This EACTS clinical statement provides comprehensive structural and operational guidelines for modern adult cardiac surgical units.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
May drive centralization of low-volume cardiac units; extends volume-outcome evidence into EACTS structural standards.
In recent years, new cardiac surgical procedures have been developed and quality standards have been implemented resulting in a significant improvement in surgical outcomes [1–5]. National associations have recognized the need to update the definition and specifications standards for core requirements of a cardiac surgical unit [6]. The European Association for Cardio-Thoracic Surgery (EACTS) has produced this clinical statement to summarize and update current guidance on the design of a modern cardiac surgical unit. This document provides guidance to be used by health care professionals, chief executives and medical directors for the design of successful programmes for the surgical treatment of acquired adult cardiothoracic conditions. The design of specialist units for paediatric cardiac surgery, adult congenital cardiac surgery and cardiac transplantation is beyond the scope of this document. Adult cardiac surgery should be provided in specialized bespoke units with dedicated facilities to provide high-quality care for patients undergoing heart operations. The appropriate care of patients considered for cardiac surgical procedures is usually planned in dedicated multidisciplinary ‘heart teams’. Surgical assessment, counselling and consenting to the proposed surgical procedures and follow-up of postoperative patients take place in dedicated outpatient clinics. In some cases, preoperative assessment and consent occur as a one-stage process when the patient is admitted to a ward prior to surgical intervention. Outpatient departments should be housed in suitable and easily accessible venues with the necessary medical and technical equipment including nearby X-ray, electrocardiogram and echocardiography facilities. Provision of adequate specialist nursing and medical cover should be available at the time of consultation. A cardiac surgical unit should have dedicated cardiac surgical wards with resident surgical staff and a minimum number of beds to accommodate the volume and case-mix of clinical practice of the department [1] for patients in all phases of preoperative and postoperative treatment. Given the nature of heart surgery and its possible cardiovascular and respiratory complications, the ward should have all facilities to monitor electrocardiogram, blood pressure and oxygen saturation at the bedside. Patients undergoing cardiac surgery recover in intensive care units (ICUs)/critical care units. The level of care required is classified as listed in Table 1 [7]. The ICU should be able to provide all levels of care. Levels of postoperative care following cardiac surgery [8] Levels of postoperative care following cardiac surgery [8] ICU (dedicated or multidisciplinary) should be equipped with facilities to care for the need to support cardiovascular including mechanical circulatory support, respiratory, renal systems (renal replacement therapy) and with nursing and physician multidisciplinary skills. ICU should be equipped and have trained personnel to deal with resuscitation of cardiac arrest following cardiac surgery, including the need for emergency surgical re-exploration [8]. Normally patients recovering from heart surgery are cared for in critical care units until their required level of care is 1 (intermediate care unit) or is 0 at which point they are transferred to a dedicated cardiac surgical ward. It is desirable for cardiac surgical units to have an area commonly referred to as ‘intermediate’ ward for patients requiring level 1 care. This approach would reduce ICU stay and possibly reduce readmissions to ICU. The intermediate ward approach provides opportunities for continuous training and maintenance of skills for nurses and practitioners from the ward area. Elective, urgent and emergency cardiac surgery must take place in dedicated operating rooms. The operating rooms should have basic facilities that keep up with technical progress and scientific knowledge and must be suitable for the use of heart lung machine, extracorporeal circulatory support equipment (e.g. extracorporeal membrane oxygenation, extracorporeal life support and ventricular assist device), trans-oesophageal echocardiography, X-ray and imaging equipment. The measures for infection prevention and control must conform to local, regional or national guidelines and law on infection prevention. There should be a minimum of two dedicated operative rooms for cardiac surgery in each department to accommodate sufficient volume of elective and urgent procedures and support emergency and out of hours activity. Current developments suggest that ‘hybrid’ operating rooms, where combined imaging and surgical equipment can be used simultaneously, should be considered when performing procedures such as transcatheter aortic valve implantation, thoracic endovascular aortic repair, mitral percutaneous and other emerging procedures that require multidisciplinary teams to work simultaneously (cardiac surgeons, cardiologists and radiologists). The majority of cardiac operations require the use of the heart–lung machine (cardiopulmonary bypass) and also facilities to use mechanical circulatory support devices. These are cared for by a dedicated clinical perfusion team [9] and stored in a clinical perfusion unit. The clinical perfusion unit must be in close proximity to the operating rooms and should be accommodated in an area to enable preparation and postoperative maintenance of the heart–lung machines (storage, preparation and priming, disposal and maintenance), mechanical circulatory support systems, cell savers, intra-aortic balloon pumps, extracorporeal life support, extracorporeal membrane oxygenation and ventricular assist device) and organ replacement equipment (haemofiltration and haemodialysis). Suitable storage areas with sufficient capacity should be available. Haematology, biochemistry, microbiology and blood transfusion services should be available with rapid access and 24 h/day, 7 days/week and 365 days/year for cardiac surgery. There should be a point of care laboratory in or near the operating room for the measurement of blood gases, electrolytes, haemoglobin, anticoagulation (including thromboelastography or thromboelestometry) and availability of blood products with rapid access [10, 11]. There should be immediate access to X-ray facilities, computerized axial tomography and cardiology catheterization laboratory. Dedicated echocardiography equipment including trans-oesophageal echocardiography should be immediately available in the operating suite and in the postoperative care areas. Echocardiography services should be delivered by personnel trained to National/International echocardiography society accreditation standards available 24 h/day, 7 days/week and 365 days/year through an appropriate on-call service. For specialist units performing valve repair surgery 3D echo facilities should be available. Access to respiratory function measurements is required for patients undergoing cardiac surgery. Physiotherapy services to provide pre- and postoperative care should be available. Medical physics or suitably qualified technicians are required to maintain, calibrate and repair anaesthetic machines, mechanical ventilators, monitors, infusion pumps, heart–lung machines and all other equipment regularly used in the care of cardiac surgical patients. Cardiac surgery is a specialist area of medicine and surgery. The care of patients undergoing cardiac surgery is delivered by multidisciplinary teams suitably trained and accredited in the specialty. Surgical teams are headed by experienced and practising surgeons (senior specialists) with appropriate nationally recognized training and accreditation qualifications. A minimum number of senior specialist cardiac surgeons is required to provide a full time elective and emergency out of hours service. The surgical teams also consist of medical staff or trainees in the specialty and/or qualified staff grade level specialists, and specialist surgical care non-medical practitioners. Minimal staffing levels to provide a multitier including the senior specialist and/or equivalent grade 24-h 7 days/week, 365 days/year on-call service should be employed. Cardiac anaesthesia must be delivered by teams headed by dedicated cardiac senior anaesthetists with suitable training and accreditation in the specialty. Anaesthetic and intensivist teams also consist of medical staff trainees in the specialty and or qualified staff grade level specialists. Postoperative care on ICU should be delivered by fully trained cardiac surgeons, intensivists and/or anaesthetists. Minimal staffing levels to provide a multitier including the senior grade 24-h 7 days/week, 365 days/year on-call service should be employed [12]. The nursing personnel must consist of qualified accredited nurses organized in a shift system to provide 24-h 7 days/week, 365 days/year cover. In the ICU areas there should be nurses whom have undergone further training as specialist nurses for intensive care and anaesthesia. During each shift there should be a minimal number of senior and experience cardiothoracic nurses to provide a safe cover for all patients. The minimal number should be set by local, regional or national guidelines and should meet the level of care required by patients in the ICU [13, 14]. The clinical perfusion department should employ perfusionists with recognized national and/or international qualifications and available on a rota to cover 24 h, 7 days/week and 365 days/year. Hospitals delivering cardiac surgical care should have access through defined service level agreements to disciplines and services for consultation and treatment of patients suffering complications requiring the following disciplines: Cardiology including interventional cardiology General anaesthesiology General surgery Vascular surgery Radiology and interventional radiology Neurology and neurosurgery Gastroenterology Nephrology Infectious disease specialist Internal medicine and geriatrics Cardiac anaesthesia and surgery are carried out under intensive physiological patient monitoring. Monitoring should be done to meet the relevant recommended standards by anaesthetic, intensive care and clinical perfusion national international standards and guidelines [15]. Cardiac surgical units provide opportunities for training of medical and non-medical staff. Training should be encouraged, unit recognition for training standards should be sought from the relevant local, regional and national training regulatory bodies. The cardiac surgical unit should have provision to deliver an elective, urgent and emergency service for most aspects of adult cardiac-acquired surgical conditions. Surgical care must be provided continuously on a daily basis 52 weeks/year [16]. All units should have arrangements and infrastructure for eligible patients to be discussed in multidisciplinary meetings (Heart teams). Multidisciplinary care pathways should be defined and should reflect the cardiac surgical services provided. Care delivery should be designed according to existing clinical guidelines and through development of local multidisciplinary protocols of care. Protocols should cover care for the entire clinical pathway. Clear processes for care delivery should be defined and implemented. A mechanism of implementing, revising and updating such protocols and pathways should be available. Quality and reflective practice initiatives must be implemented including identification of relevant outcome and process measures, data collection and outcome monitoring systems, mortality and morbidity multidisciplinary meetings, near misses reporting, clinical incident reporting and risk management departmental and institutional protocols. Participation to local, regional, national and international outcome reporting and benchmarking initiatives improves the quality of care delivered and should be encouraged where not mandatory and must be implemented where mandatory. At any stage of the care pathway, there should be an identified responsible senior specialist for each patient. It is recognized that in many units this is the senior specialist in cardiac surgery. It is recognized that the viability of a cardiac surgical unit is not only depended on the facilities, processes and experience of its stuff but it is also influenced by the volume of activity performed. In general terms, best results are achieved more consistently by high-volume surgeons in high-volume units and the worse results by low-volume surgeons in low volume units [17]. The unit should perform a minimum of 500 cardiac surgical procedures per year or at least 70 cardiac surgical procedures per surgeon per year [16] in order to maintain sufficient experience and satisfactory clinical outcomes. It is understandable that local healthcare arrangements may dictate the existence of units with a smaller case load per year. However, these smaller units should have robust clinical governance, outcome monitoring arrangements and participate to regional or national public reporting initiatives where available [18]. EACTS considers that given the complexity of these procedures and their surgical ‘bailout’ if required, transcatheter aortic valve implantation, thoracic endovascular aortic repair, mitral percutaneous and other emerging procedures should be performed in cardiac surgical unit of larger size and/or those providing continuous 24 h day/7 day week surgical and cardiological care. It is recognized that new technologies and novel procedures, which have been approved by regulatory bodies have been proved to be safe and effective by clinical trials or by clinical evidence, are a vital part of practice to enhance the quality of patient care. Cardiac surgical units should develop and agree protocols for the safe implementation of these innovations including relevant mechanism for training and proctoring staff undertaking such procedures. Conflict of interest: none declared.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Pagano et al. (2016) conducted a review in Adult cardiothoracic conditions. EACTS clinical statement on adult cardiac surgery provision was evaluated. The EACTS clinical statement recommends that adult cardiac surgical units perform a minimum of 500 procedures per year or at least 70 procedures per surgeon annually to maintain satisfactory outcomes.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: