Stability of Enteroviruses on Toys Commonly Found in Kindergartens

Hand, foot, and mouth disease (HFMD) is a contagious childhood disease caused by enteroviruses including enterovirus A71 (EV-A71), coxsackievirus A6 (CV-A6) and CV-A16 transmitted via direct and indirect contact. Different types of toy surfaces can affect the stability of viruses. Understanding the stability of enteroviruses on toys provides insightful data for effective disinfection in kindergartens or homes. Porous (ethylene-vinyl acetate mat foam, paper, pinewood, polyester fabric, and squishy polyurethane foam) and non-porous (acrylonitrile butadiene styrene plastic and stainless-steel coin) surfaces were inoculated with EV-A71 at 4, 24, and 35C, and coxsackieviruses at 24C. Infectious enteroviruses were recovered and titred in median tissue culture infectious dose assay (TCID 50 ). Atomic force microscopy (AFM) images were taken from surfaces to examine association of surface roughness with virus stability. Overall, infectious enteroviruses were persistent on all non-porous and porous surfaces. Virus persistence was longest at 4C followed by 24C and 35C. EV-A71 half-lives ranged between 6.4-12.8 hours at 4C, 2.4-6.7 hours at 24C, and 0.13-2.7 hours at 35C. At lower virus titres exposed to 24C, half-lives of enteroviruses ranged from 0.1-1.4 hours. Surface roughness values from AFM suggested smooth surfaces of non-porous surfaces were associated with better virus stability. Temperature, enterovirus concentration, and type of surface affected persistence and stability of enteroviruses. Our findings suggest both porous and non-porous surfaces in kindergartens allow enterovirus persistence and should be frequently disinfected to curb HFMD outbreaks in kindergartens.