Key result
Percentage theatre utilisation showed no correlation with income generated or total number of cases performed in a dedicated urology theatre.
Observational (n=176)
No
Percentage theatre utilisation is not a reliable performance indicator for cost effectiveness and efficiency when used in isolation.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Theatre utilisation metrics warrant caution as sole efficiency indicators; cross-sectional data leaves open validation of better performance measures.
Objective: The current economic and political climate demands a focus on efficiency and productivity, whilst delivering quality, across all aspects of the National Health Service (NHS). Operative theatres act as a critical, yet costly resource. The Audit Commission employs the use of percentage theatre utilisation as a principal measure of NHS operating theatre service and efficiency performance. We analysed theatre utilisation data in a five-consultant, high turnover, urology department within a NHS University Teaching Hospital. Our aim was to examine the relationship between theatre utilisation data, cost effectiveness and income generated. Patients and methods: Data on the usage of a dedicated urology theatre was collected over 251 hours for a full calendar month. A total of 176 consecutive procedures were performed. Linear regression analysis was performed to assess the correlation between number of operating hours, cases per hour, utilisation percentages and income generated. Results: There was no correlation between percentage theatre utilisation and income ( R2=0.0191, p=0.82). No relationship was identified between percentage theatre utilisation and total number of cases performed ( R2=0.0001, p=0.99). Although there appeared to be a positive correlation between the number of cases performed and income generated, this was not statistically significant ( R2=0.725, p=0.067). Furthermore, there was no association between the number of cases performed per hour and income generated ( R2=0.3184, p=0.32). Conclusion: Our data identifies no correlation between percentage theatre utilisation, income generated and number of cases performed. Utilisation percentages are not a reliable performance indicator when used in isolation, and therefore should be used as part of a more global picture when assessing cost effectiveness and efficiency performance.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Modgil et al. (2013) conducted an observational in Urology procedures (n=176). Percentage theatre utilisation was evaluated on Correlation between percentage theatre utilisation and income generated (R2=0.0191, p=0.82). Percentage theatre utilisation showed no correlation with income generated or total number of cases performed in a dedicated urology theatre.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: