Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Methodological framework proposes a five-tiered model of computational reproducibility in scientific workflows, highlighting contextual trade-offs over rigid standards.
Computational reproducibility is often presented as an all-or-nothing requirement: either an analysis is reproducible, or it is not. In everyday research, however, reproducibility is usually a matter of degree. Projects move from ad-hoc exploration, through partial documentation and scripted workflows, towards portable, automated, and archived computational processes. Researchers need language that helps them recognise this progression without turning reproducibility into a punitive checklist or a contest of tools. We propose Reproducibility Levels in Practice, a five-level framework for describing computational reproducibility in research workflows. The levels are: Level 1, Ephemeral Work; Level 2, Carpe Diem; Level 3, Sweet Spot; Level 4, Assembly Line; and Level 5, Nirvana. Each level describes a recognisable pattern of practice, including typical artefacts, benefits, risks, and practical next steps. The framework is intended for self-assessment, teaching, project planning, and discussion among researchers, research software engineers, data stewards, and collaborators. The central argument is that "reproducible enough" depends on context: the scale of the analysis, the expected lifespan of the project, the number and distance of collaborators, and the consequences of error. Rather than treating lower levels as failures, the framework treats them as starting points for improvement. A levels-based view can make reproducibility more approachable, more actionable, and more honest about the trade-offs involved in real research practice. The framework is maintained as a living GitHub project, with selected releases archived in Zenodo to provide stable, citable snapshots. This arrangement allows the framework to evolve without obscuring which version a reader used. This manuscript describes framework version v1.0.1.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Gerber et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: