Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Reliable estimates of field‐saturated soil hydraulic conductivity, K fs , are challenging because results may depend on the measurement method. In this investigation, K fs values obtained with the single‐ring pressure infiltrometer (PI) and bottomless bucket (BB) methods were compared across three agricultural sites (two sandy‐loam soils and one clay soil). At each site, 15 PI runs were performed using two consecutive ponding depths of water (5 and 10 cm) and 15 BB falling‐head runs were carried out with repeated declines in ponding depth from 10 to 1 cm. The PI data were analyzed using both the two‐ponding‐depth (TPD) and one‐ponding‐depth (OPD) approaches. The K fs values were predominantly log‐normally distributed, whereas the sorptive number α * was normally distributed. The estimated α * values were consistent with expectations based on soil texture (≈4.7 m −1 in the clay soil and 9.7–16.4 m −1 in the sandy‐loam soils). The mean K fs values differed by up to a factor of 1.2 in the two sandy‐loam soils (70–85 and 249–293 mm h −1 , respectively) and by 1.9 times in the clay soil (150–279 mm h −1 ). Coefficients of variation ranged from 27% to 130%, with the largest variability observed in the clay soil. Overall, the agreement between the PI and BB methods was satisfactory in sandy‐loam soils but less in the clay soil. Method‐dependent differences were more pronounced for K fs variability than for mean values. These results support the BB method as a practical option for high‐replication K fs surveys, while highlighting the need for careful application and data interpretation in fine‐textured soils.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Autovino et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: