Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
To the Editor: The concept of successful aging (SA) was conceived to acknowledge heterogeneity in aging, but after 50 years of study, no consensus definition has emerged.1 Researchers have posited many different definitions,1 as have older adults themselves,2 both with very different perspectives.3 Few studies have examined cross-cultural conceptualizations of SA in younger, European populations. Study participants aged 18 to 35 from Belgium, Estonia, Germany, the Netherlands, Romania, Switzerland, and Turkey were recruited using online snowball sampling (perpetuated through social networking sites) to complete the Successful Aging Questionnaire (SAQ),4 which was translated using independent, parallel back-translation into Dutch, Estonian, Flemish, German, Romanian, and Turkish. Study participants were asked to identify, on a 5-point scale (collapsed to important, neutral, not important) the degree to which they thought that teaching of the SAQ items was important to defining SA. Study participants (N = 393: Belgium, n = 32; Estonia, n = 96; Netherlands, n = 30; Germany, n = 78; Switzerland, n = 39; Romania, n = 47; Turkey, n = 71) were primarily female (56.5%, n = 222) and students (76.9%; n = 280) and had an average age of 24.1 ± 3.7; 47.1% (n = 185) were single, and 45.3% (n = 178) were in a committed relationship. Similar patterns were revealed in all countries. Regardless of country, respondents most commonly identified psychosocial components as of primary importance to SA (e.g., feeling good about myself, having friends and family who are there for me). The items deemed least important were primarily biomedical (e.g., living a very long time, having the kinds of genes that help me age well) (Table 1). Of the 20 SAQ items, 75% or more of respondents classified 17 as important, and 90% or more classified 10 as important. Respondents placed much less emphasis on biomedical components (e.g., remaining free of chronic disease, remaining in good health until close to death) and independence-related components (e.g., being able to take care of myself until close to death) than older sample populations (European,5 Latin American,5 Australian,6 Japanese,7 Japanese American,4 white American4). The older groups also placed greater importance on items that involved proximity to death (e.g., remaining in good health until close to death, being able to take care of myself until close to death). Longevity was the least important component of SA in all groups. The number of SAQ items that 75% or more and 90% or more of respondents deemed to be important was greatest in Latin American and older European samples, respectively.5 Young European respondents identified psychosocial aspects as particularly important to SA and placed less importance on biomedical components. This is in contrast to older groups from a number of different populations, who placed greater emphasis on biomedical components, especially those at the end of life.4-7 Data for the current study were collected using online convenience sampling, and therefore the results must be interpreted with caution. These results cannot be generalized across all populations of younger Europeans but rather they provide preliminary evidence that differences exist in the conceptualizations of SA in these understudied populations. The study was conducted across Europe, capturing the opinions of a diverse set of individuals, but despite the geographic and cultural spread of the respondents, similar trends emerged in all countries, highlighting psychosocial aspects of SA. These results have broad similarities with other sample populations, but provide some unique observations that differentiate these younger persons’ conceptualizations from those of older adults. For example, although older individuals tend to place much more emphasis on aspects concerning the end of life, these results suggest that this is not the case in younger individuals. Further research is required to examine whether these differing conceptualizations of SA of younger individuals is a pervasive and consistent theme over time.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Cosco et al. (2015) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: