Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The world-wide macroalgae industry has increased exponentially over the last 50 years (Fig. 1a,b). Between 2003 and 2012, its average annual growth was 8.13% in quantity and 6.84% in monetary value (Food & Agriculture Organization of the United Nations (FAO), 2014). Over 23 million tons of macroalgae (dry weight) were produced in 2012 from aquaculture, which were worth over six billion US$ (FAO, 2014). Approximately 83% of this biomass is produced for human consumption while the remainder is used as fertilizers, animal feed additives and, increasingly, for medical and biotechnological applications (McHugh, 2003). Seaweeds have a recognized, though barely tapped, potential for biotechnology and sustainable biofuel production (Mazarrasa et al., 2014). A more immediate expansion driver is, however, the prospect that seaweed farming can improve the sustainability of fish and shellfish aquaculture in integrated cultivation initiatives. With an annual growth of nearly 10%, fish farming is the world's most rapidly expanding food-producing sector and represents a major stake toward meeting soaring global demand for dietary proteins over the forthcoming decades (Duarte et al., 2009). Encouraged by these demands and efforts to reduce the over-exploitation of natural resources, seaweed farming has been expanding rapidly across several continents from south-eastern Asia down to South America and East Africa (Rebours et al., 2014). Though algae have been traditionally cultivated in Asia for centuries (Dillehay et al., 2008; Buchholz et al., 2012), selective breeding of macroalgae is a much more recent endeavour. China, in particular, has developed seaweed breeding programmes since the 1950s. For example, > 20 commercial varieties of the kelp Saccharina japonica have been developed, with improved yield, quality, disease resistance or stress tolerance (Zhang et al., 2007). However, the rapid expansion of the algal industry and a tendency to see it as a large ‘global crop’ (that shares identical or very similar seedling genetic background across many locations) is leading to the emergence of multiple inter-related concerns. First, seed quality is a major issue throughout the industry, mainly due to the widespread clonal propagation techniques (e.g. the carrageenophytes Eucheuma sp. and Kappaphycus sp.) or propagation via sexual reproduction from a limited pool of parent individuals (e.g. kelps, such as Undaria sp. or Saccharina sp.). The resulting phenotypic instability repeatedly leads to discard cultivars from the production lines shortly after their introduction (Shan et al., 2011). As detailed in Robinson et al. (2013), improving our understanding of the genetic resources and natural variation available in wild stocks (e.g. Voisin et al., 2005; Liu et al., 2012) is key to building more efficient, science-based breeding programmes, improve seed production systems and curb inbreeding. Throughout history, the commercial introduction of non-native organisms has contributed to the involuntary spread of alien species such as Undaria pinnatifida (wakame, Grizel & Heral, 1991; Voisin et al., 2005). In fact, many introduced macroalgae have become naturalized within a matter of years and, in some instances, raise concern with regard to their spread, such as Gracilaria salicornia and Kappaphycus alvarezii in India, Hawaii and East Africa (Conklin & Smith, 2005; Nelson et al., 2009; Halling et al., 2013). Non-native species incur huge environmental and economic damage (Pimentel et al., 2001). World-wide, marine ecosystems are already those most affected by biological invasions despite the existence of regulations that restrict the release of organisms in the open sea (e.g. Regulation no. 708/2007; no. 535/2008 and Regulation (EC) no. 506/2008 amending Annex IV to Council Regulation (EC) no. 708/2007). Containment and restoration measures are particularly difficult to deploy a posteriori in the marine environment and their cost was recently estimated at £40 million per year for the UK industries alone (Williams et al., 2010). Thus, existing and draft policies typically forbid or severely restrict the use of non-native genotypes in seaweed aquaculture. However, while slowing down the industry's growth, such restrictions are fundamentally inadequate to counter the risk of ‘crop-to-wild’ gene flow: even when native genotypes are cultivated, their capacity to cross-hybridize with native stocks may result in the introgression of crop genetic material into wild populations. Such gene swamping is now extensively documented in land agriculture and animal aquaculture (Manchester & Bullock, 2000; Jiang et al., 2012; Ellstrand et al., 2013) and is known to have profound consequences on the genetic structuring and evolution of wild populations. Ultimately, it also leads to an impoverishment of the genetic resources usable for selection and introgression of desirable traits into cultivated breeds. A factor potentially aggravating this issue is that the phenotypic traits typically sought after by breeders, in particular, easy reproduction and fast growth, might favour the spread of cultivated genotypes. Crop to wild gene flow is efficiently mitigated both in animal aquaculture and land-based agriculture by the sterilization of farmed individuals. For example, sterilization of cultivated Atlantic salmon has been recommended on these grounds as far back as 1991 (ICES, 1991). Unfortunately, the gene flow from seaweed breeds to wild stocks remains practically unmeasured, an essential step to inform future conservation initiatives. Although not yet widely available, sterilization technologies for seaweeds are scientifically within reach and should be considered to mitigate gene swamping and invasiveness. An additional benefit of developing sterile algal strains might be to offer a route towards the protection of the breeder's intellectual rights. The current over-reliance of the industry on genetically uniform genotypes increases the vulnerability of the cultivated species to abiotic stressors, pests and pathogens. The severity of laver red rot and ‘chytrid’ diseases, caused by oomycete pathogens Olpidiopsis porphyrae and Pythium porphyrae has been increasing as a result of farming intensification (Ding & Ma, 2005; Gachon et al., 2010; Fig. 1c). Recently, a dramatic decline in production has also been seen in many carrageenophytes (Kappaphycus) farming countries (e.g. the Philippines and Zanzibar). Such production deficits are mainly attributed to rising sea temperatures, which causes bleaching of the thallus, making the cultivated individuals more susceptible to viruses and bacteria from the genera Vibrio, Cytophaga, Pseudomonas, Pseudoalteromonas, Halomonas and Flavobacterium, as well as to diseases and epiphyte infestations, such as ‘goose-bumps’ caused by filamentous red algae of the genus Neosiphonia spp. (Vairappan et al., 2008; Hurtado et al., 2013; Fig. 1d–f). The protocols that are currently used to mitigate crop losses are rudimentary and often too costly for small farmers and cooperatives. Most involve the complete removal of seedlings, which requires the start of a new production cycle. This method is used in the Philippines and Malaysia, mainly to remove epiphytes from the carrageenophytes (Kappaphycus alvarezii and Eucheuma denticulatum). Chemical treatments can also be used, but are known to cause side effects on the final desired product (e.g. acid treatment on laver; Klochkova et al., 2012; Park & Kim, 2013). Moreover, in contrast to land-based agriculture, the nature and epidemiology of seaweed pathogens is dramatically understudied. Causative pathogens can sometimes be difficult to identify, partly because many remain uncultivable by current microbiological methods (Gachon et al., 2010). Previously unknown species or even groups are typically discovered when a new culture is being introduced, as shown by the recent description of the azoosporic chytrid pathogen Paraphysoderma sedebokerense (James et al., 2011). A third insidious long-term issue is the impact of pests on native stocks. Most are caused by the inadvertent introduction of non-native pathogens. In animal aquaculture, this is exemplified by the plague pathogen Aphanomyces astaci imported from America which now threatens native European crayfish with extinction (Longshaw, 2011). Farmed species can also act as a reservoir of parasites (e.g. sea lice infecting farmed salmons causing a decline of native fish stocks, Hutchings et al., 2012). Macroalgae cultivation holds great economic potential as well as the potential to increase the sustainability of fish farming practices through integrated systems. It also offers development and social alternatives in underprivileged coastal communities throughout the world, where over-fishing is often rife. However, history has repeatedly shown that intensive farming and domestication are accompanied by profound and often irreversible consequences on biodiversity. To guarantee the sustainability of algal cultivation, and its social acceptability as an environmentally sustainable activity, a coordinated effort in fundamental research is urgently required to assess genetic resources and develop adequate genetic conservation policies, that are, to date, nearly nonexistent. It is also important to start investigating the long-term environmental footprints of algal cultivation beyond immediate localized impacts such as decreased light, shifts in seawater temperature and nutrient availability. This is particularly true for seaweed cultivation in coastal ecosystems since a posteriori containment and disease management measures are both far more challenging and costly to implement, and far less efficient than the implementation of good practices regulated by science-based preventive policies.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Loureiro et al. (2015) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: