Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Criteria for assessing the presence and severity of emphysema have varied in previous studies, making comparisons between different surveys impractical. By using a simple subjective grid method applied to paper-mounted whole lung sections, emphysema was quantitated to a practical degree of reproducibility by and between different observers when interobserver differences were no greater than intraobserver differences. Both such differences were small; however, because they may not be random and because one observer may tend to score consistently lower than another, material should preferably be randomized initially and read by a panel before differences in the quantity of emphysema in lungs from different sources can be considered real. Arbitrary solutions are offered for instances that involved difficulty in interpretation.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Ryder et al. (1969) studied this question.