Key result
In-clinic ECG overestimated the 24-hour Holter average heart rate by 26 bpm in dogs with atrial fibrillation, though an ECG HR >155 bpm was useful for identifying fast AF.
Why the study?
Does in-clinic ECG-derived heart rate accurately predict at-home 24-hour Holter heart rate in dogs with atrial fibrillation?
Cross-Sectional (n=34)
Does in-clinic ECG-derived heart rate accurately predict at-home 24-hour Holter heart rate in dogs with atrial fibrillation?
In-clinic ECG overestimates 24-hour Holter heart rate in dogs with atrial fibrillation, but an ECG HR >155 bpm is highly specific for identifying fast atrial fibrillation requiring therapy.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Caution against sole reliance on in-clinic ECG for canine AF rate assessment; leaves open validation of ECG thresholds versus Holter.
OBJECTIVES: To determine if the in-clinic ECG-derived heart rate could predict the at-home Holter-derived 24-hour average heart rate (Holter24h ), and whether it is useful to identify slow versus fast atrial fibrillation in dogs. MATERIALS AND METHODS: 82 pairs of 1-minute ECGs and 24-hour Holter recordings were acquired in 34 dogs with atrial fibrillation. The initial 24-hour Holter was used to test if the ECG heart rate can identify dogs with "slow" versus "fast" atrial fibrillation based on a Holter24h threshold value of 140 bpm. RESULTS: ECG heart rate overestimated Holter24h by 26 bpm (95% CI: 3 bpm, 48 bpm; P < 0 · 015) with a 95% limit of agreement of -21 to 83 bpm. The in-clinic ECG-derived heart rate Ä155 bpm had a sensitivity of 73% and a specificity of 100% for identifying a Holter24h HR Ä140 bpm; an in-clinic ECG-derived HR <160 bpm had a sensitivity and specificity of 91% each. CLINICAL SIGNIFICANCE: In-clinic ECG assessment of heart rate in dogs with atrial fibrillation does not reliably predict the heart rate in their home environment. However, an in-clinic heart rate greater than 155 bpm is useful in identifying "fast" atrial fibrillation, allowing clinicians to stratify which case may benefit from antiarrhythmic therapy.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Gelzer et al. (2015) conducted a cross-sectional in Atrial fibrillation (n=34). In-clinic ECG-derived heart rate vs. At-home Holter-derived 24-hour average heart rate was evaluated on Difference between ECG heart rate and Holter24h heart rate (MD 26 bpm, 95% CI 3, 48, p=< 0.015). In-clinic ECG overestimated the 24-hour Holter average heart rate by 26 bpm in dogs with atrial fibrillation, though an ECG HR >155 bpm was useful for identifying fast AF.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: