Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Background: Double-blind (practitioner–patient masking) studies were impossible to perform before the introduction of matched acupuncture needles. Their efficacy in conducting double-blind studies is not well known. Objective: To investigate whether patients' reactions during double-blind needle insertion reveal needle authenticity to the practitioner. Design, Setting, and Participants: Thirty healthy volunteers (24 men, 6 women) were needled with a pair of penetrating needles at bilateral TE 5 points. The study was conducted in Tokyo, Japan, in 2002. Main Outcome Measures: The practitioner, who was informed about the possible use of non-penetrating needles, guessed whether the needle was penetrating after each needle removal. He then provided clues to the needle's authenticity and rated his confidence in identification on a numerical rating scale (0–100). Results: Of the 60 penetrating needles, 16 (27%) were correctly identified and 44 (73%) were incorrectly identified by the practitioner. Most identifications were made based on the feeling experienced during needle insertion. Of the 11 needles identified only from the participants' reactions, 7 (6 correctly identified) were based on facial expressions (mean [SD] confidence, 40.0 [11.5]), while 4 (all correctly identified) were based on facial expressions and body movements (62.5 [17.1]). Most identifications based on the participants' reactions and the “feeling of needle insertion” were incorrect. In 1 case, bleeding after needle removal unblinded the needle. Conclusion: There was no significant identification of penetrating vs non-penetrating needles based on participant reactions.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Takakura et al. (2008) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: