Key points are not available for this paper at this time.
Design
Editorial
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
This editorial debate piece argues that lactic acid remains the primary physicochemical contributor to exercise-induced metabolic acidosis, challenging alternative biochemical hypotheses.
POINT-COUNTERPOINTPoint:Counterpoint: Lactic acid is/is not the only physicochemical contributor to the acidosis of exerciseDieter Böning, and Norbert MaassenDieter Böning, and Norbert MaassenPublished Online:01 Jul 2008https://doi.org/10.1152/japplphysiol.00162.2008This is the final version - click for previous versionMoreSectionsPDF (47 KB)Download PDF ToolsExport citationAdd to favoritesGet permissionsTrack citations POINT: LACTIC ACID IS THE ONLY PHYSICOCHEMICAL CONTRIBUTOR TO THE ACIDOSIS OF EXERCISEto the editor: During intense exercise, pH markedly decreases in working muscle fibers, interstitial fluid, and blood. Here we consider not the effects of the rising Pco2 in muscles and venous blood but the nonrespiratory acidosis caused, according to traditional views, by lactic acid (HLa). Contributions by other organic acids, e. g., pyruvic acid (27), can be neglected. HLa dissociates nearly completely (pK 3.8), thus the total amount of added lactic acid is almost equal to that of lactate (La−; the sum of HLa and La− is here called La). If, however, a salt of HLa with a nonmetabolizable cation (e.g., Na+ La−) is introduced into the body, a nonrespiratory alkalosis develops (18) because La− is consumed and substituted by HCO3−.During hard exercise, anaerobic glycolysis is the source of energy for the synthesis of several hundred millimoles of ATP accompanied by La− production and H+ liberation. The amount of the latter is not directly measurable because it is mainly bound to buffers. Traditionally HLa is considered to be the end product of glycolysis: glucose → 2 HLa → 2 La− + 2 H+.This concept has been challenged by three hypotheses. ) La− and H+ are produced by independent pathways without quantitative relation.) Acidosis is mainly caused by changes in the strong ion difference (SID) in which La− is only one component.) More H+ than La− leave the working muscle and enter the extracellular space indicating the production of other acids.Regarding hypothesis 1, Robergs et al. (20) state that glycolysis produces La− and not HLa. Indeed H+ is only liberated when consuming the synthesized ATP (ATP4− + H2O → ADP3− + HPO42− + H+). The underlying physiological cause for acidosis is, however, that synthesis of ATP during glycolysis does not include the consumption of H+ (1,3-biphosphoglycerate4− + ADP3− → 3-phosphoglycerate3− + ATP4−).Strangely Robergs et al. are convinced that production of La− and H+ by different reactions is principally no synthesis of lactic acid. This principle would create a new law in chemistry. Both ions appear coincident in the cell and their effects are equal to those of adding HLa from outside. A similar case is the secretion of gastric juice: Cl− and H+ are secreted or produced by completely different reactions, but does anybody doubt that hydrochloric acid is present in the stomach?Furthermore there cannot be much quantitative difference between the outputs of La− and H+ ions since the produced ATP is immediately consumed for contraction. Robergs et al.,however, try to proof their hypothesis by demonstrating that the amounts of new La− and H+ are different depending on the source of glucose. Splitting of glucose entering the fiber from blood ends in the formation of 2 La−. Beginning with glycogen the process even consumes one H+ per molecule glucose. Robergs et al. conclude that there must be an alkalinizing effect of this pathway. But they do not consider that three instead of only two ATP per glucosyl unit are synthesized when starting with glycogen. The consumption of one additional ATP liberates one H+ ending again in two La− and two H+ (4). Later these authors (21, 22) suggested quantitative differences by partly splitting ADP to AMP and IMP despite resynthesis to ATP. But considering that several hundred millimoles La are produced during short intense exercise, whereas "muscle AMP and IMP increase to a sum total of ∼2 mmol/kg wet wt" (22), the loss of such a small amount of ATP cannot cause important differences between the amounts of La− and H+.An additional argument of Robergs et al. against lactic acid is that binding of H+ by intracellular buffers shall be much larger then the amount of La− present in the muscle fiber. But we (4) as well as Kemp (10) detected that their buffer values are too high, they do not correspond to the values in the cited sources. More contributions to this discussion have been published elsewhere (11, 13).Regarding hypothesis 2, Lindinger et al. (13) are convinced that SID (essentially [Na+ + K+ − Cl− − La−]), in which [La−] is only a part, determines [H+] in body fluids to a large extent. This concept is disputed in the physiological community (24). Lindinger et al. state explicitly that changes in SID cause changes in [H+]. But SID is a pure difference derived from a balance equation (electroneutrality equation). This is no chemical reaction equation determining the dissociation of an acid.However, there is no dispute that changes in SID are summary measures for the amount of added or subtracted strong acids and bases. During exercise acidosis, SID in the muscle is reduced additionally to the effect of increasing [La−] by a decrease of [K+] (12). This is, however, accompanied by a rise of [K+] in the extracellular fluid partly because of transport across membranes. Also Na+ and Cl− migrate between compartments; a water shift into the muscle dilutes all dissolved substances while concentrating them in the extracellular space. These changes cannot cause acidosis in muscle, extracellular fluid and blood at the same time because they cancel out. Only [La−] rises in all compartments.The SID concept is also not convincing because of methodical drawbacks [cumulative measurement errors, unknown ions (26)]. In blood changes of base excess (BE) are equivalent to changes of SID and much easier to determine. The concentrations of Na+, K+, and Cl− in the erythrocytes are not consistent in papers of the Lindinger group (e. g., Refs. 18 and 19) and differ (especially Na+ by a factor of 2–3) from values published over decades (5–8, 14, 15, 25). Since red blood cell concentrations are calculated from measurements in plasma (not deviating from usual values) and hemolyzed whole blood using the correct formula, there must exist methodical problems with determinations in hemolysates.Regarding hypothesis 3, it is long known that the decrease of actual BE (ABE, BE of whole blood) is larger after exercise than the increase of [La]blood. Corresponding differences were also observed when comparing arteriovenous differences (1, 9, 16). It has been concluded from these observations that more H+ (up to 75 %) than La− leave the muscle and enter the extracellular space. However, ABE is biased under in vivo conditions (e. g., Refs. 2, 23) because blood can interchange substances with the interstitial fluid. During acidosis HCO3− originating from the erythrocytes leaves the blood while Cl− is taken up. This explains nearly completely the difference between ABE and [La]blood changes after exercise (3). Cl− is a substitute for those La− ions that cannot enter the red blood cells because of the Donnan effect and therefore remain in the extracellular fluid.Medbö et al. (17) applied standard BE (SBE, common BE of blood and interstitial fluid) to avoid the effects of ion shifts, but unfortunately compared it with [La]blood and obtained a similar bias. When SBE is compared with estimated [La] in the same volume ([La]blood+interstitial fluid), the difference in the changes disappears nearly completely (3). There is no evidence for appreciable differences in La− and H+ transport across tissue cell membranes.Thus there remain no arguments for other acids or other mechanisms of acidification. Lactic acid is the essential cause for nonrespiratory acidosis of exercise.REFERENCES1 Bangsbo J, Juel C, Hellsten Y, Saltin B. Dissociation between lactate and proton exchange in muscle during intense exercise in man. J Physiol 504: 489–499, 1997.Crossref | PubMed | ISI | Google Scholar2 Böning D. The "in vivo" and "in vitro" CO2-equilibration curves of blood during acute hypercapnia and hypocapnia. II Theoretical considerations. Pflügers Arch 350: 213–222, 1974.Crossref | PubMed | ISI | Google Scholar3 Böning D, Klarholz C, Himmelsbach B, Hütler M, Maassen N. Causes of differences in exercise-induced changes of base excess and blood lactate. Eur J Appl Physiol 99: 163–171, 2007.Crossref | PubMed | ISI | Google Scholar4 Böning D, Strobel G, Beneke R, Maassen N. Lactic acid still remains the real cause of exercise-induced metabolic acidosis. Am J Physiol Regul Integr Comp Physiol 289: R902–R903, 2005.Link | ISI | Google Scholar5 Böning D, Tibes U, Schweigart U. Red cell hemoglobin, hydrogen ion and electrolyte concentrations during exercise in trained and untrained subjects. Eur J Appl Physiol 35: 243–249, 1976.Crossref | ISI | Google Scholar6 Dill DB, Talbott JH, Edward HT. Studies in muscular activity. VI Response of several individuals to a fixed task. J Physiol 69: 267–305, 1930.Crossref | Google Scholar7 Henderson LJ. Blood—A Study in General Physiology. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press, 1928.Google Scholar8 Juel C, Hellsten Y, Saltin B, Bangsbo J. Potassium fluxes in contracting human skeletal muscle and red blood cells. Am J Physiol Regul Integr Comp Physiol 276: R184–R188, 1999.Link | ISI | Google Scholar9 Juel C, Klarskov C, NJJ, Krustrup P, Mohr M, Bangsbo J. Effect of high-intensity intermittent training on lactate and H+ release from human skeletal muscle. Am J Physiol Endocrinol Metab 286: E245–E251, 2004.Link | ISI | Google Scholar10 Kemp G. Lactate accumulation, proton buffering, and pH change in ischemically exercising muscle. Am J Physiol Regul Integr Comp Physiol 289: R895–R901, 2005.Link | ISI | Google Scholar11 Kemp G, Böning D, Strobel G, Beneke R, Maassen N. Explaining pH change in exercising muscle: lactic acid, proton consumption, and buffering vs. strong ion difference. Am J Physiol Regul Integr Comp Physiol 291: R235–R237, 2006.Link | ISI | Google Scholar12 Kowalchuk JM, Heigenhauser GJ, Lindinger MI, Sutton JR, Jones NL. Factors influencing hydrogen ion concentration in muscle after intense exercise. J Appl Physiol 65: 2080–2089, 1988.Link | ISI | Google Scholar13 Lindinger MI, Kowalchuk JM, Heigenhauser GJ. Applying physicochemical principles to skeletal muscle acid-base status. Am J Physiol Regul Integr Comp Physiol 289: R891–R894, 2005.Link | ISI | Google Scholar14 Maassen N, Foerster M, Mairbäurl H. Red blood cells do not contribute to removal of K+ released from exhaustively working forearm muscle. J Appl Physiol 85: 326–332, 1998.Link | ISI | Google Scholar15 Mayer KD, Starkey BJ. Simpler flame photometric determination of erythrocyte sodium and potassium: the reference range for apparently healthy adults. Clin Chem 23: 275–278, 1977.ISI | Google Scholar16 Medbo JI, Hanem S, Noddeland H, Jebens E. Arterio-venous differences of blood acid-base status and plasma sodium caused by intense bicycling. Acta Physiol Scand 168: 311–326, 2000.Crossref | PubMed | Google Scholar17 Medbo JI, Sejersted OM. Acid-base and electrolyte balance after exhausting exercise in endurance-trained and sprint-trained subjects. Acta Physiol Scand 125: 97–109, 1985.Crossref | PubMed | Google Scholar18 Miller BF, Lindinger MI, Fattor JA, Jacobs KA, Leblanc PJ, Duong M, Heigenhauser GJ, Brooks GA. Hematological and acid-base changes in men during prolonged exercise with and without sodium-lactate infusion. J Appl Physiol 98: 856–865, 2005.Link | ISI | Google Scholar19 Putman CT, Jones NL, Heigenhauser GJ. Effects of short-term training on plasma acid-base balance during incremental exercise in man. J Physiol 550: 585–603, 2003.Crossref | ISI | Google Scholar20 Robergs RA, Ghiasvand F, Parker D. Biochemistry of exercise-induced metabolic acidosis. Am J Physiol Regul Integr Comp Physiol 287: R502–R516, 2004.Link | ISI | Google Scholar21 Robergs RA, Ghiasvand F, Parker D. Lingering construct of lactic acidosis. Am J Physiol Regul Integr Comp Physiol 289: R904–R910, 2005.Link | ISI | Google Scholar22 Robergs RA, Ghiasvand F, Parker D. The wandering argument favoring a lactic acidosis. Am J Physiol Regul Integr Comp Physiol 291: R238, 2006.Link | ISI | Google Scholar23 Siggaard-Andersen O. The Acid-Base Status of the Blood. Munksgaard, Copenhagen, 1974.Google Scholar24 Siggaard-Andersen O, Fogh-Andersen N. Base excess or buffer base (strong ion difference) as measure of a non-respiratory acid-base disturbance. Acta Anaesthesiol Scand Suppl 107: 123–128, 1995.Google Scholar25 Smith EK. Observations on the measurement and regulation of the sodium content of human erythrocytes. Clin Sci 42: 447–453, 1972.Crossref | ISI | Google Scholar26 Staempfli HR, Constable PD. Experimental determination of net protein charge and A(tot) and K(a) of nonvolatile buffers in human plasma. J Appl Physiol 95: 620–630, 2003.Link | ISI | Google Scholar27 Stellingwerff T, Leblanc PJ, Hollidge MG, Heigenhauser GJ, Spriet LL. Hyperoxia decreases muscle glycogenolysis, lactate production, and lactate efflux during steady-state exercise. Am J Physiol Endocrinol Metab 290: E1180–E1190, 2006.Link | ISI | Google Scholar Download PDF Previous Back to Top Next FiguresReferencesRelatedInformation Cited ByEgzersizde Asit-Baz Homeostazi Bir Geleneksel Derleme31 December 2022 | Ulusal Spor Bilimleri DergisiRegulation des Energiestoffwechsels des Muskels1 October 2022Time of VO2max Plateau and Post-Exercise Oxygen Consumption During Incremental Exercise Testing in Young Mountain Bike and Road Cyclists25 October 2018 | Physiological ResearchLactate metabolism: historical context, prior misinterpretations, and current understanding10 January 2018 | European Journal of Applied Physiology, Vol. 118, No. 4Relation between lactic acid and base excess during muscular exercise15 February 2018 | European Journal of Applied Physiology, Vol. 118, No. 4Reply to Robergs et al.Qi Qian12 December 2017 | Physiology, Vol. 33, No. 1Pulmonary Gas Exchange and Acid‐Base Balance During Exercise1 April 2013Cortical Activity during a Highly-Trained Resistance Exercise Movement Emphasizing Force, Power or Volume20 November 2012 | Brain Sciences, Vol. 2, No. 4Comments on Point:Counterpoint: Muscle lactate and H+ production do/do not have a 1:1 association in skeletal muscle1 May 2011 | Journal of Applied Physiology, Vol. 110, No. 5Point: Muscle lactate and H+ production do have a 1:1 association in skeletal muscleKalyan C. Vinnakota, and Martin J. Kushmerick1 May 2011 | Journal of Applied Physiology, Vol. 110, No. 5Studies of the Effect of Vinegar Ingestion after the Strenuous Wingate Test on Energy Substrates during Recovery PeriodsJournal of Life Science, Vol. 20, No. 9The Use of Lactate as a Biomarker1 September 2010 | Journal of Intensive Care Medicine, Vol. 25, No. 5Repeated or long-duration TASER® electronic control device exposures: acidemia and lack of respiration20 November 2009 | Forensic Science, Medicine, and Pathology, Vol. 6, No. 1Potential impact of metabolic acidosis on the fixed-acid Bohr effect in snapper (Pagrus auratus) following angling stressComparative Biochemistry and Physiology Part A: Molecular & Integrative Physiology, Vol. 154, No. 1Rebuttal from Drs. Lindinger and Heigenhauser1 July 2008 | Journal of Applied Physiology, Vol. 105, No. 1Last Word on Point:Counterpoint: Lactic acid is/is not the only physicochemical contributor to the acidosis of exerciseDieter Böning, and Norbert Maassen1 July 2008 | Journal of Applied Physiology, Vol. 105, No. 1Last Word on Point:Counterpoint: Lactate is/is not the only physicochemical contributor to the acidosis of exerciseMichael I. Lindinger, and George J. F. Heigenhauser1 July 2008 | Journal of Applied Physiology, Vol. 105, No. 1Lactic acid is/is not the only physicochemical contributor to the acidosis of exerciseE. S. Prakash1 July 2008 | Journal of Applied Physiology, Vol. 105, No. 1 More from this issue > Volume 105Issue 1July 2008Pages 358-359 Copyright & PermissionsCopyright © 2008 the American Physiological Societyhttps://doi.org/10.1152/japplphysiol.00162.2008PubMed18276903History Published online 1 July 2008 Published in print 1 July 2008 Metrics
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Böning et al. (2008) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: