Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The insights gained from probabilistic risk assessment (PRA) models and risk-informed applications over the past 5 decades have provided significant benefits to the nuclear industry in terms of improved plant safety and operational efficiency. The successes achieved in plant safety risk management provide a strong motivation for expanding the use of risk-informed methods within the nuclear power industry. The U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission has supported this expansion as they strive to be a risk-informed, performance-based, and technology-neutral regulator.Nuclear power plant PRA models are based on the answers to three questions: What can go wrong? How likely is it? What are the consequences? Although many people have suggested using a similar risk triplet approach for assessing security risk, the second question (how likely is it) has been a roadblock. With respect to safety, likelihood is assessed based on the frequencies of initiating events and the probabilities of various equipment and human (operator action) failures. With respect to security, methods currently exist to estimate the probability of the plant protection system to mitigate an adversary attack prior to achieving the desired target set (i.e. security effectiveness modeling). However, there are no currently accepted methods for addressing the frequency of occurrence for an adversary attack (i.e. the equivalence of an initiating event frequency).Quantifying attack frequencies presents some unique challenges, and the methods that have previously been developed to quantify initiating event frequencies cannot be directly applied to an attack scenario. However, these challenges can be addressed in a meaningful and technically robust manner. Solving the difficult issues associated with quantifying attack likelihood will allow the nuclear industry to implement a risk-informed approach that is consistent with safety risk assessments. This will allow for risk-informed decision-making that holistically encompasses both safety and security.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
A 2025 study studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: