Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The United States will experience a shortfall of as many as 86,000 physicians in 2036 if present trends continue.1 This workforce gap includes roughly 20,000 surgeons, and slow growth in the field of surgery has been identified as a barrier to ensuring access to health care in the future.1 The aging of the U.S. population contributes to this workforce gap, as does the uneven geographic distribution of surgeons.2 Urban settings have the greatest concentration of surgery residents and fellows, surgeons, and surgeon-scientists as well as the facilities where they train and work, including ambulatory surgery centers, hospitals, medical schools, and academic health systems.3 Rural and frontier areas, which constitute 80% of the country’s land mass, have greater unmet need but too few surgeons, health care facilities, and training programs.4 Changes in how U.S. physicians view and structure their work lives after the COVID-19 pandemic have made projections regarding the physician supply less certain, but it is clear that many communities will continue to struggle with health disparities due to physician shortages, including significant gaps in the surgeon workforce.5 This issue of Academic Medicine features several articles that focus on a variety of topics in surgery education and the surgery workforce in the United States. Defining the role, duties, and expectations of medical students on surgical subinternships is the topic of a Delphi-type study reported by Rhodin et al,6 which draws upon insights and guidance shared by 46 medical educators and trainees. Also with a focus on undergraduate medical education, the unique and potentially discouraging challenges for left-handed medical students related to their surgical experiences are explored in a qualitative research study by Gilbert et al.7 Following on this theme, the topic of handedness and its impact on a career in medicine are described in an excellent companion commentary by Sonnino and Sonnino,8 who provide practical guidance for surgery faculty working with medical students, residents, and fellows. Also appearing in this issue is an interesting article by Brown-Young et al9 with valuable recommendations on how to create an inclusive learning environment for medical students with physical disabilities, centering on the experience during her obstetrics-gynecology clerkship of a medical student who used a wheelchair. Gardner and Costa10 report on the potential utility in the resident selection process of the situational judgment test (SJT) by analyzing SJT scores and how they may relate to surgery residents’ subsequent performance with respect to milestones of the Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education. Perceptions of procedural autonomy reported by surgery residents and fellows are explored in a systematic review and meta-analysis by Lund et al.11 A handful of articles (16 of 2,714 articles) identified in the search examined differences in perspective based on gender, yielding initial evidence that women in surgery training perceive that they received less procedural autonomy than men did. As one unique example of progressive autonomy in the course of clinical training, White et al12 report on their qualitative project in which they gathered the views of 85 attending surgeons at 6 teaching hospitals regarding whether the responsibility for obtaining informed consent can properly be given over to residents, even with supervision. Obtaining informed consent is defined as a Core Entrustable Professional Activity (EPA) for Entering Residency recommended by the Association of American Medical Colleges.13 In a related commentary, Hafferty and Hamstra provide rich reflections on the importance of trust, role modeling, and attentiveness to EPAs in the context of the local culture and training environment.14 A novel study of the surgeon workforce is presented by Talbott et al,15 who describe their quantitative analysis of surgeons in 15 specialties who participate in the U.S. Medicare program. Surgeons who provide clinical care to individuals with Medicare represent an exceptionally important resource in serving elders and patients with chronic illnesses, and thus are vital to efforts to lessen health disparities. In this project, the authors revealed considerable variation in the supply of surgeons by location and subspecialty, with southern and western states of the country having the greatest need. Talbott et al noted, with concern, that surgeons appear to be leaving the Medicare program at the exact time when the population is aging and patient care needs are growing. Shortages of surgeons are further documented in the findings of a major report1 commissioned by the Association of American Medical Colleges, which was published in March 2024. This report focused on the adequacy of the overall physician workforce in the United States. With respect to the field of surgery, the report states: The supply of surgeons is projected to remain relatively unchanged over the next 15 years—despite modeled assumptions of more physicians being trained. Demand continues to grow, with projected demand exceeding projected supply under most scenarios modeled…. The projected shortage for 2036 is between 10,100 and 19,900 surgeons.1 This projection is lower than past estimates because of strong numbers of general surgeons who, according to the report, could stretch to manage many subspecialty clinical activities in response to patient need. The report’s analyses of physician shortages were proffered with two very important caveats. First, in the context of seeking to remedy health disparities, the authors commented that all of their projections are far too low, indicating significant need in most subspecialties they analyzed. To ensure equitable care across the entire country, they stated, the physician workforce overall must be greatly expanded. If communities historically underserved by our health care system had fewer access barriers, the nation would have needed approximately 117,100 to 202,800 more physicians as of 2021 to achieve comparable access for all. This is approximately three to six times the magnitude of current shortfall estimates.1 Such shortfall estimates are daunting, especially in light of the observation that underrepresentation in certain areas of medicine, including surgery subspecialties, has been identified by some medical students as negatively influencing their decision to choose these fields.16–18 Second, the modeling of population needs and physician supply has become far more complex in the post–COVID-19 era. To provide just a few examples: Over the past few years of recovery from the pandemic, the numbers of hospitals and hospital beds have decreased,19 the volume of surgical procedures has not fully recovered,20 health systems have merged,21 and outpatient and virtual care have expanded.22,23 Ambulatory surgery centers have grown dramatically as systems of care have evolved.24,25 Also, the U.S. Census shows that the number of individuals without health insurance has decreased to record low levels.26 Adequately responding to the accompanying challenges for the surgery workforce and surgery education will require greater sensitivity to such system-level changes. At the same time, adaptations across the health professions workforce have been dynamic. The numbers of graduates from MD-granting and DO-granting schools are growing, and more advanced-practice clinicians and physician assistants have assumed expanded roles. For physicians, the experience of the pandemic appears to have intensified factors that contribute not only to insufficient absolute numbers of doctors but also to the decline in their work effort, as measured by hours of work per week, month, and year. Along with their colleagues in medicine as well as in nursing, dentistry, and other fields,27,28 surgeons report significant emotional and physical exhaustion and the desire for greater work–life balance.29 In this post-pandemic period, many surgeons have chosen to serve in narrowed and part-time roles—which reduces the full-time equivalent surgery workforce—or to leave or retire from the field. The prolonged, highly demanding path of subspecialty surgery training offers challenges to medical students who value family and personal commitments that are beyond medicine.30,31 Finally, underrepresentation with respect to gender and race and ethnicity in the field of surgery is an obstacle for building a diverse and vibrant pipeline of future surgeons. Many millions of surgical procedures occur in the United States annually.32 With the aging of the population, the need for physicians, including specialist and subspecialist surgeons and surgeon-scientists, will rise significantly. At this point, there are clear indications that the supply will not meet this well-anticipated demand. Reshaping the health professions workforce can bridge this gap to some extent. With increasing numbers of students in MD-granting and DO-granting medical schools, there are opportunities to inspire interest in surgery training and to increase the supply of surgeons in the United States. Similarly, in the coming decades, it will be important to value, strengthen, and make more attractive career pathways that will build our capacity for the care of elders.33 Given the significance assigned to work–life balance by health professionals at all stages of their careers, especially post-pandemic, it is clear that new models for structuring the work of surgeons could be beneficial and, ideally, prevent early departures from the workforce. Taken together, these trends and opportunities should inspire genuine and sustained interest by members of the academic medicine community regarding how best to support our surgeon colleagues and surgery education.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Laura Weiss Roberts (2024) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: