Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Loosely based on the demise of the Brook Farm utopian community (of which Hawthorne was briefly a member), Hawthorne’s The Blithedale Romance, published in 1852, is most often read as a critique of Transcendentalist ideas or of the various reform movements they inspired.1 According to these readings, the characters all hope to create a new and better world at Blithedale, but fail due to the baggage—consisting of personal history or temperament—that each brings to the utopian experiment. Despite the novel’s engagement with contemporary philosophies and social movements, critics have tended to overlook the more subtle ways in which Hawthorne’s historical moment informs the narrative.2 In particular, they have overlooked the imagery of air and breath, which is everywhere in the novel, from the moment the protagonist and narrator “puff[s] out a final whiff of cigar smoke” (12) and leaves his bachelor apartment in the city, to his final musings on the failed experiment, when he observes that the atmosphere around Zenobia had been “rendered poisonous” (219) by the breath that Westervelt mingled with hers. Paying attention to this imagery reveals a novel in which Hawthorne actively borrows from the language of the mid-nineteenth-century conversations about air quality and public health, part of an incipient environmental movement focused not on land conservation but on the dangers of urban pollution. Hawthorne recognizes the clean air movement’s underlying anxieties about the fact that air is something that all human beings ultimately must share—no one can completely separate him or herself from air breathed by others—and he weaves them into the depiction of all the novel’s characters, especially Coverdale, the protagonist and narrator.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Anne Pimlott Baker (2019) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: