Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Theoretical analysis demonstrates path dependence in chained price indexes and capital measurement, indicating that economic aggregates do not behave as physical state variables.
Economics speaks of a price level as of a water level, and of a stock of capital as of a quantity of wheat. This paper treats that language as a hypothesis and tests it. If a substance exists, its measure is a state variable; and a magnitude is a state variable only if every closed cycle is free. Two loops are then computed in full, by hand. A three-week promotion loop in which prices and purchases return exactly leaves a chained price index 37.5 per cent higher — the chain drift the statistical institutes measure every year, and which Hulten's 1973 theorem shows cannot be removed without a potential function. Samuelson's own 1966 reswitching example leaves a reversal that no change of numéraire can undo. The two failures share one witness, the loop that does not close, yet the two literatures never cite each other; the paper documents the near-misses and the tactical reasons the bridge was never built. It then proposes Carnot's gesture: not to correct the residue but to type it — an adjustable gauge on one floor, an irreducible sign on the other. Three refutable predictions follow.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Alain Claude Olivier Simon (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: