Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Summary25 studies examining the effects of housing laying hens in either conventional deep or in shallow cages are critically reviewed.In spite of wide variations in strains used, housing methods, stocking densities and information reported, a number of conclusions stood out. Hens in shallow cages mostly produced a greater egg mass (generally in the form of higher egg number), ate more food, added more body weight and sometimes showed a reduction in mortality.These changes were probably due to the increase in feeding space provided by the shallow cage, and it is suggested that shallow cages can ameliorate some of the adverse effects of crowding.If biological productivity were an index of welfare, then the increased output observed in shallow cages would be an indicator of improved welfare, a conclusion supported by the behavioural findings. Disturbance is reduced in shallow cages, while feeding activity is increased. There may be a beneficial effect on cannibalism and feather damage, and aggressive behaviour may be reduced, though there is little effect on fear.The implications of the effect of cage shape for welfare are discussed, and it was concluded that a move to shallow cages was unlikely to have any harmful effect on welfare, and might be beneficial, provided there was no concomitant reduction in space per bird. The major influence was the improved access to food.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
B. O. Hughes (1983) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: