Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The liberation from apartheid generated great expectations of change in the workplace and the labour market (Pons-Vignon and Anseeuw 2009). This was due to the key role of trade unions in overthrowing the system of minority rule, both as a political force and through successful undermining of the racist order which had been established in workplaces (Von Holdt 2003). Apartheid geography had ensured the racial separation of dwellings; encounters (often brutal) between people considered to belong to different racial groups took place mostly in what Marx calls ‘the hidden abode of production’. The forcible commodification of Southern African peasants into wage labourers (Bernstein 1994) entailed extreme violence; it was followed by the imposition of a migrant labour system and of colour bars across workplaces. In the absence of alternative sources of income, wage employment came to occupy a central place in the reproduction of most South Africans. Yet, alongside a record-breaking unemployment rate (standing close to 35%), more and more research points to the restoration of employer power post-1994, through the widespread use of outsourcing, entailing an explosion in casual employment (Buhlungu and Bezuidenhout 2008; PonsVignon forthcoming; Webster and Von Holdt 2005). The economically liberating stable employment most South Africans aspire to has therefore not materialised, but remains the overarching objective of progressive forces in which unions continue to play a leading role (Barchiesi 2011). Yet, reading the media or the reports produced by the International Monetary Fund (IMF), one could believe that the South African government has yielded to the dreaded sirens of populism, at least in the labour market. Rigid rules have allegedly been established, killing flexibility by over-protecting workers who are poorly skilled and over-unionised; a deadly mix which lies at the root of high unemployment and poverty (Klein 2012). Such arguments follow the South African (neo)liberal tradition, according to which the key to unlocking growth and reducing poverty would be to reform the labour market (making it ‘flexible’) and equip poor people with useful skills. Similar arguments were used in the early 1990s to dismiss the report of the Macro-Economic Research Group (MERG 1993) and debunked by Sender (1994). The new claims associated with this neoliberal perspective on the labour market suffer from serious empirical limitations, whether in attempts to point to ‘high’ wages as the cause of unemployment (Forslund 2013), or to claim that South
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Paola et al. (2013) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: