and Critical Care (ACTACC) audit of the diagnosis and transfer of patients with acute type A aortic dissection [1] is an important and timely contribution. The findings quantify many of the known issues around the initial management of this condition and compliment those of the Collaborative Acute Aortic Syndrome Project (CAASP) [2]. The principle finding, that almost half of all patients are failed by pathways and processes, underlines the urgent need for substantial quality improvement. Some findings might cause significant concern among patients and the public, because there is clear evidence of widespread preventable harm. For example, misdiagnosis is too frequent and it takes too long (approximately 12 h) to get from the emergency department to an operating theatre for definitive care. Clinicians also sometimes prescribe potent anticoagulants wrongly, which makes an already high-risk operation even more dangerous. Patients are transferred around regions in ambulances without appropriate monitoring, without blood pressure control and most of the time without a qualified medical escort. These patients need a time-critical CT scan and then complex major surgery at a specialist centre. Sometimes, even when the CT scan is done in a timely manner and interpreted correctly, it is not clear who should be contacted, and there might be no ICU or operating theatre capacity at the receiving site. Each hour that passes causes complications, morbidity and, sometimes, mortality. The perspective of acute aortic dissection from a patient and a patient's family relative is in Box 1. Patient stories are a continuous improvement tool which can help highlight areas of a healthcare service where there is need to improve the quality of services. By listening and learning from the patient (and their families) clinicians are better equipped to transform patient and carer experience. Rather than focusing on the deficits within our healthcare systems, this editorial focuses on the lived patient experience together with the quality improvement work done by the Aortic Dissection Charitable Trust and others. Edward: “On a Monday morning around 7 am, I was in the gym which was not unusual. I developed symptoms of a heart attack while doing leg weight exercises. An ambulance was called, I was transferred to the hospital quickly, the diagnosis was made and I was operated on by a specialist in aortic dissection. I was fortunate that this hospital had an aortic team who were able to perform an emergency repair of my type A aortic dissection. Although I was conscious, I do not remember events running into my procedure until I woke from surgery. The operation was a success, and I am very lucky to be alive.” Catherine: “My father was a fit, healthy 69-year-old man. While in a meeting, Dad became suddenly unwell, with severe and sudden onset of pain in his back, chest and abdomen. Some might say that being a man and over the age of 65, Dad could fit the stereotypical profile of an aortic dissection patient and although Dad had all the classical documented symptoms of aortic dissection and was admitted with 10/10 pain, after 9 hours in the Emergency Department he was discharged with a misdiagnosis of gastritis. Two hours later Dad returned, again in terrible pain, and although aortic dissection was detected on a FAST scan and the team called for a CT scan to confirm the diagnosis, there was a 5 hour wait before they were ready to take Dad for his CT. Dad's aorta ruptured while the CT scan was taking place. The team now had their diagnosis, type B aortic dissection with rupture. The team managed to resuscitate Dad and arranged for an ambulance transfer to a specialist centre. My Dad arrested while the anaesthetic was being administered. Nevertheless, the team decided to intervene, Dad's aorta was successfully repaired, but they were unable to resuscitate my father. Expert review confirmed that had the diagnosis been made when Dad was first admitted and he had been transferred to the specialist centre, there was a 90% chance he would have survived. Although the situation was more severe on Dad's second admission, the expert view was that had a CT scan and transfer taken place, Dad's chances of survival would have been greater than 51%.” Further perspectives from Edward (patient): “My type A aortic dissection repair required aortic valve replacement and replacement of my aortic root and ascending aorta. For two years I have had constant monitoring of my valve and aorta. Although I have suffered a stroke since the procedure, I have made a good recovery from this and thankfully have suffered no other side effects. I have maintained a healthy lifestyle and feel very healthy and capable, both physically and mentally. At the time of writing of this piece, a monitoring CT scan has highlighted that I have developed complications requiring further surgery. I had no symptoms before the CT scan. When told the news, I felt mainly disappointment. Unlike when I had the emergency aortic dissection which was mostly anger. Disappointment given I am very focused on my mental and physical health, yet still require further surgery. However this time is it is elective, a necessary surgery with all the necessary preparation for a successful operation and I believe a quicker and better recovery.” Diagnosing acute type A aortic dissection correctly presents well-described challenges for acute and emergency clinicians [3]. The answer to some might seem obvious, but studies such as the Diagnosis of Acute Aortic Syndrome in the Emergency Department (DAShED) [4] and Acute Aortic Syndrome Evidence Synthesis (ASES) [5] show that simple solutions, such as over investigation (specifically with low a threshold for CT scanning) are not necessarily the answer. Any solution is likely to be less about complex diagnostic methods, medical machinery, equipment or individual clinical skill and more about communication, teamwork and system design. It will be worrying for patients that this condition, albeit rare, does not seem to be a priority for quality improvement in the same way that other serious and time-critical disorders are, such as myocardial infarction and stroke. Hopefully, work by the Aortic Dissection Charitable Trust will provide some hope that changes are coming. The Aortic Dissection Charitable Trust is working with NHS England in implementing the acute aortic dissection toolkit [6]. The document was published in 2022, which came after the data collection period used by Gilbey et al. [1]. Feedback to the Aortic Dissection Charitable Trust from patients matches those views reported in the literature, which is that patients accept the need for transfer to specialist hospitals for specialist care [7]. Communication between referral and treating centres, timely transfer and patient safety during transfer are all areas ripe for substantial improvement. The NHS England toolkit includes these factors in its seven key principles along with the need for regional governance, rotas, education and meetings. The overall aim is specialist treatment for all acute aortic dissections, regardless of where the patient first presents. One clear conclusion from this new study [1] is that there are many low hanging fruits where small improvements made will contribute significantly to improved outcomes for patients. The requirement is to make this transfer process as effective, timely and safe as possible, but achieving these aims will not be easy. Improving the precision of the diagnosis of acute aortic dissection requires more than a high degree of suspicion, education and awareness. It is naive to suggest that emergency department physicians do not know the presenting symptoms of aortic dissection and that education and awareness alone will be enough. The challenge arises because similar symptoms are reported by patients with other much more common diagnoses, such as (but not limited to) acute coronary syndrome; gastro-oesophageal reflux; pulmonary embolism; and panic attacks [8]. Increasing clinician knowledge alone is unlikely to have a substantial impact but improving knowledge of the pathophysiology of acute aortic dissection and why it can give rise to such a wide range of symptoms may help. There are issues around ‘message fatigue’, with awareness campaigns reaching a point of saturation. Therefore, there is a need to ‘design out’ the need for exceptional human performance, which usually results in blame, shame and calls for clinicians to ‘try harder’, ‘be more aware’ or ‘take more care’ [9]. Education and training are known to be the least effective methods to improve systems, and we should look instead to how we design environments, equipment and pathways. This requires more attention from national bodies, hospitals, departments and multidisciplinary teams. Our hope is that the NHS England toolkit does just that. Improvement in diagnosis will require a multifactorial and multidisciplinary approach towards changing systems and culture. At Hull Royal Infirmary, since the implementation of a quality improvement bundle, the emergency department team has missed no cases of acute aortic dissection and achieved a 100% detection rate, with time to CT scan cut by > 1 h [10]. Its enhanced diagnostic detection techniques move beyond ‘being more aware’ by focusing on: actionable strategies; harnessing lived experiences; embracing human factors; understanding complexity and team performance; building high performance teams; psychological safety; and installing a just, rather than a blame, culture. Even with improvements seen in 30-day mortality from 53% to 67%, the work here is not yet complete. Next steps include: ambulance service training; triage nurse training; data collection; and a comprehensive education programme. The problem for other departments and hospitals is that, just as we have seen previously with other patient safety initiatives [11], it can be difficult to implement the methods used in one centre and achieve the same results elsewhere. This might be frustrating for patients and relatives of patients treated in a region with poorer systems, practices and outcomes when others have shown that a significant proportion of morbidity and mortality seen is entirely preventable. Similarly, patients might also be concerned that the recommendations provided by Gilbey et al. [1], although seeming to be entirely reasonable, may find many barriers to widespread implementation. The NHS England toolkit addresses areas for improvement from the point of diagnosis to definitive treatment of aortic dissection. This is an area where the need for regional cooperation and interdisciplinary working is a ‘must’, because it makes the best use of available resources and puts the needs of the patient at the centre of the process. An important recent development is the involvement of adult critical care transfer services for patients with acute aortic dissection, categorising their urgency alongside cases of stroke requiring thrombectomy, subarachnoid haemorrhage and thrombocytopenic purpura [12]. For patients surviving an acute aortic dissection, the journey has only just started. This is a lifelong condition that requires specialist follow up and, for some, further intervention (Box 1). While guidance on follow up for patients with aortic dissection is established [13], we know that there is great variability in its application in the UK. We are pleased that having lobbied the Secretary of State for Health and Social Care, NHS England is commissioning work to develop an elective toolkit for aortic dissection to sit alongside the acute toolkit. Together, implementation of these toolkits will make a substantial contribution to shaping a safer future for all those affected by aortic dissection. Acute type A aortic dissection mimics other serious and benign disorders, and definitive management can be provided only in a small number of specialist cardiothoracic centres. It is clear from this new national audit of practice [1] that pathways and processes do not work currently for doctors, hospitals, patients or the public. Patients are reliant on systems which enable precise and timely diagnosis, and transfer to specialist centres; the NHS England toolkit now does just that. There are comparisons here to be drawn with trauma management standards from several decades ago, where patients died needlessly through a lack of joined up patient-centred care pathways, inadequate institutional preparedness and poorly performing teams. The Aortic Dissection Charitable Trust aims to channel the real-life impact of past and current healthcare standards on real patients to improve care for the patients of the future. It is a certainty that patients with acute type A aortic dissection will continue to present to emergency departments across the UK and we know how to provide the best care to avoid preventable harm. The challenge now is to reduce unwarranted variation [14] and eliminate the need for ‘if only’ discussions between surgeons and bereaved families, where ‘standard’ care before surgery would have led to a much better outcome. EM is a patient and at the time of writing and revising the editorial, was recovering from major redo aortic surgery. MC is an Editor of Anaesthesia. No other competing interests declared.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Montgomery et al. (2024) conducted an editorial in acute type A aortic dissection. This editorial emphasizes the urgent need for systemic quality improvement in the diagnosis and transfer of patients with acute type A aortic dissection across the UK, driven by patient perspectives.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: