This is the authors' abstract. We don't add key points for this paper.
Although abortions have been conducted for thousands of years, the subject typically raises some highly polarised views, both within society, women and the medical profession. The first written description of abortion appears in the ancient Egyptian medical text, the Ebers Papyrus (ca. 1550 BCE), where it is suggested that abortion could be induced using a plant-fibre tampon coated with a compound that included honey and crushed dates. Indeed, most of the early references to abortion technique utilised pharmacologic methods, typically herbs such as silphium (an extinct plant from North Africa) and pennyroyal (mentha pulegium), or physical techniques such as massage or abdominal binding. Surgical abortion was not common until the end of the 19th century, when the German gynaecologist Alfred Hegar developed a series of bougies to dilate the cervical canal. Societal and legislative attitudes to abortion have varied across history and among nations. Legal intervention in regard to abortion initially was based on lack of consent by the woman's husband (who would be deprived of a child), rather than any ethical issue related to loss of fetal life. The Greek philosopher Aristotle made the distinction between fetal life as the timing of fetal movement perception, and based the ‘lawfulness’ of abortion on ‘quickening’. The concept of fetal movement perception (quickening) defining the transition from abortion being a crime or not persisted from ancient Greek culture into Western civilisation. English Common Law accepted this model until 1837, when the significance of quickening was abolished. A century later in 1929, the Infant Life Preservation Act was passed in Britain, which decriminalised abortion if it was carried out in good faith, for the sole purpose of preserving the life of the mother. This legal modification was further reinforced in 1938 with Rex v. Bourne, in which the court set a precedent that medical practitioners could not be prosecuted for performing an abortion in cases where pregnancy could result in maternal physical or psychological harm. Further, in 1967, the British government passed the Abortion Act with the aim of reducing the risks of illegal abortion. The Abortion Act allowed for legal abortion to prevent permanent injury to the woman's physical or mental health, to avoid injury to the physical or mental health of the woman if the pregnancy was <28-weeks' gestation, or if the child was likely to be severely physically or mentally handicapped. Abortion law varies greatly throughout the world, with some countries having very restrictive legislation or even banning pregnancy termination. However, such legislative restrictions do not prevent abortion and may cause women to seek unsafe abortion provision or travel to other countries to procure a pregnancy interruption. Indeed, it has been estimated that in developing countries, five million women may be hospitalised annually due to unsafe abortion.1 Further, unsafe abortion has been estimated to account for 13% of total maternal mortality globally, with the most common cause of death being septic shock with multi-organ failure.2 These deaths are preventable by the provision of safe, accessible abortion care and, most importantly, the prevention of unwanted pregnancies by appropriate health service infrastructure and adequate contraceptive services. Needless to say, the concept of abortion is distressing to most – a central role of reproductive healthcare providers is to ensure that woman have ready access to safe and effective contraception to minimise unwanted pregnancies. We have not performed well to date – it is estimated that 80 000–90 000 abortions are performed annually in Australia (although no accurate national data are collected).3 The reasons for unplanned pregnancies are highly variable and not restricted to lack of contraceptive use – indeed, in a study of >3400 women presenting to an abortion provider in South Australia, 67% of women were using a form of contraception at the time of conception.4 Additionally, in this study, 90% of women were provided with contraception following abortion by the pregnancy termination service provider. It is simplistic to expect that all pregnancies will be planned and that contraception will always be effective. The World Health Organization reports that the use of modern contraception has resulted in a lowering of the incidence of abortion, although contraception alone cannot entirely eliminate women's need to access to safe abortion services.5 There are multiple factors, acting in isolation or together, that modify access to, and use of, effective contraception, such as inadequate education and information about contraceptive options, costs, relationship inequality and geography. In a survey assessing the contraceptive knowledge of tertiary students in far North Queensland, significant deficiencies were revealed, with the authors suggesting a need for improved sex education and contraceptive advice services to reduce the incidence of unplanned pregnancies.6 In this issue of ANZJOG, Caroline de Costa and colleagues provide a detailed review of Australian abortion law.7 The wide variation in abortion legislation between the states and territories in Australia is clearly demonstrated in this publication and can be a source of uncertainty and concern for those involved in the provision of reproductive health care. A national legislative approach would be optimal for women and healthcare providers to remove the variability and inequity of abortion access that currently exists in Australia. Although several states and territories have modified abortion legislation in recent decades, New South Wales and Queensland have not done so, resulting in the potential for abortion access difficulty and legal confusion.8 Even for those jurisdictions where legislation has been altered, there is substantial variation in abortion provision, particularly for the more advanced gestation cases.9 Although terminations of pregnancy beyond 20-weeks' gestation comprise <1% of abortions, they may be ethically challenging and generate a diverse range of opinions in communities. Typically, pregnancy terminations >20-weeks' gestation are performed for major fetal malformations or severe maternal physical or mental disorders.10 Access to late termination facilities in Australia depends largely upon where a woman resides rather than the indication for the procedure: it is inexplicable that a woman in Victoria can access termination for a fetal malformation in circumstances that a woman in Western Australia may not, solely due to differences in abortion law and not necessarily the fetal abnormality for which the request arose. This causes additional emotional (and fiscal) distress to the woman and her family, in a situation already beset by high stress levels. Women with the financial capacity can (and do) travel to Victoria for termination from other states in Australia – the legislation in the other states does not prevent late abortion from occurring; it just penalises socially and financially disadvantaged women from equitable access when pregnancy termination is an option for them. Although politicians may wish to avoid engaging in the difficult area of abortion, it is clearly time for some uniformity of abortion legislation and provision in Australia. Such a significant legislative change to abortion practice will require medical and political champions to effect this alteration, but the personal criticism that inevitably follows those who support abortion reform will understandably deter many.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Jan E. Dickinson (2015) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: