Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The purpose of the investigation was to compare the results obtained by four methods of individual dietary survey: weighing, questioning, homely measures and chemical analysis.The work fell into two parts: a study in the National Children's Home, Harpenden, of the four methods under review, and a study of the diets of schoolchildren in Ealing by weighing and questioning.One of us (E.R.B.) was responsible for the field work of the inquiry, 'while two of us (C.G.D., J.K.) were responsible for the chemical analyses of the diets collected in the National Children's Home, Harpenden.The four methods of survey which were compared are described below.Weighing.In the precise weighing method, developed by McCance & Widdowson, the foods eaten are weighed in the home at meal times.The method has, for example, been used by them to study the diets of adult women, expectant mothers and children (Widdowson, 1936; Widdowson & McCance, 1936; Widdowson, 1947), and by Fowke (1945) to study adolescents.Questioning.In this method, developed by Wiehl(1942)) informants are questioned on the amount of food eaten in some previous period, which is usually 24 hr.although Wiehl has obtained z day dietary histories at a single interview.There have been several subsequent variations and developments of the method, but, broadly, the person making the survey is supplied with foods, such as loaves and slices of bread, cooked potatoes and milk, or with models or photographs of foods, with spoonsand cups of different capacities, and scales.The informant is interviewed in some convenient place, such as school or factory, and indicates the amounts of the several foods eaten during the period under examination.An interview takes about 10 min.Wiehl (1942, 1944) has used the method to study the diets of children aged 11-17 years and of men up to 60 years working in a factory; Chattaway, Happold & Happold (1946) to examine the diets of children aged 8-14 years; and Pyke (1945) to obtain data on the foods eaten by male and female industrial workers.Homely measures.The amounts of food eaten by the persons being studied are recorded in ordinary domestic units, such as cupfuls, spoonfuls, or sizes, weights and measures.Cups and spoons of a uniform size are sometimes provided, together with photographs or models of foods, with which the actual amounts eaten are compared.Youmans, Patton & Keon (1942) have used the method to study the diets of individuals of various ages, and Bransby & Wagner (1945) to study the diets of children.The information is recorded by the housewife in the home at meal times, not by the child whose diet is being studied.Chemical analysis.Duplicate portions are taken of the foods as they are served at meal times for chemical analysis.Because of the labour and difficulties involved, this method has been little used and only in small-scale surveys; forexample, to study the diets of hospital patients and nurses (King Edward's Hospital Fund for London, 1943).The duplicate portions are not taken by a child whose diet is being studied, but by his mother or an investigator.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Bransby et al. (1948) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: