Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Reviewed by: Japan on the Silk Road: Encounters and Perspectives of Politics and Culture in Eurasia ed. by Selçuk Esenbel Tamara Chin (bio) Japan on the Silk Road: Encounters and Perspectives of Politics and Culture in Eurasia. Edited by Selçuk Esenbel. Brill, Leiden, 2018. xvi, 373 pages. €114.00, cloth; €114.00, E-book. What falls under the category of the "Silk Road" has grown exponentially over recent decades. Institutes, books, and conferences dedicated to the Silk Road span a bafflingly wide range of topics and disciplines. The term "Silk Road" was coined by the German geographer Ferdinand von Richthofen (die Seidenstraße) in 1877 and only entered Japanese in the 1930s in various translations (including kodai kinu kaidō and, later, shiruku rōdo). Silk Road studies, such as it is, generally accommodates a division between the ancient Silk Road (the dominant topic) and modern Silk Road "rediscovery." Selçuk Esenbel's volume is the most exciting and self-reflexive contribution to date to the latter. It differs from existing scholarship by focusing on the modern Japanese (1868–1945) encounter with Eurasia. Esenbel defines the Silk Road as "the Central Eurasian geo-cultural space which extends from the Mediterranean coastline of the Near East to [End Page 419] the shores of East Asia" (p. 1). The contributors to this volume collectively adopt the term to "place the Japanese experience with this geography in a comparative framework of modern imperial trajectories that link to the history of Silk Road explorations" (p. 3). The beautifully illustrated chapters reveal the wealth of archival materials (in and beyond Japan) that document imperial Japan's diverse Pan-Asianist, Pan-Islamicist, imperialist, cosmopolitan, and Buddhist fantasies and collaborations in this region. Generations of Japanese military spies, antiquarian scholars, geographers, and artists left a legacy that shaped the subsequent global study of this Silk Road. As Esenbel points out, the influential postwar international UNESCO Silk Roads projects from the 1950s to the 1980s drew on this earlier body of Japanese scholarship, retroactively applying the term "Silk Road." For those of us who study the Silk Road from outside the Japan field, this is a revelatory contribution. It broadens our Europeans-in-China-centered understanding of Silk Road rediscovery that is dominated by the study of explorers such as Aurel Stein and Sven Hedin. By reattuning the reader to the significance of Japanese imperial ambitions and of the Japan-Ottoman axis, it reveals a more variegated modern politics of knowledge production—and fantasy—concerning the ancient and modern Silk Road. The 16 chapters are deeply heterogeneous in disciplinary method, depth of analysis, and cultural scope (joltingly so, unless one is reading a group of related chapters). They range from political history and biography to the bibliographic essay and literary analysis of individual works. Selçuk Esenbel's masterful editorial introduction is a must-read. It conceptually anchors the collection, introducing key dates, figures, themes, and the genealogy of Japan scholarship in the field. Modern Japan's interest in Eurasia began after the 1868 Meiji Restoration as part of the outwardlooking pursuit of "civilization and enlightenment" and empire. A decade after Prince Iwakura's 1871–73 mission to the West, Yoshida Masaharu undertook the first Expedition to the Islamic World (kaikyōtanken) in 1880–81. As outlined in Ian Nish's historical introduction, the "Great Game," the interimperial rivalry between Britain, Russia, and the Qing, primarily framed Japan's specific interest in the Middle East and Central Asia. Like the European powers, Japan began a tradition of military intelligence gathering in these regions. Richly detailed chapters by Sven Saaler, Selçuk Esenbel, and Hisao Komatsu illumine the surprising extent and significance of these intelligence networks, especially in helping Japan find Eurasian allies against its main foe, Russia, and in fostering Japanese Pan-Asianism. Saaler and Esenbel analyze the particular significance of Colonel Fukushima Yasumasa, who explored Central Asia, Inner Asia, the Middle East, and India and became governor of the Kwantung Leased Territory [End Page 420] in Southern Manchuria. Saaler introduces Fukushima as part of Japan's participation in the second "Age of Discovery" and adoption of the imperial and colonial ambitions of the European powers.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Tamara T. Chin (2019) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: