Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
DO ISOLATED MEMBRANES AND PURIFIED VESICLES PUMP SODIUM? A CRITICAL REVIEW AND REINTERPRETATION* GILBERT N. UNGf and WILLIAM NEGENDANKt I. Background: The Membrane-Pump Theory Since the discovery that cells are the basic units oflife, there have been two different general viewpoints about the physical state of the living cell: the membrane theory and the bulk-phase theories. The fundamental assumption ofthe membrane theory is that the interior ofthe cell and of its organelles is essentially a dilute aqueous solution in which ions are dissolved much as they are in a Ringer's solution; hence, the discontinuity of the cell from its environment depends on a structural barrier , the plasma membrane. The fundamental assumption of the bulkphase theories is that the physical state of the water and solutes within the cell is not that of a dilute aqueous solution; the discontinuity between the cell and its environment reflects a general property of the entire cell substance. Several observations led, in the 1930s, to the ascendance of the membrane theory and, simultaneously, to the near-extinction of the bulk- *Editor's Note: From its inception Perspectives has sought and occasionally published controversial papers. This essay by Ling and Negendank seems destined to be one of these, or at least to express a minority view concerning the sodium pump. The Na-K pump is an important hypothesis which is supported with more or less strength by countless experiments . Ling has been one of the few interested scientists to withhold approval of the "pump" concept. This essay performs a valuable service by keeping before us the assumptions we make in formulating a hypothesis but tend to forget with time. We are reminded that the pump cannot be magic but must follow the same physical laws as other matter. We do not understand the pump at the molecular level. This article is published as a stimulus to the careful reexamination of the role of pumps. Perspectives welcomes and wishes to publish good humored notes or letters written in response to the Ling-Negendank position.—RLL •(¦Department of Molecular Biology, Pennsylvania Hospital, Eighth and Spruce Streets, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania 19107. Supported by NIH grants 2-ROl-CA16301-03 and 2-ROl-GMl 1422-13 and by Office of Naval Research contract N0014-71-C-0178. $Hematology-Oncology Section, Department of Medicine, Hospital of University of Pennsylvania and Philadelphia VA Hospital, Thirty-fourth and Spruce Streets, Philadelphia , Pennsylvania 19104. Supported by the Veterans Administration Medical Research Service and by Office of Naval Research contract N00014-76-C-1166.© 1980 by The University of Chicago. 0031-5982/80/2302-0142$01.00 Perspectives in Biology and Medicine ¦ Winter 1980 | 215 phase or, as it was then called, the "colloid" concept [1, 2]. These included (a) the approximate equality of total concentration of ions, expressed as millimoles per liter of cell water, with that of the external incubation medium; and (b) the swelling and shrinking of cells as if they were behaving as true osmometers, when placed in a medium containing poorly penetrating solutes. The old, and most fundamental, observation—that cells maintain markedly asymmetric ion concentration gradients between themselves and the external medium—was then explained by a combination of membrane impermeability (as to Na+, keeping cell Na+ low), and a Donnan equilibrium (as to K+, keeping cell K+ high). This concept was formalized by the theory of Boyle and Conway [3]. This relatively settled state of affairs did not last long and was thrown into turmoil by the observation of Heppel [4] and of Steinbach [5] that Na+ does in fact readily enter and leave the cell. With both absolute membrane impermeability and a Donnan equilibrium refuted, there was only one way left that cells could maintain an asymmetric concentration of Na+ between two dilute aqueous solutions—Na+ had to be pumped out continually to make up for its steady leaking down its apparent electrochemical gradient into the cell [6, 7]. Pumping would require an exogenous source of free energy, and the process by which the stable asymmetric low concentration of cell Na+ was maintained was called "active transport." This modified version of the membrane theory gained support from the discovery of what was thought to be...
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Ung et al. (1980) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: